Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Permit Number: T05CM01437
Parcel: 129051180

Review Status: Completed

Review Details: RESUBMITTAL

Permit Number - T05CM01437
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL
Review Status: Completed
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
05/16/2005 HEATHER THRALL ZONING REVIEW Denied DSD TRANSMITTAL

FROM: Heather Thrall Senior Planner FOR: David Rivera Principal Planner


PROJECT: T05CM01437
2220 E. Winsett Street
Residential addition, bedrooms, bath, porch
Site plan
2nd Review
Transmittal date: May 16, 2005



COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along with redlines and a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed.

1. Please address the following listed issues, both on the revised site plan and in a response letter with detailed explanation of how each comment is being addressed. The first and 2nd review comments are provided in respective order.

2. The original comment: The submitted site plan shows a lot size of 123.75 feet by 50 feet, for a total lot area of 6,188 square feet. Staff reviewed the shown lot size for a possible nonconforming status, as the R-1 zoning of the site requires the minimum lot size to be 7,000 square feet. Staff discovered the Country Club Manor Subdivision was created in 1928, which allows confirmation the subject lot is legal nonconforming in size. During this research process, staff noted a discrepancy between the lot size shown (listed above) on the original submitted site plan, and the lot size shown on the approved subdivision plat. The actual, nonconforming lot size for this property is 113.75 feet by 50 feet, for a total lot area of only 5,687.5 square feet. Please show this information on the revised site plan.

The 2nd review comment: The revised plan shows an altered lot size of 150 x 50 feet. Clarify what source these measurements are derived from. Please explain why the nonconforming lot size staff provided in the original review comment above was not shown on the revised plan.

3. The original comment: Based upon the lot size comment, both the north and south property line setbacks shown for the residence need to be reviewed and possibly changed to show accurate measurements on the revised site plan.

The 2nd review comment: The revised site plan is not highlighted to show lot line or setback dimension changes have been made. Given the revised lot size information on the resubmitted site plan, please clarify the lot line and setback dimension changes that have occurred from the 1st review. Staff is concerned about the accuracy of setbacks and proximity of lot lines given the changes made to lot size.

4. The original comment: Given the lot size information provided in the first review, please revise the proposed lot coverage calculations on the revised site plan.

The 2nd review comment: Once comments 2 and 3 are addressed and an accurate source of information for lot size, setback dimensions and lot line locations is confirmed, the lot coverage information can be examined.

5. The original comment: Per the last approved plans, the existing residence contains two (2) bedrooms. The proposed project shows an addition of two (2) bedrooms and a family room. The proposed family room meets the Land Use Code definition of a bedroom (Section 6.2.2, page 429), which will in essence, provide this residence with a total of five (5) bedrooms. Per Section 3.5.7.1.G. and H of the Land Use Code (page 272.1), a five (5) bedroom residence in the R-1 zone must provide three (3) parking spaces. All parking and maneuvering must be contained on site, either in a side or rear perimeter yard. The vehicular use area must be improved, which includes surfacing, striping and provision of barriers, in conformance with Development Standard 3-05. Parking spaces are not permitted in the front street perimeter yard. The front street perimeter yard is defined as the area between the street and the front wall of the residence.

Per the Zoning Administrator's determination, any proposed alley access is not allowed to any future proposed parking spaces, and cannot be approved without a Board of Adjustment variance granted to allow access.

Given the Land Use Code and Development Standard requirements listed above, the project, as currently proposed, cannot be approved.

On the revised site plan, please show a parking and vehicular use area meeting the above listed code provisions. (Please be sure to add the proposed parking and vehicular use areas to the revised lot coverage calculations.) The alternatives are to redesign the project to reduce the number of bedrooms or apply for and obtain a Board of Adjustment variance for parking and access standards, if needed.
The 2nd review comment: The parking configuration shown on the revised site plan does not meet the requirements outlined in the above review comment. Please clarify if the applicant desires to seek a referral to obtain a parking variance for the configuration provided. The alternative is to redesign the project parking area or the residential addition to meet code requirements.

6. These are not final comments for an official Board of Adjustment variance referral. Should the applicant wish to seek variances for this project, please contact me for review of any revisions to the proposed plan and for comments to be referred to the Board of Adjustment process.

7. Should you have any questions on this review, please contact Heather Thrall for an office appointment via email at Heather.Thrall@tucsonaz.gov or at 520-791-4541 x1156


If you have any questions about this transmittal, please call (520) 791-5608.

Final Status

Task End Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description
05/23/2005 KMEDINA1 OUT TO CUSTOMER Completed