Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Permit Number: T04CM02415
Parcel: 120071980

Review Status: Completed

Review Details: REVISION - SITE

Permit Number - T04CM02415
Review Name: REVISION - SITE
Review Status: Completed
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
12/08/2006 MARTIN BROWN FIRE REVIEW Denied Exterior exit stairs at South propery line need fire need fire protection per IFC Chapter 7 and IRC. So does West wall of South unit.
12/13/2006 DAVID RIVERA ZONING HC SITE REVIEW Denied see zoning comments
12/13/2006 DAVID RIVERA ZONING REVIEW Denied DSD Zoning Review Transmittal

TO: Development Services Department Plans Coordination Office
FROM: David Rivera
Principal Planner

PROJECT: T06CM02415
143 W Palmdale St
Multifamily use - 2- SFRs

TRANSMITTAL DATE: December 13, 2006

The following comments are final that must be addressed either by Board of Adjustment variances or DSMR or both.

1. Building setbacks as noted in comment one 1.a - 1.e are based on the greatest of ten feet or the ¾ the height of the structure. Building elevations were not submitted as requested in the previous set of comments in order to verify the actual building heights to determine the setback deficiency. When submitting the documents to DSD for staff review, dimensioned building elevations must be included.

The setbacks as noted in comment 1.a - 1.e are final, based on the site plan review only.
LUC section 3.2.6.4, per the perimeter yard indicator BB a building setback based on the greatest of ten feet or ¾ the height of the building is required when adjacent to R-2 zoning (South, West and East perimeter yards)

2. The revision to the plan does not include five parking spaces as required. Therefore a variance for one parking space is required. LUC section 3.3.4 parking requirements for single family homes requires 2.25 spaces per residence. This site is developed with two single-family residences. A total of five parking spaces are required for this development. When more than four parking spaces are required the site must be developed with a parking lot. The parking lot must be designed to comply with development standards 3-05. See previous comment two for specifics related to parking lot requirements.



COMMENTS: This site has been reviewed for full code compliance. The following items must be addressed by the Board of Adjustment for variance approval.

1. The side yard building setbacks must be the greater of 10 feet or three-fourths the height of the structure. The required building setbacks could not be verified because building elevation drawings were not included with the site plan. Both buildings are existing and therefore the set backs are existing.
a. Building one: West Side yard setback must be a minimum of ten feet or three quarters the height of the structure. The owner proposes 5' (existing bldg. setback).
b. Building one: East Side yard bldg. setback must be a minimum of ten feet or three quarters the height of the structure. The owner proposes 6'-10" (existing bldg. setback).
c. Building two: West Side yard setback must be a minimum of ten feet or three quarters the height of the structure. The owner proposes 4'-4" (existing bldg. setback).
d. Building two: East Side yard setback must be a minimum of ten feet or three quarters the height of the structure. The owner proposes 0'-0" and 3'-6" (existing bldg. setbacks).
e. Building two: South Side yard setback must be a minimum of ten feet or three quarters the height of the structure. The owner proposes 4'-5" and 7'-0" (existing bldg. setback). Also a staircase has been built within the building setback and over an easement. (The staircase may have to be removed.) Fire safety concerns, Permits Plus comments by Dave Mann "Exterior exit stairs at South property line need fire protection per IFC Chapter 7 and IRC. So does West wall of South unit."

2. Parking for this development is based on the number of bedrooms per unit. Unit one is designed with five bedrooms and unit two is designed with six bedrooms. The parking requirements are as follows. For units with four or more bedrooms 2.5 spaces are required. The total number of parking spaces required (includes both units) is five spaces.


A minimum four-foot concrete sidewalk is required between the parking spaces and the building. Also the parking area will have to be paved and striped and wheel stops provided to keep vehicles from overhanging onto the sidewalk.

When more than four more parking spaces is provided on site the vehicular use area must be designed to meet the design criterion in Development standards 3-05. The design criteria include paving, striping, on site maneuvering area, two-way PAALs, landscaping, screening and pedestrian sidewalks. It is clear that the six parking spaces cannot be provided on site and that the on site maneuvering area, PAAL width, landscaping and screening cannot be provided. A variance to eliminate one parking space, on site maneuvering area, backing out onto the street, PAAL width, pedestrian sidewalks, possibly landscaping and screening will be required.

