Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESIDENTIAL - BLDG/ZONING/ENGINE/WWM
Permit Number - T11CM00866
Review Name: RESIDENTIAL - BLDG/ZONING/ENGINE/WWM
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 03/24/2011 | MICHAEL ST. PAUL | ZONING | REVIEW | Denied | The Development Plan (D10-0035) must first be approved. |
| 03/24/2011 | JASON GREEN | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Denied | DATE: March 24, 2011 REVIEWER: Jason Green, CFM ACTIVITY: T11CM00866 (Building Plan) SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Planning & Development Services Department has received the building plan (T11CM00866). Engineering Division does not recommend approval of the building plan applications at this time. The following items need to be addressed: BUILDING PLAN COMMENTS: 1) Engineering could not verify that the building plan was in compliance with a stamped approved Development Plan Package (D10-0035). Please submit a copy of the stamped approved Development Plan, landscape, and NPPO plans with the next building plan submittal. 2) Engineering will re-review the building plan on the next submittal to insure compliance with the approved and stamped Development Plan. Additional comments may be forthcoming. GENERAL COMMENTS: Please provide the building plan with a copy of the last approved Development Plan (D10-0035). Further comments may be generated upon resubmittal of the building plan review. For questions or to schedule an appointment I can be reached at 837-4929. Jason Green, CFM Senior Engineer Associate Engineering Division COT Development Services |
| 03/25/2011 | ANDREW CONNOR | NPPO | REVIEW | Denied | Ensure that all comments and concerns on The Development Plan (D10-0035) are addressed prior to Landscape / NPPO approval. |
| 03/28/2011 | GERRY KOZIOL | WWM | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 04/18/2011 | KEN VAN KARSEN | BUILDING-RESIDENTIAL | REVIEW | Denied | PLAN REVIEW COMMENTS Plan review for the above referenced structure has been completed. This letter reflects comments to be addressed. In order to facilitate a shorter back check time, we request that you please provide revised plans and calculations, highlighting any changes, along with a written response to each of the notated items indicating action taken. SCOPE OF REVIEW: The scope of this plan review covers architectural, plumbing, mechanical, energy conservation and electrical. All code references are to the 2006 International Residential Code, 2006 International Energy Conservation Code, and Arizona State amendments to the 2006 Uniform Plumbing Code. All features were checked only to the extent allowed by the submittals provided. All portions of this project are assumed to meet or will meet other departmental requirements, conditions and concerns before permit approval. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS: Show corrections and revisions on original tracings or a finished reproducible set. Return two sets along with a set of the first submission for reference. Pen or pencil corrections on final prints will not be acceptable. To avoid delays, ensure that all corrections have been made, are complete, and have been coordinated on all applicable detail and notate sheets. (Do not cloud the changes made for comment revisions). Incorporate changes on originals and provide two copied sets for review. All engineers and architects involved in the design of the structure are to seal the related sheets of plans, details and calculations in accordance with the rules of the State Board of Technical Registration. The City of Tucson adopted the 2006 IRC with amendments on 6/12/2007 and the 2006 UPC with amendments on 7/10/2007. For initial construction: Effective 1/1/2007 the Inclusive Home Design; starting 3/1/2009 Solar Water Preparation and 7/1/2009 Solar Photo-Voltaic Preparation are required for all new SFR and duplex plans. Show the code references on the plans. Amendments to adopted codes are at the City web-site http://www.tucsonaz.gov: Planning, Building, & Business; under the Building topic; Building Ordinances and Codes; Building Codes GENERAL NOTES: " Show compliance with