Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Plan Number: S07-033
Parcel: Unknown

Review Status: Completed

Review Details: TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW

Plan Number - S07-033
Review Name: TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW
Review Status: Completed
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
03/05/2007 FERNE RODRIGUEZ START PLANS SUBMITTED Completed
03/08/2007 JIM EGAN COT NON-DSD FIRE Denied Provide a cross section for the islands in the entry roads. The width must be 20 feet clear and the height 15 feet clear.

All of the lots except 6, 22, 23, 27, 28 and 42 will require automatic fire sprinklers because of buildable areas over 150 feet from the fire lane. If all the units in the sub-division are sprinklered the hydrant spacing can be increased. Please contact David Mann at 791-3234 for more information.
03/09/2007 TOM MARTINEZ OTHER AGENCIES AZ DEPT TRANSPORTATION Approved NO COMMENT
S07-033
RICK ENGINEERING CO, INC.
STARR PASS VISTAS VILLAGE II

--------------------------------------------------------


Confidentiality and Nondisclosure Notice: This email transmission and any attachments are intended for use by the person(s)/entity(ies) named above and may contain confidential/privileged information. Any unauthorized use, disclosure or distribution is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by email, and delete or destroy all copies plus attachments.
03/09/2007 DBELL1 LANDFILL ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Approved
03/15/2007 KAROL ARAGONEZ ZONING REVIEW Denied CDRC TRANSMITTAL

TO: Development Services Department Plans Coordination Office

FROM: Karol Aragonez
Planner

PROJECT: S07-033
Starr Pass Vistas Village II
Tentative Plat

TRANSMITTAL DATE: March 27, 2007

DUE DATE: April 2, 2007

COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed.

1. Section 4.1.7.1, LUC, permits a maximum of one year from the date of application to obtain approval of a tentative plat. If, at the end of that time, the tentative plat has not been approved, it must be revised to be in compliance with all regulations in effect at that time, and must be resubmitted for a full CDRC review. The one-year expiration date for this tentative plat is March 4, 2008.

2. Case number S07-033 has been assigned to this development plan (DP). Please place this number in the right corner of all sheets of the development plan, landscape plan, NPPO, and any other associated sheets.
DS 2-03.2.2.B.1

3. Please add general note 3 that Family Dwelling is Subject to LUC Sec. 3.5.7.1.F.
DS 2-03.2.2.B.5

4. Please add to general note 6 LUC Sec. 2.8.6, Environmental Resource Zone (ERZ).
DS 2-03.2.2.B.7

5. Please draw all existing easements on the plan along with recordation information, location, width, and purpose. If an easement is no longer in use and scheduled to be vacated or has been abandoned, so indicate. If none exist provide response to reviewer's comments. Also if easements are purposed please draw, dimension and label as to their purpose and whether they will be public or private. If none exist provide response to reviewer's comments.
DS 2-03.2.3.C & DS 2-03.2.4.J

6. Please provide the type and dimensioned width of existing paving, curbs, curb cuts, and sidewalks within Greasewood Road and Starr Pass Boulevard.
DS 2-03.2.3.D

7. A separate Special Application, review, and approval for the Hillside Development Zone (HDZ) and Environmental Resource Zone (ERZ) overlay is required. For more information the applicant must contact Patricia Gehlen at 791-5608 ext 1179. The application form is on the DSD website at http://www.tucsonaz.gov/dsd/Forms_Fees___Maps/Applications/Overlay_Zone_Application.pdf

8. The street cross section provided on sheet 5 of 5 does not meet the minimum standards for a residential cluster project (RCP). Within a RCP site improvements include, but are not limited to, streets, curbs, sidewalks, parking areas, and utilities. The pedestrian circulation system must be physically separated from the vehicular circulation system, except where the system intersects a PAAL or street. The typical cross section is to provide at a minimum twenty (20) foot wide travel lane (2-10 foot); wedge or vertical curbing; seven (7) or eight (8) foot wide parking lanes; and five (5) foot wide sidewalks. Please refer to DS 3-01.10.0 Figure 2.
LUC 3.6.1.4.G.2 & H and DS 3-01.10.0 Figure 2

