Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you can not find what you are looking for please submit a records request.
Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESUBMITTAL
Permit Number - T11CM03707
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02/09/2012 | MARTIN BROWN | FIRE | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 02/10/2012 | RONALD BROWN | BUILDING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | RESUBMITTAL COMMENTS: Comment 4: In conversations with Mr. LeeRay Hanly, he had agreed to allow a 2' grab bar only if there was not sufficient wall space for a 3' grab bar. He also gave waiver for the 3' grab bar centering requirement as per section 604.5.2 so a 3' grab bar could be placed on those partitions having sufficient width for fit. The only toilet that clearly can not fit a 3' bar is toilet 30147. All the rest appear to have sufficient space for an off centered 3' grab bar. Please verify actual dimensional requirements and provide 3' wide grab bars where possible. Comment 6: Where may the structural engineer's confirmation for the additional equipment load be found? END OF REVIEW |
| 02/14/2012 | ROBERT SHERRY | MECHANICAL-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 02/14/2012 | ROBERT SHERRY | PLUMBING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | 1. Comment not resolved. Fractional fixtures are not allowed to be used when calculating the minimum number of fixtures; correct the calculations for the drinking fountains on sheet G-005. Reference: footnote a, Table 2902.1, IBC 2006.[Original comment: Provide calculations to show that the minimum plumbing facilities (i.e. drinking fountains) required by Table 2902.1, IBC 2006, for institutional occupancy, I-2, have been provided.] 2. Comment not resolved; correct the size of the water supplies to the water closet flush valves in detail 1/P401 from 1" to 1-1/4". [Original comment: The purpose of a waste and vent diagram is to clarify the installation of the fixtures and the piping. Enlarge detail 1/P-401 so that the detail is legible. Reference: Section 103.2.3, UPC 2006.] 3. Comment not resolved; both P-403 and P404 have sanitary waste riser diagrams for the 3rd floor with the primary difference being that the fixtures themselves are not shown on sheet P403. Sanitary waste riser diagrams for the 2nd floor are shown on sheet P402. [Original comment: Sheets P-403 and P-404 have identical waste and vent riser diagrams for the third floor; should P-404 be for the domestic water riser diagrams as referenced on sheet P-141.2?] 4. The revised note specifies a minimum water pressure of 15 PSI for flush valves with all other fixtures requiring a minimum pressure of 8 PSI. American Standard water closets (WC-4) require a minimum pressure of 20 PSI and drinking fountains, ice makers, and eyewashes typically require a minimum pressure of 30 PSI. [Original comment: Revise Plumbing General Note #10 to change the minimum water pressure to 15 PSI at outlets other than flush valves or at other fixtures or appliances that require water pressures higher than 15 PSI (e.g. drinking fountains, ice makers, eyewashes, etc.). Reference: Section 608.1, UPC 2006.] 5. The note has been changed to include storm drains as well as sanitary drains. Section 708.0 does not apply to storm drains, all of which may have a slope of 1/8" per foot is they are appropriately sized per Table 11-2, UPC 2006. Check the sizing of the horizontal storm drains to see if the changes have adversely affected them or modify the note to apply the requirements of Section 708.0 only to the sanitary drains. [Original comment: Revise Plumbing General Note #13 to change the slope of the horizontal drainage piping to comply with the requirements of Section 708.0, UPC 2006.] 6. Are we looking at the same drawings? I see no changes to the drawings in this set. [Original comment: Provide a vent for each fixture trap (see FD-1, near S-4 in detail 3/P-402.1, detail 8/P-402; detail 13/P-402; and details 11 and 12, P-403). Reference: Sections 901.0 and 910.1, UPC 2006.] 7. Are we looking at the same drawings? I see no changes to the drawings in this set. [Original comment: Each vent pipe shall rise vertically to a minimum of 6" above the flood-level rim of the fixture it serves before connecting to any other vent. (See detail 3/P-402.1). Reference: Section 905.3, UPC 2006.] |
| 03/12/2012 | DAVID RIVERA | ZONING | REVIEW | Approv-Cond | Zoning approves the building plans with conditions. As of this review the remaining comments do not affect zoning's review requirements. But, if the remaining comments require that changes be made to the cover sheet, floor plan or elevation sheets, Zoning will have to re-stamp the cover, floor plan or elevation sheets if they are replaced. |
