Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Permit Number: T06CM00243
Parcel: 134030040

Review Status: Completed

Review Details: RESUBMITTAL

Permit Number - T06CM00243
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL
Review Status: Completed
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
04/18/2006 BROWN & ASSOCIATES 2ND PARTY REVIEW REVIEW Denied Brown & Associates
177 N Church Avenue, Suite 311
Tucson, Arizona 85701
Office (520) 882-4735 Fax (520) 882-5412

2nd Review
RESIDENTIAL PLAN REVIEW

Client: City of Tucson Reviewer: L. Pudvah

Project: 9231 East Old Spanish Trail Permit #: T06CM00243

Date: 17 April 2005 Brown & Associates #: 85701-6209

_______________________________________________________________

2003 International Residential Code; 2003 UPC with State Amendments; Outdoor Lighting Code; 2003 International Building Code.

Residence Area: n/a S.F. Number of Floor Levels: One
Garage Area: 576 S.F. Number of Elevation Options: n/a
Porch Area: 399 S.F. Building Wall Construction: masonry
Basement Level Area: n/a S.F. Building Grade Floor Construction: S.O.G.
Guest House Area: 2,105 S.F. Building Roof Construction: wood
Guest House Construction: n/a Elevated Floor Construction: n/a

NOTE: THE FOLLOWING ITEMS NEED TO BE CORRECTED PRIOR TO RESUBMITTING YOUR PLANS FOR APPROVAL. RETURN ALL SUBMITTAL PLANS AND DOCUMENTS WITH YOUR REVISED SUBMITTAL PLANS AND DOCUMENTS. . Highlighted bold comments are in response to the applicant’s reply. .

X Revise Plans for Compliance
IRC Section R105.3.1
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS:

X 1. Construction details provided for Building Safety approval should be represented and detailed on the drawings and not specified by code reference only. CODE section references only are not acceptable when specific construction details are needed to convey and distinguish what it is the constructor is suppose to actually supply and install. R106.1.1

X 2. All corrections to drawings shall be delineated as a dated “clouded delta” revision number on each plan or detail that is revised. Revised drawings shall be submitted as prints of original tracings or masters that have been revised. IRC Section R105, R106

ARCHITECTURAL PLAN COMMENTS

X 3. Openings between the garage and residence shall be equipped with solid wood doors not less than 1 3/8-inch thick, or shall be 20-minute fire-rated doors and shall be maintained self-closing and self-latching. Amendment to IRC Section R309.1. The plans now call for a 1-hour fire-rated steel door. This is much more than what is needed since the division wall is not 1-hour rated construction.

X 6. Provide attic ventilation calculations for all concealed attic spaces; include required and provided net free ventilation area. Indicate the size, type, wire mesh and location of attic ventilation. Provide the following note, if applicable: "Where eave or cornice vents are installed insulation shall not block the free flow of air. A minimum of 1 inch space shall be provided between the insulation and roof sheathing at the location of the vent”. IRC Section R806. The plans show roof vents installed flat on the roof. Weather proofing this is extremely difficult and maybe not practical. No allowance has been made for the net vent area and no eave vents are shown. The proposed design is not accepted.

MODEL ENERGY CODE COMMENTS

X 2. Identify on the mechanical drawing the required insulation for mechanical systems piping. IRC Section N1103.5 The required refrigerant pipe insulation thickness is not identified on the drawing.

X 5. Recessed lighting fixtures type and rated installation requirements shall be noted on the drawing. Coordinate this with fire-resistive requirements. N1102.1.11 Provide conclusive note on the drawing specifying that all recessed light fixtures shall be Type IC rated.

STRUCTURAL FOUNDATION PLAN COMMENTS:

X 2. Fills supporting slabs on grade are limited in height. Establish the (USGS datum) existing grade contour elevations within and surrounding the proposed building along with the finish floor elevation for the new and existing buildings. R106.1.1, R506 Coordinate foundation design by identifying existing and new grade contours with an integrated site drainage plan for the new and existing construction. Retaining walls supporting buildings must be designed by a qualified licensed Arizona engineer. R301.1.3, R401.3

X 3. Identify on the drawing the required 28-day concrete compressive strength. R402.2





STRUCTURAL FRAMING PLAN COMMENTS:

X 2 Specify all structural material types, species, grades, etc. Wood stud and steel stud construction shall be shown to comply with the prescriptive requirements of applicable IRC Sections or the components shall be designed by an Arizona Registrant. Wood, steel, masonry and concrete components shall comply with prescriptive/empirical design requirements of IRC Sections or shall be designed by an Arizona Registrant. The proposed irregular masonry wall and wood truss building shall be appropriately designed and sealed by a qualified engineer. R301.1.3, R401, R501, R502.2, R505, R601, R602.10.10, R603, R604, R801, R1001, R1003 The resubmitted plans do not have the appropriate designs and plans under the professional seal of a qualified licensed Arizona registrant.