9. Streets within the RCP site must be designed for parking lanes on both sides to accommodate proposed visitor parking at a ratio of one space per 0.25 dwelling units, unless common parking areas are proposed at a ratio of 1:1. All visitor parking must be evenly distributed through out the subdivision. Please indicate on the street cross section parking lanes on both sides.
LUC 3.6.1.4.F, LUC 3.3.4 Residential, and DS 2-03.2.4.G

10. The required perimeter yard setback for lots adjacent to Greasewood Road and Starr Pass Boulevard will be six (6) feet from interior lot lines. This provides a greater setback than the MS&R setback, which would place the required setback within the landscape border. Please show and label the six (6) foot setback on the plan view on sheet 3 of 4. This should also be noted in the perimeter yard tabulations on sheet 1 of 4.
DS 2-10.3.1.A, LUC 1.2.2, & LUC 3.6.1.4.D.2.d.2

11. Please provide the names of the proposed streets internal to the subdivision.
DS 2-03.2.4.F

12. Along interior lot lines for detached dwellings, the minimum separation between a dwelling unit and interior lot line is six (6) feet in RX-2 zoned property. Please revise lot typicals for interior and corner lots to reflect this dimension.
LUC 3.6.1.4.D.2.d.2

13. The maximum allowed height within property designated as HDZ twenty-four (24) feet. Please revise maximum height allowed and maximum height proposed on sheet 1 of 5.

14. The project site is within the Tumamoc Area Plan. Please submit to the Department of Urban Planning and Design, plans showing how the RCP will comply with design requirements of the Plan as required by LUC Sec. 3.6.1.4.A.1.
DS 2-10.3.2.B

15. Please provide three (3) copies of the CC&Rs to allow for review of responsibility for the ownership and maintenance of commonly owned property.
DS 2-10.3.2.E

16. The RCP shall be designed so that any potentially adverse impacts from yards, balconies, courts, landscaping, lighting, or noise producing activities are mitigated within the RCP.
LUC 3.6.1.4.A.8

17. Please provide a detail as to how screening of the mechanical equipment is done. If ground mounted and screened by property walls please provide note stating that. If roof mounted provide a detail showing how screening will be architecturally integrated with the overall design of the RCP.
LUC 3.6.1.4.A.9

18. Bus turn-outs lanes and bus waiting shelters must be provided if requested by the City of Tucson.
LUC 3.6.1.4.A.7

19. All changes, modifications, and/or corrections must be made on all applicable plans including the development plan, landscape plan, and NPPO. Once changes, modifications, and/or corrections are made and reviewed further comments may result.


If you have any questions about this transmittal, please call Karol Aragonez, (520) 791-5550, ext. 1197.

KAA S:\zoning review\karol\planning\cdrc\tentativeplat\S07-033tp.doc

RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised tentative plat, CC&R's and additional requested documents.
03/27/2007 JOSE ORTIZ COT NON-DSD TRAFFIC Denied March 27, 2007
ACTIVITY NUMBER: S07-033
PROJECT NAME: Starr Pass Vistas Village II
PROJECT ADDRESS: Nwc Starr Pass Blvd/Greasewood Rd
PROJECT REVIEWER: Jose E. Ortiz PE, Traffic Engineer

Resubmittal Required: Traffic Engineering does not recommend approval of the Tentative Plat; therefore a revised Tentative Plat is required for re-submittal.

The following items must be revised or added to the plat.

1. Include a response letter with the next submittal that states how all comments have been addressed.

2. Consider aligning the proposed roadway entering off of Starr Pass with the roadway south of Starr Pass (Park West Lane).

3. Provide a traffic Impact Analysis (category 1) or a Traffic Statement to address possible off-site improvements such as right-turn/decel lane along Starr Pass BLVD, and/or a left-turn lane along Greasewood RD.