| 03/14/2012 | RAY MAJUTA | ELECTRICAL-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | T11CM03707 Tucson Medical Hospital,West Wing 5303 E Grant Rd, The electrical plans have been denied for the following, please address each item and indicate how each was addressed. 1. The IECC Budget Lighting Calculations have been denied, provide the calculations in the form of a ComCheck report, you have provided values, how did you come about them ? 2. Throught the plans clouded areas are shown, indicate what has been changed,deleted or added as new. 3. Fault curren calculations have not been provide as requested last review, these are to be provided for on plans themselves not attachments.(Service thur to all panels). 4. E-211.2, the following ciruits are used ---- marked spares in panel, S1LLSA4,6 also S1-LA 2,4,6,8. 5. E-213.2------ "Sheet Keyed Notes" #1,2,3,4 indicate to connect to lighting to normal circuit, or Normal Life Safety, Critical Lighting circuits in existing areas, these need to be identified by # and panel. 6. E-214.2--- same as item #5. 7. E-221A3.2, entire sheet revised,indicate what changes were made. 8. E-221A4.2, this sheet appears to have revisions made to lighting plan , these should be incorporated to main lighting plan this floor. 9. E-222B1.2, revised changes to be made to main lighting plan this floor. 10. E-222B2.2, same as #9. 11. Please indiate on all sheets what was revised or why entire sheets have been revised, do not have a set of previous plans to check revisions. 12. E-231.2, following circuits S3LCBA-1,3,5,7,9,11,13,32 also S3LLSA-2,4, used this sheet marked spares in panels no loads shown. 13. E-232.2 followinf circuits used, marked spares no loads, S3LCBA 2,4,6,8,10,12,14,16,18,20,22,24,26,28, also S3LA-8,and S3LLBC-34. 14. E232B1.2, circuits S3LCBA 8,12,16 spares no loads. 15. 240.2 fixtures not circuited, no changes,circuits shown on 2 E241.2, why is this sheet provided ? 16. E241.2, circuits S4LA 1,3,5,7,9,13,15,17,19,2,4,6,8,12,14,16 also S4LCBA 1,3,5,7,9,13,15,19, spares in panel sccheduls no loads. 17. E311.2, S1PA 1,3,2,4,6,31,33,35 not in panel. 18. E313.2, identify circuits reconnecting to as per Keyed Notes 2,3,4,5. Circuits UCBC 26,28-----LICP 36,40,41,42 panel schedule not found. 19. E315.2, circuits S1PEQ 2,4,6,8,10 used panel schedule not found, Circuits SPPLSA 2,4,6,8,10,12 used panel not found. 20. E321.2, circuits S2PB---28,42, S2PC--27,29,31,30,32,34,24,25,26,28---S2PCBT-17,32,34,36,26,28,30,20,22,24,16,18,19,21,23,13,15,17,1,3,5 marked spares in panels no loads. 21. E321A1.2-- entire sheet revised appears to be like E321.2,same as E321A2.2,E321A3.2 and E321A4.2, can all of these changes be incorporated into E321.2 ? 22. E321B1.2, Circuits S2PCBN 34,36,38,40,42, spares in panel no loads. 23.E323.2 circuits S2PCBU 26, also S2PEBB 31,33,35,37,34,36, also S2PLSA 9,13,15,17,19,21,23,25,27,29,8,10,12,16,18,22,24,26,28,30, spares in panel no loads. 24. E323C3.2 circuits 13,15,17 used twice for diff items . Circuits S2PCBU 32,34 also S2P1 21,22 spares in panel no loads. 25. E322.2 circuits S3PB-28,30 also S3PC--29,31,33 spares in panel. Circuit S3PCBS 8,10,12, should be S3PCBU 8,10,12 ? Circuits S3PPLSA 8,10,16,18--- no panel ? 26. E331.2 circuits S3PLSA 2,4,6, also S3PCBQ-29,27 spares in pnl no loads. 27. E331A3.2 circuits S3PB 31,20,22,30,32, spares in panel,also S3PLSA 24,26,29,30 no panel schedule. 28. E332B1.2, circuits S3PCBB--36,38,40,42 spares, S3PCBK 39 spare in pnl. 29. Several of the panel index boxes are incorrect,some panels not on coresponding page,please correct. 30. E341.2 Panel S4PB is not shown,Panel S4PA is shown twice. 27.Panel S4PCPE not found 28. E342, circuit S4PCBD in pantry not identified, also S4PE in inpatient hab not identified, 29. E1110.2, What was revised ? circuits S1LA 2,4,6,8 also S1LLSA 46, also S2LA1-C2, also S3LCBA 1 thur 15, S3LA 1,4,10 not in panel schedules. 30. Sheets E1110.2 continuosly thur E1150.2 indicate "Entire Sheet Revised", indicate revisions. 31. E1200.1-- for total Service Load at time, indicate section of NEC used to calculate, follow requirements and provide all necessart data for calculation. Since this will be the first time loading for new switchgear provided, provide a load summary for the individual switchboards and distribution boards. 32. E1200.2 thur 1202.2, indicate how clouded items revised to indicate new sheet. 31. E1140.2, Panel Schedule S4LA appears to be Panell S3LA. Indicate on these set of plans, installation to comply with 2005 NEC 517, proper Ground Fault Protection has been provided as required per 2005 NEC 517. Provide an individual count for following ,1-- all fixtures (including exit and emergency), 2---receptacles (120v), 3---switches and occupency sensors used on these drawings. Ray T Majuta Electrical Plan Review PDSD, City of Tucson 3/15/12 Ray.majuta@tucsonaz.gov |