Plan Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESUBMITTAL - CDRC - TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW
Plan Number - S07-033
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL - CDRC - TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/16/2008 | ELIZABETH EBERBACH | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Denied | TO: Patricia Gehlen; CDRC Coordinator Consultant: RICK Engineering SUBJECT: Starr Pass Vistas Village 2 Tentative Plat Engineering Resubmittal Review REVIEWER: Elizabeth Eberbach LOCATION: T14S R13E Section 16 ACTIVITY NUMBER: S07-033 SUMMARY: The revised Tentative Plat sheets, revised Drainage Report, ERR plans, schedules of title report, response letters, geotechnical letter with one addendum, and CC&R's were received by Engineering for review. The Drainage Report was reviewed for Tentative Plat purposes only. Engineering does not recommend approval of the Tentative Plat at this time. DRAINAGE COMMENTS: 1) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L: Address the remaining drainage report comments: a) Development Standard (DS) Sec.2-13.2.2.C.4: Regarding the proposed disturbance of the riparian floodplain for some lots and a road improvement, address the following remaining comment. Since the proposed lot development is not allowed to encroach the riparian floodplain area, show that each proposed lot has a viable buildable area by indicating a potential or proposed building area that would include the area needed to accommodate appurtenances and a footprint of a house that is a reasonable product for this type of subdivision. If a typical footprint can not fit within the restrictions of a lot (floodplain or otherwise), lot lines may need to be revised. A note may be added to state this is an approximate location so as not to restrict the future buyer rather to show feasibility of potential lot development. Accessory structures should be clarified as well. It is unclear whether this plat proposes crossing of the 404 or other riparian floodplains for future gazebos or other secondary structures; add a general note to clarify. b) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L.2: Some FFE's are shown too low, or are missing; provide a table for the minimum proposed finished floor elevations for lots 3, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 16, 17, 23, 24, 42, and 43 to assure they meet minimum FFE floodplain requirements adjacent to washes. c) General Note 9 indicates lots 21 is affected by floodplain- clarify. d) DS Sec.10-02.8.5.1: Provide WSEL at downstream side of SRP's. e) LUC 3.7.4: Surface stormwater should be directed into the landscape areas to promote water harvesting surface drainage. Further explain in drainage report and on landscape plans how water harvesting will be accomplished to the maximum extent possible and whether drainage from lots are to be discharged into water harvesting areas prior to discharge into wash. Show how stormwater will be directed toward the water harvesting areas. Consult the Water Harvesting Guidance Manual (Adopted October 18, 2005) for design guidelines. The manual is available online at http://dot.tucsonaz.gov/stormwater/downloads/2006WaterHarvesting.pdf The landscape plans shall reflect response letter discussion of water harvesting at basins, culverts, and road side swales. f) Tucson Code Sec.29-15(b)(1)f: Regarding 404 compliance statement sheet, address the following: i) In legend or label on plat, delineation of the 404 areas that are to be avoided. ii) Provide jurisdictional exhibit / documentation from Army Corps of Engineers for this project referenced in 404 compliance statement. g) The response letter states that the maintenance list should be revised by the City of Tucson. Any table provided by the City is a sample from other projects to assist consultants with addressing maintenance design questions. Each EOR is responsible for designing their own basin maintenance charts. For drainage maintenance section, provide additional column for proposed solutions for condition in table. 2) Drainage response letter shall be added to the verbiage in the drainage report or added as a registrant's sealed letter. TENTATIVE PLAT COMMENTS: 3) DS Sec.2-03.2.3.A: For survey and boundary data, address the remaining comments: a) DS Sec.2-03.2.1.J: Clarify locations and make legible all survey monuments to be set and found. The symbol for found monuments appear to be the same for the monuments to be set; differentiate any as to be set or label all found monuments on planview. b) Boundary data needs to match title report exhibit, provide title report exhibit legal description. c) For grading plan review, a local benchmark must be provided and shown on planview. 4) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.J: Response letter states there are no private drainage maintenance easement areas however there are many locations of private slope and drainage easements shown on planview for this submittal. Unless clarified, it will be assumed these are private and not public easements. 