4. A permit or a private improvement agreement will be necessary for any work performed within the Right-of-way. Contact Permits and Codes at (520) 791-5100 for permit information.


If you have any questions, I can be reached at 791-4259 x76730 or Jose.Ortiz@tucsonaz.gov
03/29/2007 LIZA CASTILLO UTILITIES TUCSON ELECTRIC POWER Approved 4350 E. Irvington Road, Tucson, AZ 85714
Post Office Box 711, Tucson, AZ 85702


WR#178628 March 29, 2007


Rick Engineering Company, Inc
Attn: Mirela Hromatka
1745 E River Road, Suite 101
Tucson, AZ 85718


Dear Ms. Hromatka:

SUBJECT: Starr Pass Vistas Village II
Lots Starr Pass Blvd and Greasewood Rd
S07-033

Tucson Electric Power Company (TEP) has no objection to the preliminary plat submitted for review March 7, 2007

Enclosed is TEP facilities map showing the approximate location of the existing facilities. The copy of the tentative plat showing where TEP will be placing the aboveground equipment for this subdivision will be mailed to you under separate cover.

Possible feed from poles 10, 11 on Greasewood, or PME STAR-109, PB STAR-113 on Starr Pass. Facilities are within the Road Right of Way.

TEP will provide a preliminary electrical design on the Approved Tentative Plat within fifteen (15) working days upon receipt of the plat. Additional plans necessary for preparation of the design are: building plans including water, electrical, landscape, sidewalk and paving plans. Also, submit the AutoCAD version of the plat on a CD or email to lmiranda@tep.com. Should you have any questions, please contact the area designer, Ron Grant at (520) 918- 8212.


Sincerely,



Elizabeth Miranda
Office Specialist
Design/Build
lm
Enclosures
cc: P. Gehlen and F. Rodriguez, City of Tucson (e-mail)
D. Sloane, Title Security Agency of Arizona (Letter only)
R. Grant, Tucson Electric Power
03/29/2007 ANDY VERA ENV SVCS REVIEW Approv-Cond * Cul-de-sacs do not appear to meet the minimum requirement for the paved turnaround of 42 ft radius per DS 3-01.6.2.C.1.c
Must demonstrate 42 ft radius.

* Curbside refuse and recycle service with automated plastic containers (APC) would be provided from available frontage access.
03/29/2007 LIZA CASTILLO UTILITIES TUCSON ELECTRIC POWER Approved 4350 E. Irvington Road, Tucson, AZ 85714
Post Office Box 711, Tucson, AZ 85702


WR# 178628 May 16, 2007


Rick Engineering Company
Attn: Mirela Hromatka
1745 E River Rd, Suite 101
Tucson, Arizona 85718


Dear Ms. Hromatka :

SUBJECT: Starr Pass Vistas Village II - Resubmittal
Lots 1-44
S07-033

Please find enclosed the tentative plat showing where TEP will be placing the aboveground equipment for this subdivision. This is not a preliminary design. TEP has provided this drawing to show where the proposed locations are for transformers, pedestals, secondary and primary. Feed from existing pole on the east side of Greasewood and new 3 phase junction box, J-2, fed from an existing PMH-11, STAR-109. This J-2 will also feed Village I loop.

TEP will provide a preliminary electrical design on the Approved Tentative Plat within Twenty (20) working days upon receipt of the plat. Additional plans necessary for preparation of the design are: building plans including water, electrical, landscape, sidewalk and paving plans. Any relocation costs will be billable to the customer. Also, submit the AutoCAD version of the plat on a CD or email to kclark@tep.com. Should you have any questions, please contact the Designer for this project Ron Grant 917-8712.




