Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
Permit Number - T11SA00006
Review Name: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/06/2011 | DAVE MANN | FIRE | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 01/13/2011 | MATT FLICK | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Approved | No objection or adverse comment. |
| 01/14/2011 | JHERSHE1 | COMMUNITY PLANNING | REVIEW | Approved | Planning and Development Services Department Community Planning Section Board of Adjustment Case C10-11-01, First St. & Norris Ave. Resid. Development 2000 - 2008 E. First Street; R-2 zoning Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan and General Plan 1/14/11 jsh Need for Land Use Plan Compliance The project site is at the southeast corner of First Street and Norris Avenue, about one block east of the University of Arizona, in the Sam Hughes Neighborhood. Because the proposed density would be approximately 17 units per acre (6 units/0.35 acre), and the maximum allowed density in the R-2 zone per development designator "K" is 15 units per acre, the applicant is proposing to use the Flexible Lot Development option (FLD-6) option, which permits densities of up to 22 units per acre. In accordance with the Land Use Code (LUC) Section 3.6.1.4.A, FLD proposals need to conform with the General Plan and its components, including the Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan (SHNP). Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan Policy Summary A goal of the Land Use Policies is to maintain the quiet, single-family residential character of the neighborhood. Land Use Policy 1.1.9 requires that all Code-required parking be located on-site, and 1.1.10 recommends against the granting of parking variances. Policy 2 promotes preserving the unique diversity and character of the neighborhood's historic and architectural value. Policy 2.1 requires that the architectural design of new construction be compatible with, and complementary to the design of structures along the surrounding block frontage. Transportation Policy 5 promotes upgrading alleys in the neighborhood, for vehicular access and parking. General Plan Policy Summary Element 2, Supporting Policy 2.1 encourages housing … adjacent to regional activity centers to … minimize auto use and air pollution. Land Use Policy 3 protects established residential neighborhoods by supporting compatible development. Supporting Policy 3.4 supports urban character residential development (15 or more units/acre) along arterial streets or adjacent to community and regional activity centers and major employment sites. Policy 6.13 supports incentives for development in or adjacent to regional activity centers that will encourage infilling of vacant or underutilized parcels adjacent to activity nodes. Action 6.13.A is to consider incentives, including density bonuses and parking reductions, to expedite activity center infill. Element 4, Policy 5 promotes neighborhood identity and visual character. Supporting Policy 5.3 supports infill projects that reflect sensitivity to site and neighborhood conditions and adhere to relevant site and architectural design guidelines. Supporting Policy 5.5 promotes upgrades to neighborhood infrastructure, including sidewalks, and improvements to the existing housing stock. Policy 6 promotes quality in design for all new development. Variance Request and Plan Compliance Based on a review of development plan D10-0035, Planning and Development Services staff has determined that five variances to the Land Use Code (Code) will be required: 1. To allow an alley abutting an existing development to be used for parking access and maneuvering. Comment: SHNP Transportation Policy 5 supports the use of alleys for vehicular access and parking. The proposed variance is consistent with the plan policy direction. 2. To reduce the required number of vehicular parking spaces from 10 to 8. Comment: SHNP Land Use Policy 1.1.9 requires that all Code-required parking be provided onsite, and Policy 1.1.10 recommends against the granting of parking variances. The SHNP policies are clear with respect to providing Code-required parking onsite. However, the SHNP was adopted in 1985. Over the past few of years, to facilitate infill development, the Mayor and Council have directed staff to provide relief for parking requirements, and there have been Code amendments to that effect. Also, the site is adjacent to a major activity center, and General Plan policies encourage considering incentives, such as density bonuses and parking reductions, to expedite infill near activity centers (Element 2, Action 6.13A). Because the General Plan provides more current activity center policy direction than the SHNP, staff relies on General Plan policies in these cases. In summary, while the request for reduced parking isn't consistent with SHNP policies, it is consistent with more current General Plan policies, as well as recent Code amendments that have reduced parking to facilitate infill development, in accordance with Mayor and Council direction. 3. To reduce the setbacks of the two existing buildings on the east side (2006 and 2002 E. First Street). No comment. 4. To allow the required landscaping on the Norris Avenue frontage to be inside the existing wall rather than outside. No comment. 5. To allow the existing site walls to remain in the sight visibility triangle at the southwest corner of the site. No comment. F:\Sharedir\UPDfiles\DevRev\CASE_REVIEW|\BOA\2011\FirstNorris11311.doc |
| 01/18/2011 | JOSE ORTIZ | DOT TRAFFIC | REVIEW | Completed | TDOT-Traffic has no objections to allowing the existing development to continue using the alley for parking access maneuvering. This property is a corner lot and the existing parking maneuvering patterns do not impact adjacent parcels. The shortage of parking for this development can be absorbed by the public parking available along 1st Street. If you have any questions, I can be reached at 791-4259 x76730 or Jose.Ortiz@tucsonaz.gov |