Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Permit Number: T08SA00418
Parcel: 125041580

Address:
2334 E 1ST ST

Review Status: Active

Review Details: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT

Permit Number - T08SA00418
Review Name: BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
Review Status: Active
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
11/26/2008 JOSE ORTIZ DOT TRAFFIC REVIEW Completed TDOT-Traffic has no objections to the proposed on-site improvements.
11/26/2008 JIM VOGELSBERG ENGINEERING REVIEW Approved Engineering Division has no objection/adverse comments to the variance request.
-JPV
11/28/2008 DAVE MANN FIRE REVIEW Approved
12/01/2008 DCORRAL1 COMMUNITY PLANNING REVIEW Completed URBAN PLANNING AND DESIGN COMMENTS
C10-08-19 Frank Residence Addition
2334 E. 1st Street , R-1
University Area Plan and Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan
11/25/08 drcorral

The applicant is appealing the Development Services Director's decision to deny Design Development Option (DDO) case DDO-08-120. DDO-08-120 is a request by the property owner (L. Frank) to expand the two bedroom, one bath dwelling with room additions, an additional bathroom and a single car carport. The applicant filed a Design Development Option (DDO) application with the Development Services Department (DSD) requesting the zoning approval necessary to allow construction of expansion with reduced side and rear yard setbacks. The applicant's DDO was denied in part, due to a protest on the project's non-compliance with the required DDO Findings of LUC Section 5.3.4.3.F, H, K, L, M and N. Tucson Land Use Code (LUC) Sections applicable to this project include Section 5.3.4.3 (DDO Findings); Section 2.3.4 which provides the design criteria applicable to residential development in the R-1 "Residential" zone; Sections 3.2.3, 3.2.5 and 3.2.6 which provide the development criteria for all principal and accessory structures; and, Section 5.1.7.3 which provides for the Board of Adjustment to hear and decide on appeals made to the Development Services Director's decision on DDO applications.

The applicant is requesting a reversal of the Development Services Director's decision to deny DDO-08-12

This site is within the boundaries of the University Area Plan and Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan, which provides land use guidance for this request. The General Plan and Design Guidelines Manual provide additional relevant land use direction for this case.

POLICY
Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan
LAND USE
Recommendations for land use in the Sam Hughes neighborhood focus on maintaining the present residential aspect and integrity of the neighborhood. The residents of the Sam Hughes neighborhood recognize that development on vacant land will occur and strongly encourage that development design:
Goal 1:
Maintain the quiet, single-family residential character of the Sam Hughes Neighborhood.
Policy 2:
Preserve the unique diversity and character of the neighborhood's historic and architectural value.
Implementation:
2. Building setbacks for new structures should be at least those which exist on contiguous lots or as required by the City of Tucson Major Streets and Routes Plan and Gateway regulations adopted by Mayor and Council.

University Area Plan
Adopted Policies and Recommendations
Section 1: Overall Goals of the University Area Plan
1. Recognize distinct neighborhoods in the University Area, and support those changes which protect and enhance the character, identity, and residential quality of life in these neighborhoods.

Section 8: General Design Guidelines
1. Complement surrounding development - Utilize compatible building materials, architectural style and ornamentation, setbacks, stepbacks, and variations in building height or mass to complement the scale and character of surrounding development and reduce the appearance of excessive height and bulk (Figure A).


General Plan
Element 4: Community Character and Design
Policy 5: Promote neighborhood identity and visual character
Supporting Policy 5.4: Promote subdivision design that responds to the physical characteristics of the site, adjacent land use patterns, and unique visual qualities. Street design, lot size and layout, building orientation, and pedestrian and bicycle circulation should together help to create a cohesive, distinct neighborhood that is an asset to the larger community. Unconnected and/or monotonous designs and repetitive building footprints and orientations should be avoided.

Policy 6: Promote quality in design for residential, commercial, industrial, mixed-use, and publicly-funded development.
Supporting Policy 6.1: All development should incorporate environmentally sensitive design that protects the integrity of existing neighborhoods, complements adjacent land uses, and enhances the overall function and visual quality of the street, adjacent properties, and the community.
Supporting Policy 6.3: Solutions and strategies included in the Design Guidelines Manual should be utilized to provide an improved level of community design.

Element 6: Conservation, Rehabilitation, and Redevelopment
Policy 2: Protect established residential neighborhoods by supporting compatible development, which may include other residential, mixed-use infill and appropriate nonresidential uses.

Design Guidelines Manual
I. Residential Development
B. Community Character and Design
1. Spatial and Functional Relationships
a. Subdivision Streetscape
Intent: Add visual interest and character to the streetscape and increase the overall appeal of the development
Solution: Vary the following to add character and interest and to create a sense of uniqueness
- Building footprint
- Building orientation
- Setbacks
- Orientation of garages and porches

DISCUSSION
The applicant's property is located on a local residential street in the Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan and University Area Plan. The property is surrounded by R-1 zoning and residential land uses. The majority of the lots in this area are relatively small and the parcels that do have structures on them are located extremely close and in some cases up to the property lines. The applicant is proposing the construction of a room addition and a garage to the rear of the existing house.

The Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan and the University Area Plan both state that the distinct neighborhoods in this area should be recognized and that the character of the neighborhoods should be saved. The General Plan promotes neighborhood identity, visual character, and quality design in residential areas. The General Plan states that building orientation should help create a cohesive, distinct neighborhood that is an asset to the larger community and that unconnected and/or monotonous designs and repetitive building footprints and orientations should be avoided. In addition, the General Plan states that established residential neighborhoods should be protected by supporting only compatible development. All development should incorporate environmentally sensitive design that protects the integrity of existing neighborhoods, complements adjacent land uses, and enhances the overall function and visual quality of adjacent properties, and the community. The Design Guidelines Manual states that to add character and to create a sense of uniqueness that setbacks should be varied.

CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the applicant is requesting the variances to allow for the construction of a room addition and a garage. The pattern of development in the neighborhood is inconsistent. Many structures in the neighborhood are closer to the lot lines as is proposed for the subject property. The applicable policies support reversal of Development Services Director's decision to deny Design Development Option (DDO) DDO-08-120.


s:\caserev\boa\10-08-19.doc