the Inclusive Home Design Ordinance adopted by the City of Tucson on 10/16/2007. Notate accessible route, minimum door width, changes in floor elevation, door hardware, electrical outlet reach range, grab bar reinforcement, etc. " All SFR and Duplex plans submitted after March 1, 2009 require a solar water system, or future installation preparation City of Tucson Ordinance #10549 with one of the following provisions: ½"control conduit and two ¾" copper piping for water with rooftop termination; straight 3" metallic sleeve; or an accessible attic (clear path 30" wide x 30" high) over the water heater. Show appropriate notation. " All SFR and Duplex plans submitted after July 1, 2009 require a solar photo-voltaic system, or future installation preparation City of Tucson Ordinance #10549 with the following provisions: 1. A 4 square feet area for (meter, disconnect & inverter) equipment adjacent to the electrical service panel or near the proposed collector panel space. 2. The best roof space available for accommodating PV solar collector panels with capacity for collector dead loading (typically 4 lbs/SF). 3. A minimum 3,800 volt-ampere PV electrical load entry on the Service Load Calculation (Show as a continuous load of 15.8 A). 4. An Electrical Panel Schedule with a 240 volt circuit breaker space labeled "reserved for Photo Voltaic". Show appropriate notation. " All construction drawings submitted after June 1, 2010 for one- or two-family dwellings must provide segregated building drains for future gray water utilization, Ordinance #10579. Include both: a) dual clothes washer standpipes, one with an above grade stub-out; b) separate gray water tub/shower and lavatory drain with exterior connection to the building sewer line at 3' from foundation. FOUNDATION PLANS: 1. Indicate the slope for garage slab, R309.3. 2. Show compliance with termite treatment, R320 as amended. 3. Notate (Keynote #13/A2.0) the grade away from foundations with a minimum 6" fall within the first 10', R401.3. 4. Revise the Braced Wall Panel notation with a device and an installation method that provides the required 1800 LBS uplift capacity, R602.10.6. The PAHD series shown on sheet A1.0 has been discontinued. FLOOR PLANS: 1. Show a maximum ½" floor elevation change at a notated accessible route entrance on the floor plan, R106.1.1. 2. Show the location of tempered glass (within 24" of doorways, and adjacent to stairways and landings), R308.4. CoT Amended. 3. Show the door from garage to dwelling with a self-closing and self-latching provision, 2006 IRC Amendment section 309.1. 4. Clarify the door type from garage to utility closet under the stairway. The plan shows HCMTL and Keynote #6 shows SC wood. 5. Provide fireplace spec sheets, make, model number and the approval number of the UL-127 testing agency (or ICBO #), or notate the requirement for deferred submittal approval prior to installation. 6. Show the water heater with access from the garage with a platform at least 18" above the floor, M1307.3 & P2801.6. 7. Clarify Keynote #31/A1.0 with removed water heater reinstalled with a platform at least 18" above the floor and with impact protection, M1307.3.1. ELEVATIONS: 1. Provide an attic space ventilation calculation and specify size and location of all vents needed to comply, or show compliance with R806.4 by stating "no vapor retarders at the ceiling" for an installation without vented attic space. 2. Notate and dimension the masonry fireplace chimney. Show a minimum 2' termination above any roof point within 10' measured horizontally, and not less than 3' above the point where the chimney passes through the roof, R1003.9. SECTIONS - DETAILS: 1. Clarify Keynote #34/A1.0. Show fiber-cement board or glass mat gypsum backers for tiled walls in tub and shower areas, R702.4.2. 2. Clarify Keynote #10/A2.0, #19/A3.0 and #7/A4.0. Roof shingles may not be used on roof slopes less than 2:12, R905.2.2. 3. Clarify the (?) Detail references shown on sheet A3.0 & A3.1. 4. Show Detail 2/A4.0 referenced at Keynote #3/A4.0 5. Show the weep screed with a minimum clearance 4" above grade or 2" above paved areas, R703.6.2.1. Revise detail 1/S1.0. 