5) DS Sec.11-01: Address the remaining conceptual grading design questions: a) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L.2: Some FFE's are shown too low, or are missing; check minimum proposed finished floor elevations for lots 3, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 16, 17, 23, 24, 42, and 43 to assure they meet minimum FFE floodplain requirements adjacent to washes. b) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.M: Provide revised geotechnical report or addenda that addresses the remaining comments: i) Provide Infiltration test results from the 4 infiltration tests shown on boring location maps. ii) Provide geotechnical recommendations for minimum setbacks from basins and show on the planview sheets. c) Per D.S. 2-03.2.4.K: Revise typical lot grading details on sheet 5 to reflect custom lot graded lot product. Clarify by labeling the "minimum" setbacks. The minimum side and rear setbacks, building setbacks to swales shall reflect recommendations per geotechnical report and addenda. An addendum to Terracon Project No.63055135 was submitted referencing a grading plan. For resubmittal, the geotechnical engineer shall resubmit the addendum with attachment for the referenced document. Other typical lot grading information should be provided (including: minimum slope around building and detail for side yard swale location with dimensions). OVERLAY COMMENTS: 6) LUC Sec.2.8.1: Per Hillside Development Zone, address the following comments for the HDZ submittal: a) LUC Sec.2.8.1.6: With the HDZ Overlay package, submit an HDZ Plan including the calculations and content specified in DS Sec.2-12.2.0 and LUC table 2.8.1.I. including but not limited to the following comments for the HDZ exhibit sheet: i) Show 15% slope areas. ii) Label any delineated HDZ undisturbed open spaces. iii) After providing calculation for ACS, provide applicable data per columns A, B, C, and D of table 2.8.1.I. b) Update General Note 28. 7) Discuss proposed crossing in the ERR Report-plan. The next submittal should address all the above items. Submit revised Tentative Plat, a bound copy of the geotechnical report with any addenda, revised Drainage Report, title report, revised ERR plans, and response letter. Prior to resubmittal, you may schedule a meeting with me to go over your comments. If you have any questions, please call me at 837-4934. Elizabeth Eberbach, PE Civil Engineer Engineering Division Development Services |
| 01/17/2008 | PATRICIA GEHLEN | ZONING-DECISION LETTER | REVIEW | Denied | COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES January 17, 2008 Mirela Hromatka Rick Engineering Company, Inc. 1745 East River Road, Suite 101 Tucson, Arizona 85718 Subject: S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II Tentative Plat Dear Mirela: Your submittal of November 16, 2007 for the above project has been reviewed by the Community Design Review Committee and the comments reflect the outstanding requirements which need to be addressed before approval is granted. Please review the comments carefully. Once you have addressed all of the comments, please submit the following revised documents and a DETAILED cover letter explaining how each outstanding requirement has been addressed: ALL BLACKLINES MUST BE FOLDED 5 Copies Revised Tentative Plat (Zoning, Landscape, DUPD, Engineering, DSD) 5 Copies Revised Landscape Plan (Zoning, Landscape, DUPD, Engineering, DSD) 2 Copies Bound Geotechnical Report (Engineering, DSD) 2 Copies Environmental Resource Report and Mitigation Plan (Landscape, DSD) 2 Copies Revised Drainage Report (Engineering, DSD) 2 Copies Title Report (Engineering, DSD) Should you have any questions, please call me at 837-4919. Sincerely, Patricia Gehlen CDRC Manager All comments for this case are available on our website at http://www.ci.tucson.az.us/dsd/ Via fax: 322-6956 |
| 11/16/2007 | FERNE RODRIGUEZ | START | PLANS SUBMITTED | Completed | |
| 11/21/2007 | FRODRIG2 | PIMA COUNTY | WASTEWATER | Approved | November 21, 2007 To: Mirela Hromatka Rick Engineering Thru: Patricia Gehlen, CDRC Manager City of Tucson Development Services Department ___________________________ From: Tom Porter, Sr. CEA (520-740-6579), representing the Pima County Departments of Wastewater Management and Environment Quality Subject: Starr Pass Vistas Village II, Lots 1-43 & Common Areas "A" & "B-1"- "B-4" & "C-1" - "C-2" An RCP Subdivision Tent. Plat - 2nd Submittal S07-033 The proposed sewer collection lines for the above-referenced project have been reviewed on behalf of the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality (PDEQ) and the Pima County Wastewater Management Department (PCWMD). This review letter may contain comments pertaining to the concerns of either Department. The following comments are offered for your use. The Pima County Department of Environmental Quality and Wastewater