Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: SITE
Permit Number - T04CM04619
Review Name: SITE
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07/06/2006 | MARTIN BROWN | FIRE | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 07/07/2006 | ANDREW CONNOR | NPPO | REVIEW | Denied | 1. Applications for projects within the Scenic Corridor Zone (SCZ) shall be reviewed in accordance with the DSD Full Notice Procedure, Sec. 23A-50 and 23A-51. Contact Patricia Gehlen-Zoning Manager for application information. The decision to approve or deny the project will be based on the purpose, intent, and specific regulations of LUC 2.8.2. 2. Submit a separate landscape plan per DS 2-07.0. to verify that entire site meets current minimum requirements. 3. Submit a native plant preservation plan or application for exception. LUC 3.8.4.2 4. Additional comments may apply |
| 07/07/2006 | ANDREW CONNOR | LANDSCAPE | REVIEW | Denied | 1. Applications for projects within the Scenic Corridor Zone (SCZ) shall be reviewed in accordance with the DSD Full Notice Procedure, Sec. 23A-50 and 23A-51. Contact Patricia Gehlen-Zoning Manager for application information. The decision to approve or deny the project will be based on the purpose, intent, and specific regulations of LUC 2.8.2. 2. Submit a separate landscape plan per DS 2-07.0. to verify that entire site meets current minimum requirements. 3. Submit a native plant preservation plan or application for exception. LUC 3.8.4.2 4. Additional comments may apply |
| 08/08/2006 | JASON GREEN | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Denied | DATE: August 8, 2006 SUBJECT: Fellowship Hall- Site Plan Review TO: Jeff Stanley LOCATION: 2955 W Ironwood Hill Dr, T14S R13E Sec05, Ward 1 REVIEWERS: Jason Green, CFM ACTIVITY: T04CM04619 SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Development Services Department has received and reviewed the re-submitted site plan. Comments related to the site plan review dated November 17, 2004 prepared by Doug Williams, Senior Engineering Associate and further comments generated by this review must be addressed prior to site plan approval. The site plan is not approved at this time. Please address the following comments: SITE PLAN COMMENTS: 1) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.15: Provide a drainage report for the parcel showing existing and developed conditions. The subject parcel is located in a balanced basin as shown on the Balanced and Critical Basin Maps outlined in the Stormwater Detention/Retention Manual. The developed discharge for the 2, 10, and 100-year flow events must be less than or equal to the existing corresponding discharge values. Since the subject parcel is larger than an acre 5-year threshold retention is also required. The drainage report must meet the minimum standards for development outlined in the Stormwater Detention/Retention Manual. 2) DS Sec.10-01.III.3.5.1.3.a, 10-02.14.2.6: Provide a geotechnical report evaluation that addresses the following: a) Soils report should provide conformance with DS Section 10-02.14.2.6 regarding a discussion of the potential for hydro-collapsible soils and any recommendation for setbacks from the building to the proposed detention/retention basin or water harvesting basins. b) The soils report shall provide identification / assessment of any potentially hazardous geotechnical areas, and state any geotechnical recommendations and whether there are special provisions for the soil preparation for this development. c) Provide slope stability recommendations for any proposed constructed slopes. d) Provide percolation rates for the detention/retention basin for 5-year threshold retention. 3) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.12: Revise the site plan to show the required continuous pedestrian circulation path that must connect all public access areas of the proposed building and the circulation path located on Ironwood Hill Drive. 4) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.16: Provide a detail for the location and type of drainage structure, label and dimension proposed scuppers, that are used for collecting onsite roof drainage at all pedestrian sidewalk. Any scuppers proposed under the sidewalk will be designed and constructed to convey the 10-year flood flow. Provide a statement in the drainage report showing scupper calculations that demonstrate that the 10-year flood flow is contained under the sidewalk. 5) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.17: Provide estimated cut and fill quantities on the site plan for grading plan purposes. 6) DS Sec.3-05.2.1.3.b: Revise the site plan to show a minimum unobstructed radius of 5 feet that is required at PAAL intersections, unless the PAAL is designated as a fire lane or access for refuse collection then a minimum unobstructed radius of 18 feet is required. 7) DS Sec.3-01.3.2.C: Depict and label 25' radii concrete curbs/headers per City of Tucson/Pima County Standard Detail 213 (PC/COT SD 213) at the Prince Road driveway egress and ingress. The curbs/headers should be constructed at the edge of pavement, which must also be depicted on the site plan. 8) DS Sec.3-01.3.3.A: Revise the site plan to show the required 6-foot wide sidewalk with curb along the street frontage of Ironwood Hill Drive. Per the adopted Mayor and Counsel policy all sidewalks along MS&R right-of-ways for arterial and collector streets require 6-foot wide sidewalks. 9) DS Sec.3-01.2.7 A: Revise the site plan to reflect handicap access ramps with truncated domes. Please refer to this standard and the figures for additional street design requirements, including curb access ramps, utilities, landscaping, etc. 10) Provide water-harvesting areas, depressed 6-inches, shown in plan view to provide for onsite drainage. Refer to the City of Tucson Water Harvesting Guidance Manual, Ordinance # 10210, for recommendation on how to construct and maintain the required water harvesting areas. GENERAL COMMENTS: Please provide a revised site plan, a drainage report, and a geotechnical report that address the comments provided above. Include a comprehensive response letter addressing in detail responses to all of the above comments. Further comments may be generated upon resubmittal of the site plan, drainage report, and geotechnical report. Please enclose "redlines" with the resubmittal package for reference. For any questions or to schedule a meeting, call me at 791-5550, extension 1189. Jason Green, CFM Senior Engineer Associate Engineering Division Development Services |
| 08/17/2006 | STEVE SHIELDS | ZONING | REVIEW | Denied | DSD TRANSMITTAL FROM: Steve Shields Lead Planner PROJECT: SON LIFE CHURCH - FELLOWSHIP HALL EXP. 2955 W. Ironwood Hills Drive T04CM04619 Site Plan (1st Review) TRANSMITTAL DATE: August 25, 2006 COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along with redlines and a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed. The following comments are based on a greater than 25% building area expansion resulting in a full code compliance review of the entire site. 1. The Site Plan (SP) cannot be approved as submitted. Please include a response letter to the comments along with the corrected copies of the SP with your next submittal. 2. Include the entire site on the plan at a scale no larger than 1"=60', similar to the prior submittal. D.S. 2-02.2.1A. 3. Location map is very difficult to read, please revise D.S. 2-02.2.1.4. Provide a ling drawing with major streets, washes, railroads, etc. & subject property. 4. Show all existing and proposed structures, including location, size, height, overhangs, canopies and use. D.S. 2-02.2.1.4. 5. Provide all required zoning setbacks and distances between buildings dimensioned. D.S. 2-02.2.1.6. 6. Provide a fully dimensioned off-street parking layout. D.S. 2-02.2.1.6. The north and east PAALs are not dimensioned. It also appears that a drop off area is proposed on the west end of the parking area, delineate between the PAAL and drop of zone and dimension. 7. Keynote 9 calls out "NEW 6" EXTRUDED CURB, 4'X40' ISLANDS (TYP.) At the southwest corner of the parking area keynote 9 is pointing to an undeveloped area, please clarify. 8. A paved vehicle access is required to the "CARETAKER'S HOUSE", provide and dimension. D.S. 3-05. 9. The parking area east of the existing Chapel shows areas that will have the "pavement is to be removed and revegetated". It is unclear how this PAAL will be utilized after removal of the parking areas. Also keynote 43 addresses "ROLL-OUT TRASH CONTAINER STORAGE" to be used in this area, if this area is to be used for trash containers then demonstrate the maneuvering area. See engineering comments. 