Sincerely,



Elizabeth Miranda
Office Specialist
Design/Build
lm
Enclosures
cc: Diane Sloane, Title Security of Arizona (Letter only)
Ron Grant, Tucson Electric Power Company
03/30/2007 FRODRIG2 COT NON-DSD REAL ESTATE Approved S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II: Tentative Plat Review - No comment.
04/02/2007 KAY MARKS PIMA COUNTY ADDRESSING Denied 201 N. STONE AV., 1ST FL
TUCSON, AZ 85701-1207

KAY MARKS
ADDRESSING OFFICIAL
PH: 740-6480
FAX #: 740-6370


TO: CITY PLANNING
FROM: KAY MARKS, ADDRESSING OFFICIAL
SUBJECT: S07-033 STARR PASS VISTAS VILLAGE II/TENTATIVE PLAT
DATE: 4/02/07



The above referenced project has been reviewed by this Division for all matters pertaining to street naming/addressing, and the following matters must be resolved prior to our approval:

Label approved interior street names on Final Plat.

Spell out all street suffixes on page 4.

All books and pages will need to be filled in before this plat records.

Change Starr Shadow Dr. to Star Shadow Drive on page 4.


es
04/03/2007 JOE LINVILLE LANDSCAPE REVIEW Denied 1) Add the CDRC case number and any related case numbers to the landscape and native plant preservation plans.
DS 2-07.2.1.B

2) The site contains regulatory floodplain areas that may contain riparian habitat. This habitat may not unnecessarily altered per TCC Sec. 26-5.2. Refer to DS 2-13 for the preparation, submittal, and review procedures for development within areas that have environmentally valuable habitat in conformance with Article 1, Division 1, Floodplain and Erosion Hazard Area Regulations.

3) Submit an Environmental Resource Report (ERR) per DS 2-13.2.5.B.1. The report will document (1) the areas that contain riparian and wildlife habitat that is to be preserved and (2) those areas without such habitat within the regulatory floodplain.

4) All tentative plats, development plans, site plans, plot plans or other plans providing for approval of development within property that includes any Regulated Area as defined in Development Standard 2-13.2.2.A shall identify and delineate the Regulated Areas and the Protected Riparian Area ( SEE COMMENT 9). Revise the tentative plat as necessary.

5) All development within the Protected Riparian Area shall be reviewed to insure that there is no unnecessary disturbance of the riparian resources. Refer to DS 2-13.2.5.B.2 for the section on Development Restrictions and revise the plans as necessary to comply.

6) Where any development encroaches within the Protected Riparian Areas, mitigation will be required. A mitigation report shall be submitted with the Environmental Resource Report demonstrating that the proposed mitigation is in conformance with this subsection and applicable codes. DS 2-13.2.5.C

7) Landscape plans are required to document compliance with the mitigation plan requirements. A summary of mitigation and preservation requirements shall be included on the plans. The plans shall show the location of mitigation areas; techniques used for mitigating impacts to, or preservation of, natural areas; specifications for restoration and revegetation of disturbed areas; and general compliance with the applicable standards. Revise as necessary.


8) Encroachments that cross the Protected Riparian Area shall be located and constructed to minimize disturbance of the habitat and wildlife movement and utilities will be placed either in proposed or existing public right of way along roadway, bike path, or paved walkway improvements or within approved easements. Discuss the location of the sewer crossing of the floodplain in the ERR. Locate the sewer (see Common Area B-1) in the proposed street if possible to minimize disturbance. DS 2-13.2.5.B.2

9) Privately owned individual residential lots that are greater than 24,000 square feet may include Protected Riparian Area where the Protected Riparian Area is delineated on the plat providing a surveyed description of the location within each lot, and there is a note on the plat requiring that each purchaser of a lot shall sign a disclosure form acknowledging the prohibition upon development in the Protected Riparian Area and (iii) no walls or fences are constructed within the Protected Riparian Areas. Revise the tentative plat as necessary.

10) All lettering and dimensions shall be the equivalent of twelve (0.12") point or greater in size per DS 2-05.2.1.A. Revise all plans as necessary.

11) Revise the Tentative & Final Plats and the Native Plant Preservation Plans to include a statement regarding the requirements for an individual Native Plant Preservation Plan for each lot subsequently developed. No grubbing, grading, construction, or salvaging of any plants on the site shall take place prior to the submittal and approval of the required Native Plant Preservation Plan. LUC 3.8.4.2.

