Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you can not find what you are looking for please submit a records request.
Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESUBMITTAL
Permit Number - T13CM00547
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03/25/2013 | RONALD BROWN | COMMERCIAL IMPACT FEE | COMMERCIAL IMPACT FEE PROCESSING | Completed | |
| 03/25/2013 | RONALD BROWN | BUILDING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | SHEET A1.00 1. At detail 2, delete the width dimensions shown and provide a reference to the floor plan for accessible parking and asile width dimensions. SHEET A1.01 2. At detail 2, delete the width dimesions shown and reference detail 1/A1.00 for actual accessible parking width dimensions. DETAIL NUMBERS 2/A4.05, 4/A.18 AND 3/4.23, 1,2,3,and 4/A5.11 AND ANY OTHER TYPE "A" UNITS FLOOR PLANS 3. As per the 2006 IBC, Section 1107.6.2.1 "Apartment houses, monasteries and convents. Type A units and Type B units shall be provided in apartment houses, monasteries and convents in accordance with Sections 1107.6.2.1.1 and 1107.6.2.1.2. 1107.6.2.1.1 Type A units. In Group R-2 occupancies containing more than 20 dwelling units or sleeping units, at least 2 percent but not less than one of the units shall be a Type A unit. All units on a site shall be considered to determine the total number of units and the required number of Type A units. Type A units shall be dispersed among the various classes of units. Exceptions: 1. The number of Type A units is permitted to be reduced in accordance with Section 1107.7. 2. Existing structures on a site shall not contribute to the total number of units on a site. 1107.6.2.1.2 Type B units. Where there are four or more dwelling units or sleeping units intended to be occupied as a residence in a single structure, every dwelling unit and sleeping unit intended to be occupied as a residence shall be a Type B unit. Exception: The number of Type B units is permitted to be reduced in accordance with Section 1107.7." This translates to a requirement of 4 Type A" units and all the rest must be Type "B" units as per the the above inserted code requirment. As per the 2003 ICC A117.1, Sections 1003 for Type "A" and 1004 for Type "B" accessible requirements for each type are outlined. As per section 1003.11.9, Type "A" unit showers are to comply with Section 608 which requires roll in access, seats, special hardware and grab bars. Type "B" units as per Section 1004.11.2 need only to provide the reinforcement for accessible elements. Please revise all type "A" units to include all accessible requirements including clearances as per the 2003 ICC A 117.1, Section 1003. Also, please review all other "B" type units to insure that all accessible requiresment are as per Section 1004, including all clearances and wall reinforcements. 4. Elevation detail 17/A502 was not revised to the required water closet clearance of 5' to the edge of the lavatory. 5. Sheet A7.04 has not been removed. THE HUB STUDENT HOUSING PROJECT T13CM00547 STRUCTURAL COMMENTS 6. SHEETS S-1.06 AND S-1.07: THESE SHEETS ARE CLOUDED (DELTA 2) AS CHANGED, BUT NO CHANGES ARE INDICATED. CLARIFY. VERIFY THAT ALL SHEETS IN THE SET THAT HAVE BEEN REVISED ARE CLOUDED. 7. SHEET S-2.01a (GB1); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET MG40): THE REVISED CALCULATIONS INDICATE (14) #7 HORIZONTAL BARS EACH FACE FOR TORSION RESISTANCE, WHILE THE ELEVATION AT GB1 INDICATES #4 AT 6" HORIZONTAL EACH FACE. CLARIFY. 8. PREVIOUS COMMENT 55: THE LETTER REGARDING REQUESTED DEFERRED SUBMITTALS WAS NOT LOCATED WITH THIS SUBMITTAL. VERIFY. END OF RESUBMITTAL REVIEW |