6. Specify water-resistive barrier equivalent to two layers of Grade D paper over the wood based sheathing of exterior plaster wall coverings, R703.6.3. 7. Identify factory-built fireplace compliance with R1004 and chimney compliance with R1005 at Keynote #28/A1.0. 8. Provide roof scupper openings with a (4" min) width equal to the drain circumference required for the area served (3 in/hr rainfall rate), UPC 1101.11.2.1 & Table 11-1. PLUMBING PLANS: 1. Provide a plumbing design using a single code, 2006 UPC or 2006 IRC. Sheet P1.0 references the IRC at the recessed washer box and dish washer notations, and sheet P2.0 references the UPC at note #1 and the fixture schedule. 2. Clarify the fixture symbols. The plan shows P-4 at the kitchen sink. The fixture schedule shows P-4 for the kitchen sink. 3. Show a provision for a future solar water system, City of Tucson Ordinance #10549. 4. Show a drain system in compliance with City of Tucson Ordinance #10579 for gray water system preparation. 5. Show dual clothes washer standpipes. Provide one discharge opening plumbed to an exterior wall with an above grade stub-out for gray water surface distribution, or when the exterior wall is inaccessible to the building gray collection line. Provide a second discharge opening plumbed to the building black line in compliance with the City of Tucson Ordinance #10579. 6. Show an individual water meter for each dwelling unit, P2602.1.1 (City of Tucson Amended). 7. Provide water hammer arresters wherever quick-closing valves are installed in a water distribution system. The devices should conform to ASSE 1010-2004. Water hammer arresters are required for clothes washer, dishwasher and refrigerator water connections, UPC 609.10. P2903.5. 8. Show the water service pipe and water meter sizes with sufficient capacity for controlling excessive flow rates, UPC 610.3, P2903.6. Change the 1" service pipe to 1-1/4" for supporting a 26.5 fixture unit system with greater than 200' developed length. 9. Provide gas pipe sizes in compliance with connected demand, UPC 1217.2, & Table 12-8. G2413.3 & Table G2413.4(1). Change the pipe segment supplying the furnace and fireplace to 1". Change the pipe segment supplying the furnace, fireplace and range to 1". Change the pipe segment supplying all appliances to 1-1/4". MECHANICAL PLANS: 1. Notate on plans that Mechanical complies with the 2006 IRC. Change the reference at Note #1. 2. Show a means of make-up air to the laundry closet (transfer grille, louvered or undercut door), M1307. ELECTRICAL PLANS: 1. Add a double breaker space for future Photo Voltaic on the panel schedule, E3304.11 & E3606.2. 2. Show the location of a typical electrical panel on the Electrical Plan with 4 square feet of clear area for future Photo Voltaic equipment, E3501.6.2 & E3605.8. 3. Revise the electrical load calculations following Table E3502.2 for sizing 100% of the dwelling load. Show 1500 watts for each 20A appliance and laundry circuit. Show nameplate entries for each appliance. Apply a 40% factor for loads above 10,000 watts. Add the total nameplate for the air conditioning unit. And show a minimum 3,800 volt-ampere or 16A entry for future Photo Voltaic equipment. 4. Show receptacle outlets in each Bedroom with no wall point (exclude door openings) more than 6' from a receptacle outlet, E3801.2. 5. Show an additional counter top receptacle outlet over the dishwasher area with no point along the wall line more than 24" from a receptacle outlet, E3801.4.1. 6. Show two or more 2O AMP small appliance circuits at the kitchen countertop receptacle outlets, E3603.2 and E3801.3. 7. Protect all bedroom outlets including receptacles, lights and smoke detectors with combination type arc-fault circuit interrupters, E3802.12. OUTDOOR LIGHTING CODE 1. Show compliance with City of Tucson Outdoor Lighting Code with an approved lighting calculation in accordance with OLC 3.1.2. Include all exterior fixtures on the property in the calculations. 2. Provide spec sheets for all full cut-off fixtures showing the lamp type, placement and fixture wattage. All other fixtures are assumed to be unshielded (non-FCO style). Fixtures are only exempt from the total lumen budget if both of the full cut-off FCO style and located under overhangs, OLC 5.1.2. INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE: 1. Clarify the insulation location between the garage utility closet and the stairway surface for compliance with N1102.4. If you have any questions please contact: Ken Van Karsen (520) 837-4912 City of Tucson Residential Plan Review |
