Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESUBMITTAL
Permit Number - T11CM01170
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 05/18/2011 | ELIZABETH EBERBACH | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Approved | SEE FLOODPLAIN USE PERMIT FOR SUBSTANTIAL IMPROVEMENT PAPERWORK. |
| 05/24/2011 | RONALD BROWN | BUILDING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | RESUBMITTAL IN ALL CAPS - 24 MAY 2011 GENERAL 1. On most all architectural and structural drawings, the depiction of the existing conditions and building is way too light and illegible. Please correct the line weight as per the mechanical and electrical drawings and resubmit. RESUBMITTAL COMMENT: LINE WEIGHT IS STILL TOO LIGHT. IT APPEARS THAT THE MECHANICAL DRAWINGS ARE EVEN LIGHTER THAN THE FIRST SUBMITTAL 2. Please provide 2 copies of the structural calculations. Only one set was submitted with this package. OK 3. There are two different sheets enumerated as "A-1". Please reconcile. OK SHEET C1 4. An effect of this addition is that it increases the occupancy load and size of the office space for which you're Certificate of Occupancy was issued. A new Certificate of Occupancy will need to be issued with all the new addition information included. Please provide the following information and additional detailing: a. A new occupancy load including the new addition, existing first floor and existing second floor breakdown and summary. OK b. Please provide a new EXIT plan including the new addition load and the second floor load. Please provide a second floor plan and its proposed exiting. OK c. Please recalculate the required number of plumbing fixtures based upon the new total occupant load; existing 1st floor load, addition load plus 2nd floor load. This includes w.c., urinals, lavs, drinking fountains and mop sinks. OK d. Please show all toilets located on the second level. OK 5. This is a two story building. Please correct the building data to reflect this fact. OK a. Please provide a breakdown of all square footages to show the second level OK b. Please provide an occupant load calculation breakdown showing the 2nd floor load. OK 6. Please correct the Applicable Codes accessible code to ICC (ANSI 117.1, 2003 Edition). OK SHEET A1 7. This sheet is not an approved site development plan and differs from the submitted site development plan in several areas of new and existing parking layout. Please provide an approved site development plan showing accurately the new addition, all concrete walkways and their slopes, landscaping and please clarify modifications and definition of and to the decorative wall. OK SHEET A1 8. Please remove the new room titles and numbers from the Demo Plan. OK 9. General roof plan note 1: The alternate methods of non-vented attic design are not applicable to commercial apartment projects. They were intended for residential use only. We apologize for any confusion caused as this reference was published on our web site. It is over 10 years old and is not longer relevant or applicable as changes in the code now address this situation. a. All attic venting for this project must comply with the requirements of the 2006 IBC, Section 1203. OK SHEET A2 10. As per the toilet details shown on sheet A-3, the new toilet room is identified as a Unisex Toilet. As per the 2006 IBC, Section 1109.2.1, Unisex Toilets are considered for mercantile and assembly occupancies only. If the existing toilet fixture count (including the second floor) meets the occupant load requirement, a unisex toilet might be approved in an appeal to the building official. OK 11. Clarify any modifications to decorative courtyard wall. OK 12. Please show all walkways and landscape area outside decorative wall and inside courtyard. NON-RESPONSIVE, PLEASE COMPLY AND RESUBMIT SHEET A-3 11. Please provide a large scale toilet floor plan showing all accessible dimensions, clearances and accessories. OK 12. Generic, typical toilet elevations are not acceptable. Please provide elevations of the exact toilet design showing all accessible dimensions, accessories and finishes. OK a. Please provide wall finish as required by the 2006 IBC, Section 1210.2. OK 13. At the "General Toilet Room - Mounting Height Notes" delete all references to ADA and clarify the 2006 IBC Chapter 11 and ICC (ANSI 117.1, 2003 Edition) for accessibility code compliance. OK 14. At the TYP PARTITION detail, clarify the bracing to the structure above. OK SHEET S2.1 15. Detail 16 calls for typical stud wall framing while page 11 of the calculations call for 600S162-33@16" o.c.. Please reconcile. OK 16. Detail 17 calls for typical stud wall framing while page 11 of the calculations call for 362S162-33@16" o.k.. Please reconcile. OK SHEET S3.1 17. Detail 4 calls for 362S162-33 studs to be at 24" o.c. while the calculations on page 11 calls for studs at 16" o.c. Please reconcile. OK 18. The calculations do not address the TJI calculations for the roof framing. OK END OF REVIEW |
| 05/25/2011 | DAVID RIVERA | ZONING | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 05/31/2011 | ROBERT SHERRY | MECHANICAL-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | Comment not resolved. Revise the submitted energy code compliance calculations for the building envelope using the correct climate zone for Pima County < 4,000 feet (i.e. not Pima, Arizona, which is a small town Northwest of Safford in Graham County). Revise the component entries in the calculations to correspond with the drawings: the steel-stud exterior walls do not have continuous R-21 insulation, the structural engineer will be shocked to learn that the other walls are solid concrete instead of concrete masonry units, the CMU walls do not have continuous R-21 insulation, and the addition includes a roof. [Original comment: Provide energy code compliance calculations for the building envelope (the correct climate zone is Pima County < 4,000 feet) and for the mechanical equipment. Provide sufficient detail on the drawings to evaluate the energy compliance of the building envelope. The information shall, as a minimum, include U-factors of the envelope systems and fenestration components, along with the SHGC for the fenestration. Reference: Sections 101.4 and 104.2, International Energy Conservation Code 2006.] |
| 05/31/2011 | ROBERT SHERRY | PLUMBING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Approved |
Final Status
| Task End Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 06/06/2011 | DELMA ROBEY | OUT TO CUSTOMER | Completed |