| 04/02/2013 | KEN BROUILLETTE | FIRE | REVIEW | Denied | Fire Code Review: This review was conducted using the 2012 International Fire Code. Please provide a written response for each item. It is acceptable to add a note to the drawings or indicate where in the plans compliance is indicated. 1. Fire Command Center 129 is not correct size see 2012 IFC Section 508.1.3.-corrected 4-2-13 2. Sheet A10.05 Door Schedule-What column in schedule refers to hardware set description? Indicate hourly rated of all fire rated doors and glass.-Not Approved, A10.05 1st floor still not shown. 3. Sheet M-7.01 3 of 5 page and number 4 NFPA ? List editions and Standard numbers.-Accepted 4-2-13 4. Sheet G-1.04 Generator is required to be in 2 hour room-IFC 604.2.14.1-Accepted 4-2-13 5. Sheet G-0.02 General Notes. Incorrect codes add IFC 2012.-Accepted 4-2-13 6. Sheet G-1.04 Indicate proper exiting for "M" Occupancy. Look at the number of required exits for Retail 1 and 2.-Accepted 4-2-13 7. Sheet E-3.01 Missing Exit signage. It should match G-1.04 for egress paths.-Not Approved, E-3.01 still missing exit signs 8. Is generator going to be sized for all egress lights for 90 minutes duration or is the egress emergency lighting all going to have 90 minute batteries? Remember Generator needs to service several other life safety items including elevator.-Accepted 4-2-13 9. Sheet G.1.04- Please indicate the locations of the FSD/FD in all rated walls.-Not Approved, What pages? Did not find a mechanical schedule that helped. 10. Sheet G-1.04 Please indicate the Discernible path of egress per IFC 1014.2 for the exit path from corridor through S-2 occupancy.-Accepted 4-2-13 11. The fire pump room door 264-A is only 3 feet wide. The door should be wide enough to accommodate the largest piece of equipment. Please see IFC 901.4.6.-Accepted 4-2-13 12. Egress doors 120A and 121A please indicate what type of hardware is going to be used. 13. Please review IFC Section 317.1 Landscape Roofs for compliance.-Accepted 4-2-13 14. Please review IFC Section 308.1.4 Open-flame cooking devices. The trellis is made of combustible construction and a 10 foot separation is required from the cooking area. Not Approved, could not find note on A4.04 15. IFC Section 404 requires a Fire Safety and Evacuation Plan for Group R-2 College and University Buildings. Please indicate compliance will be provided.-Accepted 4-2-13 16. Submit the layout for the fire command center as required in IFC 508.1.4-Accepted 4-2-13 17. Indicate how compliance will be met for Emergency Responder Radio Coverage per Section 510.1.-Accepted 4-2-13 18. Indicate compliance with Section 604.2.14 for Standby Power for High-Rise Buildings.-Accepted 4-2-13 19. Indicate compliance with Automatic Smoke Detection per IFC 907.2.9.3 and 907.2.13.1.-Not Approved, TFD has investigated the proposed use of this building and it is our opinion that it is being advertised as a student housing project for the benefit of the University. Based on the 2012 IFC Commentary, we feel as the AHJ that we have the ability to enforce this section regardless of the ownership, but rather on the proposed use. 20. Indicate if a wired communication system will be used in lieu of compliance of Section 510 as allowed in Section 907.2.13.2.-Accepted 4-2-13 21. Indicate compliance with Section 914.3.1.2 for water supply to required fire pump.-Accepted 4-2-13 22. Indicate that the building will be supplied with an Automatic Wet Standpipe System per IFC Section 905.1 and have a connection on the landscaped roof areas per 905.3.8.-Accepted 4-2-13 23. Please indicate on which plan shows the location of Portable Fire Extinguishers as required in Section 906.-Accepted 4-2-13 |
| 04/03/2013 | ROBERT SHERRY | PLUMBING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | 1. Verify that the pressure balanced shower valves are listed as complying with ASSE 1016 or CSA B125. [Original comment: Provide shower and tub/shower control valves that comply with the requirements of Section 424.5, IPC 2006.] 2. Provide tempered water to the public lavatories through a device listed as conforming to ASSE 1070. [Original comment: Show how the temperature of the hot water supply to the public lavatories is controlled. Reference: Section 416.5, IPC 2006 and Section C404.3, IECC 2012.] 3. No working pressure notes for the water supply piping were found on sheet P1.02. Also, per ASME B31.9, type L drawn copper pipe (ASTM B-88), larger than 2-1/2" with 95-5 soldered joints has a pressure rating of about 150 PSI at 75 degrees Fahrenheit. [Original comment: Provide the specifications and the rated working pressure for the water supply piping to be used between the booster pumps and the pressure reducing valves. Reference: Section 605.3, IPC 2006.] 4. The booster pumps (i.e. DWBP-1) require a low-pressure cutoff. [Original comment: Provide a low-pressure cutoff for the booster pump per Section 606.5.5, IPC 2006.] 5. Provide the manufacturer's piping instructions for the boilers and include the storage tank in the detail. [Original comment: Clarify the piping diagram for the boilers: how does the cold water enter the boilers and how does the hot water recirculation system comply with Section 607.2.3, IPC 2006 or the manufacturer's instructions?] |