10. A barrier will be required along the south side of the parking so that there is no vehicle access to the basketball court & undeveloped area. D.S. 3-05.2.3.C. 11. Off-street bicycle parking include materials for lighting, paving and security; fully dimensioned layout; specific type of rack and the number of bikes it supports; and type of directional. D.S. 2-02.2.1.9. A detail is provided for the Class 1, please provide a detail for the Class 2 with the above information. 12. Clarify the existing sidewalks. It is difficult to tell where they are located. D.S. 2-02.2.1.12. 13. Provide pedestrian & accessible route to all buildings, new & existing. This includes access between the existing Chapel and new Fellowship Hall and an access route to the existing Caretakers Home. D.S. 2-08.3. 14. Provide pedestrian & accessible route to the required sidewalk along Ironwood Hills. D.S. 2-08.3 See engineering comments for sidewalk required along Ironwood Hills. 15. Revise Note 2 on sheet 1 to include existing and proposed use. D.S. 2-02.2.1.31. 16. This project is within the Scenic Corridor Zone (SCZ). SCZ approval is required prior to site plan approval. A separate review is required for the SCZ. The case number for this review must be noted in the lower right corner of each sheet of the site, landscape and NPPO plans. All required elements of the SCZ (i.e. 30 foot buffer, view corridors, approved colors, etc.) as shown on the approved SCZ plan must be added to the site plan, along with date of approval and any conditions placed on that approval. A thirty-foot-wide buffer area, adjacent to the future MS & R right-of-way, is to be preserved in place and maintained in its natural state. Maximum height of a structure is one-third the distance of the structure from the future-right-of-way, not to exceed 25 feet in height. Material and/or paint description for areas of structures and signage visible from the Scenic Route are reviewed for colors, which are predominant within the surrounding landscape, such as desert and earthtones. The SCZ process requires that the applicant offer to meet with the adjacent property owners and neighborhood associations. For more information regarding the SCZ application process please contact Patricia Gehlen @ 791-5608 ext. 1179 (LUC 2.8.2) 17. There is a 50' dimension shown along the east property line, please clarify. See redline. 18. Building labels on the Site Map should match Building labels on the site plan. 19. The Floor Area Ratio (FAR) Calculation is incorrect. Provide a complete calculation. D.S. 2-02.2.A.3, L.U.C. 3.2.112.C 20. The Lot Coverage Calculation is incorrect. Provide a complete calculation. D.S. 2-02.2.A.3, L.U.C. 3.2.9.4 21. Define the "AREAS OF ASSEMBLY WHERE RELIGIOUS SERVICES ARE HELD" so that the parking calculation can be verified. Per L.U.C. 3.3.4 Religious Use one (1) space per five (5) fixed seats in all combined public assembly areas or one (1) space per fifty (50) sq. ft. of floor area assembly where religious services are held. Once the areas of assembly are defined then the parking calculation can be verified. D.S. 2-02.2.A.4 22. The bicycle calculation is based on the number of parking spaces provided. Based on the number of vehicle spaces provided 136 the required bicycle parking bicycle parking would be 10 Class 2 and 1 Class 1. Please revise the calculation. D.S. 2-02.2.A.4 23. Provide the percentage of building area expansion and vehicular use area expansion. (D.S. 2-02.2.A.6 24. The existing parking area along the east property line shows paving to be removed and the area to be revegetated, Keynote 26, leaving a 24' wide PAAL. Keynote 43 calls for Rollout Trash Containers. It appears take a refuse truck will need access to this area, but will not have a way to turn around, demonstrate maneuvering area. 25. A Board of Adjustment Variance may be required if the FAR & Lot Coverage exceed the allowed. LUC 3.2.9 & 3.2.11 26. Additional comments may be forth coming based on response to Zoning comments & the revised site plan. If you have any questions about this transmittal, please call Steve Shields, (520) 791-5608 ext. 1180. C:\planning\site\t04cm04619.doc RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised site plan and additional requested documents |
| 08/25/2006 | STEVE SHIELDS | ZONING HC SITE | REVIEW | Denied | See zoning comments. |
Final Status
| Task End Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 09/25/2006 | DELMA ROBEY | OUT TO CUSTOMER | Completed |
| 09/25/2006 | SUE REEVES | REJECT SHELF | Completed |