12) Revise the Native Plant Preservation Plans to show the regulatory floodplains correctly and delineate and label the Protected Riparian Areas. No grubbing, grading, or construction will occur on a project site which includes areas designated as Protected Riparian Area to be retained in a natural state until those designated areas are temporarily fenced.

13) Revise NPPP sheet 4 to refer to the COT DSD Landscape Inspector, rather than the Parks and Recreation inspector. LUC 3.8.6.7

14) ERZ note 1 on sheet 1 of the Native Plant Preservation Plan indicates that the wash buffer zone shall not be disturbed. Describe or show the buffer zone on the plans.

15) The set-aside submittal approved for Starr Pass Vistas Plat is recorded at Book 58, Page 20. Revise the reference to Book 44, page 60 on sheet 1 of the NPPP.

16) Revise note 6 on sheet 1 of the tentative plat to include ERZ. DS 2-03.2.2.B.7


RESUBMITTAL OF ALL PLANS IS REQUIRED. IN ADDITION AN ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCE REPORT AND MITIGATION PLAN ARE REQUIRED.
04/05/2007 ED ABRIGO PIMA COUNTY ASSESSOR Approved Office of the Pima County Assessor


115 N. Church Ave.


Tucson, Arizona 85701



BILL STAPLES

ASSESSOR










TO: CDRC Office

Subdivision Review

City of Tucson (FAX# 791-5559)



FROM: Gary Ault, Mapping Supervisor

Pima County Assessor's Office

Mapping Department



DATE: April 4, 2007





RE: Assessor's Review and Comments Regarding Tentative Plat

S07-033 STARR PASS VISTAS VILLAGE II T141316





* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *



X Plat meets Assessor's Office requirements.

_______ Plat does not meet Assessor's Office requirements.





COMMENTS: PLEASE MAKE THE FOLLOWING ADJUSTMENTS BY FINAL PLAT STAGE:

1. ADD BEARINGS AMD COMPLETE CURVE DATA.



THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUBMITTAL. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE CALL
ROSANNA WERNER AT 740-4390



NOTE: THE ASSESSOR'S CURRENT INVOLVEMENT IN PROCESSING ITS MANUAL MAPS
TO DIGITAL FORMAT IS EXPEDITED GREATLY BY EXCHANGE OF DIGITAL DATA. IN
THE COURSE OF RECORDING THIS SUBDIVISION YOUR ASSISTANCE IN PROVIDING
THIS OFFICE WITH AN AUTOCAD COPY WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED. THANK
YOU FOR ANY DIGITAL DATA PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED.









ROSANNA WERNER
04/09/2007 PGEHLEN1 TUCSON WATER NEW AREA DEVELOPMENT REVIEW Passed
04/10/2007 ROGER HOWLETT COT NON-DSD COMMUNITY PLANNING Denied DEPARTMENT OF URBAN PLANNING & DESIGN COMMENTS

Regarding

SUBJECT: Community Design Review Committee Application

CASE NUMBER: CASE NAME: DATE SENT

S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II 04/09/07

(X) Tentative Plat
() Development Plan
(X) Landscape Plan
() Revised Plan/Plat
() Board of Adjustment
() Other

CROSS REFERENCE: Starr Pass Vistas Book 58, Page 20

NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN: Tumamoc Area Plan

GATEWAY/SCENIC ROUTE: NO

COMMENTS DUE BY: 4/2/07

SUBJECT DEVELOPMENT PLAN/PLAT HAS BEEN REVIEWED BY COMMUNITY PLANNING AND PRESERVATION, AND STAFF SUBMITS THE FOLLOWING COMMENTS:

() No Annexation or Rezoning Conditions, Not an RCP - No Comment
() Proposal Complies with Annexation or Rezoning Conditions
() RCP Proposal Complies with Plan Policies
(X) See Additional Comments Attached
() No Additional Comments - Complies With Planning Comments Submitted on:
(X) Resubmittal Required:
(X) Tentative Plat
() Development Plan
(X) Landscape Plan
() Other