Additional comments by other reviewing agencies are likely and could affect the site and variance request items. Please address all possible comments and resubmit for final variance comments if necessary. Please keep in mind that the Board of Adjustments addresses only LUC requirements.



If you have any questions about this transmittal, please call David Rivera, (520) 791-5608.
12/18/2006 ANDREW CONNOR NPPO REVIEW Approved Exception
12/18/2006 ANDREW CONNOR LANDSCAPE REVIEW Denied Include with re-submittal approval documentation. Indicate on the lower right hand corner of the site plan, the variance case number, date of approval, and any conditions imposed.

1. The following requirements apply to developments, which provide and/or require more than 4 motor vehicle parking spaces per LUC 3.7.2.3.

2. A landscape plan per DS 2-07.0. to verify that entire site meets current minimum requirements.

3. A street landscape border, per LUC 3.7.2.4, is a landscape area with a minimum width of ten (10) feet, running the full length of the street property line(s) bounding the site except for points of ingress-egress.

4. Fifty (50) percent or more of the street landscape border area must have shrubs and vegetative ground cover per LUC 3.7.2.4

5. One (1) canopy tree must be provided for every thirty-three (33) linear feet of landscape border per LUC 3.7.2.4.

6. A 30" continuous screen along street frontages for vehicle use area must be provided per LUC Table 3.7.2-I.

7. An unpaved planting area, which is a minimum of thirty-four (34) square feet in area and four (4) feet in width, must be provided for each canopy tree per LUC 3.7.2.3.A.1.c. Indicate square footage of planter within vehicle use area.

8. Landscaping along parking lots where plants are susceptible to injury by vehicular traffic must be protected by appropriate means, such as curbs, bollards, or low walls per LUC 3.7.2.3.B. Provide protection for aforementioned canopy tree.
12/19/2006 JASON GREEN ENGINEERING REVIEW Denied DATE: December 19, 2006
SUBJECT: Remodel Apartments to Single Family Residence- 2nd Site Plan Review
TO: Kevin Petrick
LOCATION: 143 W Palmdale St., T14S R13E Sec36, Ward 5
REVIEWERS: Jason Green, CFM
ACTIVITY: T04CM02415


SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Development Services Department has received and reviewed the resubmitted site plan. The revised site plan was reviewed for Development Standards compliance. The site plan is not approved at this time. Please address the following comments:

SITE PLAN COMMENTS:

1) DS Sec.3-05: Provide an on-site vehicular use area designed to meet the criterion in this section. If the requirements for the vehicular use area can not be meet then a variance must be applied for to eliminate on-site maneuvering area, PAAL width, pedestrian sidewalks and other requirements found within this section.
2) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.11: Revise the site plan to label and show the maximum width for the shared ingress/egress location for the subject property per Chapter 29, Section 25-38 of the Tucson Code.
3) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.12: Revise the site plan to label and show the required 4-foot unobstructed pedestrian circulation path that must be located between the existing building and the parking area.
4) DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.12 & 2-08.3.0: Revise the site plan to label and show the required 4-foot minimum pedestrian circulation path that is required from the parking area to the pedestrian circulation path located along Palmdale Street.
5) DS Sec.3-01.2.7 A: Revise the site plan to reflect handicap access ramps with truncated domes that are required with the construction of the new 5-foot sidewalk located on Palmdale Street per ANSI Standards A117.1-2003 Section 406.13. Please refer to these standards and the figures provided for additional curb access ramps requirements.

GENERAL COMMENTS:

Please provide a revised site plan that address the comments provided above. Include a comprehensive response letter addressing in detail responses to all of the above comments.

Further comments may be generated upon resubmittal of the site plan.

For any questions or to schedule a meeting, call me at 791-5550, extension 1189.



Jason Green, CFM
Senior Engineer Associate
Engineering Division
Development Services

Final Status

Task End Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description
12/19/2006 CINDY AGUILAR OUT TO CUSTOMER Completed
12/19/2006 SUE REEVES REJECT SHELF Completed