Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Active
Review Details: FLOODPLAIN
Permit Number - T12OT01461
Review Name: FLOODPLAIN
Review Status: Active
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11/26/2012 | JASON GREEN | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Approved | DATE: November 26, 2012 SUBJECT: 833 E Freeman Pl- Addition Kitchen and Bath to an existing single-family residence TO: John Riggs, AIA REVIEWERS: Jason Green, CFM ACTIVITY: T12CM06248 (Site Plan) and T12OT01416 (Floodplain Use Permit) SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Planning & Development Services Department has received and reviewed the Site Plan (T12CM06248), Floodplain Use Permit (T12OT01416), Construction Cost Estimate and proposed Comparable Market Value for the addition to the existing structure for the above referenced property and does not recommend approval of the Site Plan or Floodplain Use Permit at this time. The subject property is located within a mapped Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA), Zone AE as shown on the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM), Community- Panel No. 040073-04019C-1689L; effective date July 16, 2011. Any improvements to the existing structure are considered a substantial improvement to an existing floodprone structure if the value of the new improvement is 50% or more than the assessed/appraised value of the existing structure. Please note that as per the Substantial Improvement & Substantial Damage Rule: A Guideline for Permitting, dated October 2003 only one 3-foot wide doorway may be provided between the common wall of the existing structure and the new improvement. If more than one 3-foot wide linking doorway is proposed for the new improvement, and/or the improvements are determined to be substantial, then the entire existing structure and improved portions of the structure must be brought into compliance by elevation of the floors 1-foot above the regulatory flood elevation. In order to help you permit the addition we will need the following information from you. 1) The Construction Proposal as submitted is acceptable for use to determine if the new improvement is considered a substantial/nonsubstantial improvement. This cost estimate however must be compared to an Appraisal prepared by a licensed appraiser. 2) Chapter 26.4.1: Provide an assessed or appraised value of the existing single family. The assessed or appraised value is for the structure only (excluding land value). The 2012 assessed value provided by the latest assessment rolls of the county assessor is $36,712 (Total Value of $56,480x 0.65(less land value)) 3) Chapter 26.2: The Comparable Market Analysis submitted does not meet the minimum qualifications of a Licensed Appraisal. Per the NFIP; Market value is defined as replacement cost less depreciation determined by an independent appraiser. The market value of a structure reflects its original quality, subsequent improvements, physical age of the building components, and current condition. The market value for the property can be different than that of the building itself. The value of developed property varies widely due to the desirability of its location. For the purposes of determining substantial improvement, market value pertains only to the structure in question, not the land, landscaping, or detached accessory structures on the property. Acceptable estimates of market value can be obtained from an independent appraisal by a professional appraiser, detailed estimates of the structure's actual cash value, property appraisals used for tax assessment purposes with an adjustment recommended by the tax appraiser to reflect market conditions, the value of building taken from the NFIP claims data. 4) Chapter 26.4.1: If the cost estimate provided exceeds the 50% threshold determined by the Appraisal then an Elevation Certificate prepared by an Arizona Registered Land Surveyor is required to determine the lowest finished floor elevation of the proposed enclosure and the single-family residence. The lowest finished floor must be a minimum of one foot above the computed 100-year water surface elevation of the SFHA Zone AE floodplain. 5) Cumulative values shall be accounted for in the building structure, so that tracking of the 50% status is current. No person shall repair or alter property in a piecemeal manner so as to avoid the provisions of Section 26-4.1.a.3, Chapter 26-Floodplain and Erosion Hazard Management. GENERAL COMMENTS: Please provide an appraised value of the structure from a licensed Appraiser that address the comments provided above. Include a comprehensive response letter addressing in detail responses to all of the above comments. If you have any questions, I can be reached at 837-4929. Jason Green, CFM Senior Engineer Associate Engineering Division Planning & Development Services |