REVIEWER: msp 791-4505 DATE: 4/2/07
Department of Urban Planning and Design
S07-033, Starr Pass Vistas Village II: Tentative Plat Review
April 2, 2007

Staff offers the following comments:

Prior to resubmitting, staff recommends the applicant contact Ann Audrey from the Office of Conservation and Sustainable Development to discuss the revisions/requirements outlined below as it pertains to compliance with Watercourse and ERZ Wash Ordinances. Ms. Audrey may be reached at (520) 791-4505.

As per Land Use Code section 3.6.1.4.A.1., a residential development utilizing the RCP option must be in conformance with the design policies and criteria of the General Plan and any of its components, including adopted area and neighborhood plans. This site is within the bounds of the Tumamoc Area Plan (TAP), Subarea 4. A criteria within Subarea 4, under Natural Features Policy 1.c, states;

Major washes, including the Silvercroft Wash should be left in their natural state unless there is a threat to private property or personal safety. Wash buffer zones should be provided, and wash and drainage treatment should be consistent with the intent to maintain natural areas and conservation linkages.

The wash buffer zone is defined in the TAP as;
A setback area bordering a wash that is predominantly NUOS … the buffer adds additional protection to an area equivalent to one-half the width of the wash on either side of the wash, not less than 25 feet wide, as measured from the edge of the 100-year floodplain. The wash buffer zone is a no –development/no-encroachment area. The wash buffer zone is not a land use zone adopted by the Land Use Code. It is derived from Plan policy

In addition, the Silvercroft Wash is an ERZ Wash, which is subject to the Watercourse Ordinance adopted on November 7, 2006.

Therefore, please revise the tentative plat and the landscape plan to comply with the City of Tucson Watercourse Ordinance, resolution No. 20505, and the Floodplain, Wash and Environmental Resource Zone (ERZ) Standards (see attached copies).
In addition, the tentative plat and landscape plan shall comply with the Tumamoc Area Plan Policy which requests a wash buffer zone as outlined above.

As per the Watercourse Ordinance, those portions of ERZ Washes with protected riparian areas need to be public, or located within common area of the recorded plat. Please revise tentative plat and the landscape plan to show protected riparian areas as common areas, as NUOS. As proposed private lot areas extend into and through in what seems to be riparian protected areas. Prior to resubmittal, please address these type of issues with Ann Audrey from the Office of Conservation and Sustainable Development, at 791-4505.

2. One of the main features and benefit of an RCP design is to protect natural terran and vegetation through clustering lots and establishing natural undisturbed open space (NUOS) and usable open spaces, in addition to minimal grading through the site. Therefore, please address how grading will be minimized within each lot. Please show building pad delineation and the square footage of pad area for each lot.

Although building pad square footage should be minimal to help preserve the natural terran and vegetation, the pad layout needs to take into account accessory uses associated with custom built homes, such as detached accessory buildings, outdoor activity areas, pools, privacy walls. Lot areas outside of the building pad to remain undisturbed and outside of human activity/space needs.

The Eastern Pima County Trail System Master Plan identifies at this site the Silvercroft Wash to include local trail # 136. Please contact Mr. Glenn Hicks at 791-4873, at the Department of Parks and Recreation to determine type and amenities required on local trail #136 along Silvercroft Wash. At the time of resubmittal, please provide documentation of agreement with the Department of Parks and Recreation.