Management Department hereby approve the above referenced submittal of the tentative or preliminary plat as submitted. Please note the following: Approval of the above referenced submittal does not authorize the construction of public or private sewer collection lines, or water distribution lines. Prior to the construction of such features, a Construction Authorization (Approval To Construct) may need to be obtained from the Pima County Environmental Quality. Also, air quality activity permits must be secured by the developer or prime contractor from the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality before constructing, operating or engaging in an activity which may cause or contribute to air pollution. If you have any questions regarding the above-mentioned comments, please contact me. |
| 11/27/2007 | DAVID RIVERA | ZONING | REVIEW | Denied | CDRC TRANSMITTAL TO: Development Services Department Plans Coordination Office FROM: Karol Aragonez Planner PROJECT: S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II Tentative Plat TRANSMITTAL DATE: March 27, 2007 DUE DATE: April 2, 2007 COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed. 1. Previous comment: The required perimeter yard setback for lots adjacent to Greasewood Road and Starr Pass Boulevard will be six (6) feet from interior lot lines. This provides a greater setback than the MS&R setback, which would place the required setback within the landscape border. Please show and label the six (6) foot setback on the plan view on sheet 3 of 4. This should also be noted in the perimeter yard tabulations on sheet 1 of 4. DS 2-10.3.1.A, LUC 1.2.2, & LUC 3.6.1.4.D.2.d.2 When common area separates lots from adjacent MS&R the interior setback of six (6) in this case is used if it provides a greater perimeter setback than what is required for a M&R right-of-way. Please indicate on the plan view and tabulations on sheet 1. 2. The cover sheet of the CC&Rs should reflect the name including lot number and common areas. This can be submitted at time of final plat review. 3. Once the overlay application has been reviewed and approved by Engineering and Landscaping zoning can approve. The tentative plat cannot be approved until the special application is approved. If you have any questions about this transmittal, please call David Rivera, (520) 791-5608. KAA S:\zoning review\karol\planning\cdrc\tentativeplat\S07-033tpr.doc RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised tentative plat, CC&R's and additional requested documents. |
| 12/07/2007 | JOSE ORTIZ | COT NON-DSD | TRAFFIC | Approved | |
| 12/07/2007 | KAY MARKS | PIMA COUNTY | ADDRESSING | Approved | 201 N. STONE AV., 1ST FL TUCSON, AZ 85701-1207 KAY MARKS ADDRESSING OFFICIAL PH: 740-6480 FAX #: 740-6370 TO: CITY PLANNING FROM: KAY MARKS, ADDRESSING OFFICIAL SUBJECT: S07-033 STARR PASS VISTAS VILLAGE II/REVISED TENTATIVE PLAT DATE: 12/06/07 The above referenced project has been reviewed by this Division for all matters pertaining to street naming/addressing, and we hereby approve this project. ***The Pima County Addressing Section can use digital CAD drawing files when submitted with your final plat Mylar. These CAD files can be submitted through Pima County Addressing. The digital CAD drawing files expedite the addressing and permitting processes when we are able to insert this digital data into the County’s Geographic Information System. Your support is greatly appreciated.*** ES |
| 12/10/2007 | JOE LINVILLE | LANDSCAPE | REVIEW | Denied | 1) Privately owned individual residential lots that are greater than 24,000 square feet may include Protected Riparian Area where the Protected Riparian Area is delineated on the plat providing a surveyed description of the location within each lot, and there is a note on the plat requiring that each purchaser of a lot shall sign a disclosure form acknowledging the prohibition upon development in the Protected Riparian Area and no walls or fences are constructed within the Protected Riparian Areas. Revise the tentative plat to add the note regarding the required disclosure. 2) Revise the landscape plans to include provisions for general revegetation and dust control per LUC 3.7.2.7 for disturbed portions of the project site and critical habitat areas. LUC 2.8.6.6.A.7 RESUBMITTAL OF THE TENTATIVE PLANT AND LANDSCAPE PLANS IS REQUIRED. |
| 12/11/2007 | GLENN HICKS | COT NON-DSD | PARKS & RECREATION | Approved | DATE: December 10, 2007 TO: Ferne Rodriguez, Development Services FROM: Glenn Hicks Parks and Recreation 791-4873 ext. 215 Glenn.Hicks@tucsonaz.gov CC: SUBJECT: S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II: Tentative Plat Review(11-16-07) Approved. |
| 12/12/2007 | JIM EGAN | COT NON-DSD | FIRE | Approved | |
| 12/17/2007 | ANDY VERA | ENV SVCS | REVIEW | Approved | 1. Approved for APC refuse and recycle curbside collection service. Adequate street frontage access and maneuverability within development. |