| 11/26/2012 | JASON GREEN | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Approved | November 29, 2012 FLOODPLAIN USE PERMIT NO.: T12OT01461 ADDRESS: 833 E Freeman Pl Tucson, Arizona 85719 PROPERTY OWNER: Michael Flynn 833 E Freeman Pl Tucson, Arizona 85719 The applicant is authorized to use a portion of the FEMA Special Flood Hazard Area Zone AE floodplain per the Flood Insurance Rate Maps 04019C1689L, specifically described as: A portion of Parcel 113-04-2550, Freeman Lot 23 For the purpose of an addition (extending kitchen, adding bathroom, laundry room and family room) to an existing non-conforming building In reviewing this Floodplain Use Permit application for improvements to an existing floodprone structure, it has been concluded that the cumulative value of proposed improvements to this structure, as supported by documentation provided by the applicant, is less than 50% of the current value of the existing structure. The applicant agrees to comply with City of Tucson Floodplain and Erosion Hazard Area Regulations, and is bound by the conditions stated below. Violation of any of the conditions stated or referred to below, as determined by the City Engineer, shall be grounds for revocation of this permit. Responsibility for renewal of this permit, if necessary, is with the applicant. Issuance of this permit does not constitute a waiver of other requirements contained in the Tucson City Code, Land Use Code, or any other Federal, State, or local regulation. No use other than as permitted herein is allowed. Additional uses allowed under City of Tucson Floodplain and Erosion Hazard Regulations require application for, review and approval of an additional Floodplain Use Permit. This floodplain use permit is issued with the following 11 conditions: 1) All improvements proposed under this permit will be cumulative in percentage, to include this project. 2) The proposed improvements shall not impose conditions that would increase the flood damage potential to the combined proposed and existing building, by 50 percent or greater of the existing structure's value. 3) A cost estimate was submitted showing that the improvements are less than 50 % (estimate was 42.7%) of the Floodplain Insurance Declaration ($121,000) as reviewed and approved by Jim Vogelsberg, Floodplain Administrator. No person shall repair or alter property in a piecemeal manner so as to avoid the provisions of Section 26-4.1.a.3, Chapter 26-Tucson Code. The estimate will be recorded and if piecemeal permits for this construction are applied for the cost estimate will be added to it. 4) Except as approved by the City Engineer prior to the start of construction, development under this permit shall not obstruct, retard or divert the existing flow of floodwaters from or to adjacent properties. 5) This Floodplain Use Permit is issued concurrently with the improvement plans/permit. Copies of these documents shall be kept in a readily accessible location on site at all times. 6) Any future permanent, freestanding walls or other structures shall have separate floodplain use permit applications submitted to this office for review and approval. 7) An application/processing fee of $50.00 (submittal fee) must accompany each future request for work to be authorized under this floodplain use permit. Engineering study review fees of $150.00 may be imposed based upon the fee schedule in the current floodplain ordinance. 8) The associated improvements are with permit activity number T12CM06248. 9) The applicant attests to the fact that the plans and documents submitted represent all of the improvements that will be done to the existing building, and that all additions, improvements or repairs to the building are included in the construction plans and/or documents herewith. No other improvements, repairs, reconstruction, additions or remodeling have been made to the structure that is not indicated in the attached plans and/or documents. 10) Renewal of this permit will require a new application, review and approval of that application by the City of Tucson Planning & Development Services Department, Engineering Division. This permit may be renewed for up to one year at the sole discretion of the City Engineer or designated representatives. 11) This permit is specific to the improvements for 833 E Freeman Pl as indicated on the approved plans. It shall not apply to any other structure or property, whether attached or unattached, not specified under this permit. This Floodplain Use Permit will be automatically revoked and becomes invalid if conditions are not complied with, as set forth in this permit. APPLICANT NAME: John Riggs ADDRESS: 1344 E Renfrew Pl Tucson AZ 85719 PHONE: 520-319-5909 OWNER: Michael Flynn ADDRESS: 833 E Freeman Pl Tucson, Arizona 85719 (EXPIRATION DATE) Month: 11 Day: 29 Year: 2013 SIGNATURE OF APPLICANT DATE The applicant is authorized by the City Engineer to receive a floodplain use permit subject to the above referenced conditions and restrictions. |
Final Status
| Task End Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01/24/2013 | CPIERCE1 | APPROVAL SHELF | RECEIVED |