| 04/04/2013 | STEVE SHIELDS | ZONING | REVIEW | Denied | PDSD TRANSMITTAL FROM: Steve Shields Lead Planner PROJECT: The HUB T13CM00547 Building Plan (2nd Review) TRANSMITTAL DATE: April 4, 2013 1. The building plan has been reviewed by Zoning Review Section but cannot approve the plan until all zoning comments or concerns have been addressed. 2. Zoning has reviewed the building plans they appear to match the development package. 3. Due to the amount of comments from other PDSD review agencies Zoning will not stamp and approve the building plans at this time. 4. Zoning will re-review the building plan on the next submittal to insure compliance with the approved development plan. Additional comments may be forthcoming. If you have any questions about this transmittal, please contact me at Steve.Shields@tucsonaz.gov or (520) 837-4956 |
| 04/04/2013 | RAY MAJUTA | ELECTRICAL-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | T13CM00547 1011 N Tyndall The Hub. 1. Item #3 previous review, concerning areas that do not provide illumination as required per 110.26(D), for unit panels, not all were addressed, see Sheetts E4.05D, 4.05G, 4.09 and 4.11E. 2. Item #10 last review, requested a detail of Fire Pump Room on Sheet 2.02 showing clearances concerning equipment in room, only a note on sheet is provided indicating that Electrical Contractor and Fire Sprinkler Contractor to insure all NEC clearances maintained. This is insufficient, please provide a detail as requested. 3. Item #11 last review, requesting notation on Sheet E2.02 Electrical Room for doors to comply with 110.26(C).3, "panic bars, pressure plates or other devices " which allow doors to open under simple pressure. No response. 4. Item #12 last review, per 110.16, indicate on sheet E2.01, provide ARC Flash Warning in Electrical Room, no response. 5. Item #14 last review, Sheet E5.00, Panel 3A has a 400 A breaker feeding Panel 6P with only a 150 Amp feeder, no response. 6. Item #16 last review, Sheet E6.00, indicate on Panel Schedule 2H it's AIC value, no response. 7. Item #17 last review. Sheet E5.00, the 3000 Amp Residential Service is a 3 phase, the individual panels are single phase, show how 3 phase service to feed panels with single phase, show distribution of which phases to feed which panels (phases A,B----B,C-----AC), Note Per City of Tucson Submittal Requirements that phases are to be balanced within 15 percent of each other. No response. 8. Item #18 last review, NEC 700.27 requires systems overcurrent devices to be Selectively Coordinated with all supply overcurrent devices, how will this be done,no response. 9. Sheets E5.03 and E5.03, what does the Delta 1( clouding of various panels) indicate ? Ray T Majuta Electrical Plan Review DSD, Tucson 4/5/2013 Ray.Majuta@tucsonaz.gov |
| 04/04/2013 | ROBERT SHERRY | MECHANICAL-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | 1. The maximum ventilation rates shown for the parking garage are based on the 2012 IMC, not on the 2006 IMC which requires 1.5 CFM per square foot of parking garage. If you wish to use the 2006 IMC requirements, an appeal to the building official will be required. Under the 2012 IMC, nitrogen dioxide will be required in addition to the carbon monoxide detectors noted in the sequence of operation. [Original comment: Provide minimum ventilation rates for the parking garage per Section 404.2, IMC 2006.] 2. Correct the labeling of the dryer duct and the exhaust duct in residential unit 7B. [Original comment: Revise the enlarged mechanical plan for residential unit 7 so that EF-1 is not connecting to the dryer exhaust duct. Reference: Section 504.1, IMC 2006.] 3. Provide returns for rooms 106, 107, 108, and 109. [Original comment: Clarify the return air configuration for FC-101; the fan-coil unit appears to be located in a return air plenum. If so, remove the pressurized exhaust duct from the plenum. Reference: Section 601.4, IMC 2006.] |