| 12/24/2007 | ROGER HOWLETT | COT NON-DSD | COMMUNITY PLANNING | Denied | DEPARTMENT OF URBAN PLANNING & DESIGN COMMENTS Regarding SUBJECT: Community Design Review Committee Application CASE NUMBER: CASE NAME: DATE SENT S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II 12/21/07 (X) Tentative Plat () Development Plan (X) Landscape Plan () Revised Plan/Plat () Board of Adjustment () Other CROSS REFERENCE: Starr Pass Vistas Book 58, Page 20 NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN: Tumamoc Area Plan GATEWAY/SCENIC ROUTE: NO COMMENTS DUE BY: 12/17/07 SUBJECT DEVELOPMENT PLAN/PLAT HAS BEEN REVIEWED BY COMMUNITY PLANNING AND PRESERVATION, AND STAFF SUBMITS THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS: () No Annexation or Rezoning Conditions, Not an RCP - No Comment () Proposal Complies with Annexation or Rezoning Conditions () RCP Proposal Complies with Plan Policies (X) See Additional Comments Attached () No Additional Comments - Complies With Planning Comments Submitted on: (X) Resubmittal Required: (X) Tentative Plat () Development Plan (X) Landscape Plan () Other REVIEWER: msp 791-4505 DATE: 12/17/07 Department of Urban Planning and Design (DUPD) S07-033, Starr Pass Vistas Village II: Tentative Plat Review December 17, 2007 DUPD previous comments have not been adequately addressed and therefore the proposed tentative plat (resubmitted) is not in compliance with staff’s first comments provided in April of 2007. The following staff comments still need to be addressed: 1. As per Land Use Code section 3.6.1.4.A.1., a residential development utilizing the RCP option must be in conformance with the design policies and criteria of the General Plan and any of its components, including adopted area and neighborhood plans. This site is within the bounds of the Tumamoc Area Plan (TAP), Subarea 4. A criteria within Subarea 4, under Natural Features Policy 1.c, states; Major washes, including the Silvercroft Wash should be left in their natural state unless there is a threat to private property or personal safety. Wash buffer zones should be provided, and wash and drainage treatment should be consistent with the intent to maintain natural areas and conservation linkages. The wash buffer zone is defined in the TAP as; A setback area bordering a wash that is predominantly NUOS, the buffer adds additional protection to an area equivalent to one-half the width of the wash on either side of the wash, not less than 25 feet wide, as measured from the edge of the 100-year floodplain. The wash buffer zone is a no –development/no-encroachment area. The wash buffer zone is not a land use zone adopted by the Land Use Code. It is derived from Plan policy In addition, the Silvercroft Wash is an ERZ Wash, which is subject to the Watercourse Ordinance adopted on November 7, 2006. Therefore, please revise the tentative plat and the landscape plan to comply with the City of Tucson Watercourse Ordinance, resolution No. 20505, and the Floodplain, Wash and Environmental Resource Zone (ERZ) Standards. In addition, the tentative plat and landscape plan shall comply with the Tumamoc Area Plan Policy which requests a wash buffer zone as outlined above. Therefore, based the above mentioned information, revise tentative plat and landscape plan to identify those portions of the ERZ Wash, including protected riparian areas outside of the 100 year floodplain limits, as common areas/natural undisturbed open space, as may be approved by the Office of Conservation and Sustainable Development (OCSD). Staff at OCSD may be reached at 837-6932. As part of the DUPD approval, please provide copy of letter made reference to (Department of Parks and Recreation, dated 4/11/07), as it relates to Local Trail # 136 (identified in the Eastern Pima County Trail System Master Plan for Silvercroft Wash). Tumamoc Area Plan, Design Guideline 8 states that, Wash buffer zones should be protected from the impact of pet and human activity by construction of fencing or walls. Access from individual lots to conservation areas is discouraged. Pedestrian access should be only from a common access point. Based the above policy, please revise tentative plat and/or landscape plan to show location of walls or fences that will create a barrier between the ERZ Wash and the adjacent residential lots. Pedestrian access is encouraged in natural areas of the site when recreational amenities are approved as part of natural area amenities. However in this case, the required Local Trail # 136 is proposed beyond the boundaries of the site and based on this new information staff does not support human/pet activity within the natural undisturbed open space of the ERZ wash. 4. Again, DUPD staff recommends that prior to resubmitting, for the applicant to contact the Office of Conservation and Sustainable Development at 837-6932 to discuss the revisions/requirements as outlined in this and the prior review, as it pertains to compliance with Watercourse and ERZ Wash Ordinance requirements. |