X 3 Girders/beams must be within the load and span limitations of IRC Table R502.5.(1) and (2) or the design shall be selected by a qualified engineer. Provide engineer sealed design calculations and plans as required.

X 4 Specify on the drawings the design wind and seismic criteria and required floor live load, roof live load, attic live load and dead loads used for selection of joists, beams, trusses and girders. IRC Section R301.

X 5 City of Tucson Amendment to Table R301.5 requires 40 psf for floor live load and 40 psf for storage or habitable attic floor. The bottom chord of attic trusses shall be designed for not less than 10 p.s.f. non-current live load or as may be required. Identify on the drawings whether or not the attic space is to be used for storage. Bottom chord live load needs to be specified for use by the truss manufacturer.

X 6. Identify and specify structural sheathing for walls, floors and roofs. R503, R604, R803 The required specification and rating for structural roof sheathing could not be identified on the plans.

X 7. Identify and specify on the plans required nailing per Table R602.3(1) except as may be otherwise required by sealed engineer’s design. R502.9, R602.3, R802.2

X 11 Roof trusses shall be attached to wall plates with approved connectors that have a resistance to uplift of not less than 175 pounds. The fastener connection to the truss shall be in accordance with the truss manufacturer’s specifications. IRC Reference R802.10.5 Identify the required connection and fasteners so that the truss manufacturer can accept it or decline it.

X 13. When an architect or engineer of record is utilized for the building design that registrant must review truss document and other engineered design submittals provided by another registrant. Truss calculations shall bear an appropriate review stamp showing this review has been done. IRC Reference Sections R106.3.3, R301.1.3, R502.1.4, R502.8.2, R502.10, R502.11.3, R802.7.2, IBC Section 106.3.4 The engineer for the building design shall be called upon to later review and approve the deferred design trusses prior to submittal to the building official for permit approval of the roof trusses. IBC 106.3.4




MECHANICAL PLAN COMMENTS:

X 2. Show trap, routing, pipe size and disposal point for condensate piping, emergency pan and secondary condensate line as required. Section M1411.3 IT appears that the proposed discharge from the condensate line will be deposited directly upon earth over the building foundation with no apparent route for the water to drain away from the building. This is not acceptable.

PLUMBING PLAN COMMENTS

X 1 Provide table of fixture unit counts for water supply piping. P2903.6, P2903.7; UPC 610 The proposed waste water is being directed to an existing septic tank system. It is therefore necessary for the applicant to show that the existing septic system is adequate for the combined flow and for the septic plans to be submitted to the waste water official for approval. P2602, UPC Appendix K,

ELECTRICAL PLAN COMMENTS:

X 1. Receptacles shall be installed so that no point along the floor line in any wall space is more than 6 feet, measured horizontally, from an outlet in that space, including any wall space 2 feet or more in width. IRC Section E3801.2.1. Add additional receptacles redlined on the drawing.

X 5. Electric power to the new building is shown connected to the existing service panel. However, electrical calculations are shown only for the new building. Provide complete electrical calculations that evidence the total connected lighting and power requirements for both existing and new electrical uses. IRC Section E3502.2 The proposed new 600 ampere service requires that the electrical power and distribution system be under seal of a licensed Arizona electrical engineer. R106.1, 2002 NEC

OUTDOOR LIGHTING CODE:

X 1. Provide catalog cuts of all outdoor lighting fixtures identifying fixture shielding or non shielding installation conditions and output lumens for each outdoor lighting fixture. It is necessary that the design represents that it includes both new and existing exterior lighting fixtures.

X 2. Provide on the drawing appropriate tabular calculations that identify Outdoor Lighting Code site designation, total site area, allowable lumens per Table 5.1, conditions for installation of outdoor lighting fixture type, total lumens allowed at the site, maximum unshielded lumens at the site, and the actual installed lumens at the site for each fixture type. All exterior lighting fixtures (new and existing) shall be included in the calculations.

Sincerely,

BROWN & ASSOCIATES



Michael J. Brown, C.B.O. President
MB:ns
04/20/2006 SEPTIC APPROVAL WWM REVIEW Denied SEPTIC, UNDER P06CP02524, NOT YET APPROVED