| 04/20/2011 | ERIC NEWCOMB | BUILDING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Denied | 1. SHEETS S1.0/S2.0/S2.1; SECTIONS: THE CITY OF TUCSON REQUIRES ALL LETTERING (UPPER AND LOWER CASE) TO BE A MINIMUM OF 3/32" IN HEIGHT. REVISE. 2. SHEET S1.0 (FOUNDATION PLAN); SECTION 2: WHERE IS SECTION 2 PERTINENT TO THIS PLAN? THERE ARE TWO SECTION CUTS THAT ARE MARKED SIMILAR. REVISE SECTION. 3. SHEET S1.0 (SECTIONS); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 2): THE CALCULATIONS INDICATE AN ALLOWABLE SOIL PRESSURE OF 1500 PSF. A CITY OF TUCSON AMENDMENT TO THE CODE REQUIRES 18" BELOW FINISH GRADE TO ACQUIRE 1500 PSF, OR 12" FOR 1000 PSF. REVISE CALCULATIONS AND/OR DRAWINGS. 4. SHEET S1.0 (FOUNDATION PLAN); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 9): THE CALCULATIONS INDICATE INTERIOR FOOTING F4 TO BE 2'-4" SQUARE, WHILE THE DRAWING INDICATES F4 IS 2'-0" SQUARE. CLARIFY AND COORDINATE. 5. SHEET S1.0 (FOOTING SCHEDULE); SECTION 1: THE SECTION INDICATES THE FOOTING WIDTH TO BE 16" MINIMUM, WHILE THE NOTE INDICATES THE FOOTING IS 1'-6" WIDE. REVISE THE SECTION. 6. SHEET S1.0 (FOUNDATION PLAN); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 13): HOLDOWNS ARE NOT INDICATED ON THE DRAWINGS. PROVIDE. 7. SHEET S1.0; FOUNDATION PLAN: A SECTION 5 IS REFERENCED AT THE PATIO, BUT NO SECTION 5 IS SHOWN. PROVIDE. 8. SHEET S1.0; FOUNDATION PLAN: SHOULD THE SECTION CUTS AT THE SOUTH WALL (GARAGE) BE 2 INSTEAD OF 4? CLARIFY. 9. SHEET S1.0; SECTION 4: CHANGE THE NOTES ON THIS SECTION TO INDICATE WOOD STUDS ARE 2X6 AT 16" OC. 10. SHEET S2.0 (GARAGE ROOF FRAMING); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 6): THE CALCULATIONS INDICATE JOIST J1 TO BE 11-7/8" LPI-20 AT 16" OC, WHILE THE DRAWING INDICATES 11-7/8" LPI-56 AT 24" OC. CLARIFY AND COORDINATE. 11. SHEET S2.0; FRAMING PLAN: THE PLAN DENOTED 'FIRST FLOOR AND GARAGE ROOF FRAMING PLAN' SHOULD BE SECOND FLOOR AND GARAGE ROOF FRAMING PLAN. REVISE. 12. SHEET S2.0 (FRAMING PLAN); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 4): THE CALCULATIONS INDICATE JOIST J3 TO BE 11-7/8" LPI-56 AT 24" OC, WHILE THE DRAWING INDICATES 2X10 AT 24" OC. CLARIFY AND COORDINATE. 13. SHEET S2.0 (FRAMING PLAN); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 4): THE CALCULATIONS INDICATE JOIST J2 (FLOOR JOISTS) TO BE 2X8 AT 24" OC, WHILE THE DRAWING INDICATES 11-7/8" LPI-20 AT 16" OC. CLARIFY AND COORDINATE. 14. SHEET S2.0; FRAMING PLANS: THERE ARE SEVERAL LINTEL BEAMS THAT ARE INDICATED ON THE PLANS, BUT NO SIZES ARE INDICATED AND NO CALCULATIONS ARE PROVIDED. CLARIFY. 15. SHEET S2.0 (FRAMING PLANS); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 14): THE STRAP TIES AND SOLID BLOCKING ARE NOT INDICATED ON THE DRAWINGS. PROVIDE. 16. SHEET S2.0 (PLAN); SECTION 9: SHOULD THE SECTION CUTS AT THE SOUTH WALL (GARAGE) BE 9 INSTEAD OF 7? CLARIFY. 17. SHEET S2.0; PLANS: THE PLANS INDICATE SECTION CUT 10, BUT NO SECTION 10 IS SHOWN. PROVIDE. 18. SHEET S2.1 (SHEAR WALLS); STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS (SHEET 18): THE SHEAR WALL SCHEDULE IS NOT ON THE DRAWINGS. PROVIDE. 19. STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS; SHEETS 4 AND 6: SHEET 4 INDICATES JOIST J2 JOISTS ARE FLOOR JOISTS, WHILE SHEET 6 DESIGNS J2 WITH ROOF LOADING AND A 10' SPAN. CLARIFY AND COORDINATE. 20. GENERAL: STRUCTURAL CALCULATIONS ARE SEALED BY THE ENGINEER OF RECORD JESUS L. FLOREZ, P.E. ALL DRAWINGS PREPARED BY MR. FLOREZ, OR UNDER HIS DIRECT SUPERVISION, MUST BE SEALED, SIGNED, AND DATED BY HIM. 21. GENERAL: PROVIDE WRITTEN RESPONSES TO ALL REVIEW COMMENTS. |
Final Status
| Task End Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 04/21/2011 | CPIERCE1 | OUT TO CUSTOMER | Completed |
| 04/21/2011 | SUE REEVES | REJECT SHELF | Completed |