Staff is unable to determine if lot #25 has a buildable area. One of the purposes of an RCP project is to protect natural wash and floodplain areas by clustering lots with buildable areas outside of these protected resources. Please revise tentative plat to show how the 100-year floodplain limits effects the entire lot. Currently, only part of the floodplain limits are shown on this lot. If lot #25 has no acceptable buildable area then it needs to be considered as protected 100-year floodplain area.
Lots # 1, 2, 3, 17, 18, and 24 have area which may be buildable, but only accessible by encroaching through protected 100year floodplain limits. Please address how the 100-year floodplain and natural wash areas will be protected if these lots are divided by natural washes. Prior to revisions/resubmittal, staff recommends the applicant contact Ann Audrey at 791-4505 to address these issues.
Tumamoc Area Plan, Design Guideline 8 states that,
Wash buffer zones should be protected from the impact of pet and human activity by construction of fencing or walls. Access from individual lots to conservation areas is discouraged. Pedestrian access should be only from a common access point. Please revise tentative plat and landscape plan to provide common access points to access the Silvercroft Wash, local trail # 136 amenities, as determined by the Department of Parks and Recreation.
04/11/2007 FRODRIG2 PIMA COUNTY WASTEWATER Denied April 10, 2007

To: Mirela Hromatka
Rick Engineering, Inc.

Thru: Patricia Gehlen, CDRC Project Manager
City of Tucson Development Services Department

____________________________________
From: Thomas Porter(520-740-6579) Sr. CEA, representing the Pima County
Departments of Wastewater Management and Environmental Quality

Subject: Star Pass Vistas
Village II
Lots 1-44 & Common Areas “A”and “B-1” thru “B-4”
Tentative Plat – 1st Submittal
S07-033

The proposed Tentative Plat for the above-referenced project has been reviewed on behalf of the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality (PDEQ) and the Pima County Wastewater Management Department (PCWMD). This review letter may contain comments pertaining to the concerns of either Department. The following comments are offered for your use.

Obtain a letter from the PCWMD's Development Services Section, written within the past 90 days, stating that treatment and conveyance system capacity for the project is available in the downstream public sewerage system and provide a copy of that letter to this office. The required form to request such a letter may be found at:

http://www.pima.gov/wwm/forms/docs/CapResponseRequest.pdf.

The tentative plat for this project cannot be approved until a copy of this letter has been received by this office.

We have sent to your office via e-mail, a .pdf file containing a Sewer Service Agreement for the proposed number of residential lots. Three originals will need to be printed out from this file for notarized signatures by the Owner of Record. The three signed originals of the Agreement must be returned to this office in order to satisfy the necessary requirements needed to approve the Mylars of the tentative plat..



All Sheets: Add the case number, S07-033, to the title block of each sheet. This number should be shown larger or bolder than any cross reference numbers. Also add (PRIVATE STREETS) after COMMON AREAS “A” in the title block. No wastewater review fees will be charged for sheets where this is the only required revision.

Sheet 1: In the legend, change EXISTING SEWER LINE W/MH to Existing PUBLIC SEWER LINE W/MH. Make this change in all three places.


Sheet 2: Revise the line for the existing public sewer line to be separate and distinguished from the line shown for the proposed public sewer line. Also show the sewer flow directional arrow and pipe size for the existing public sewer line.

Sheet 2, 3 and 4: Show the invert elevations for both the incoming and outgoing pipes at all of the manholes. Also with pipe deflections from 10ÿ to 45ÿ there must be a minimum drop of 0.1 ft. across the manhole. Deflections from 45ÿ to 90ÿ must show a minimum drop of 0.2 ft.

Sheet 2,3 and 4: Show the culvert invert elevations at all places where the sewer line intersects with culverts.

Sheet 4: Show by calculation the scour depth in a 100 year flood over the sewer line where it crosses thru the wash in CA “B-1”.

This office will require a revised set of bluelines, and a response letter, addressing these co mments. Additional comments may be made during the review of these documents.

Pima County Code Title 13.20.030.A.2 requires that a wastewater review fee be paid for each submittal of the tentative plat. The fee for the first submittal is $166 plus $50 per sheet. For the second submittal, the review fee is $50 per sheet. For all subsequent submittals, the review fee is $39 per sheet.

The next submittal of this project will be the 2nd submittal. A check for the review fee of this submittal in the amount of $200 (made out to PIMA COUNTY TREASURER) must accompany the revised set of bluelines and response letter.

If the number of sheets changes, please adjust the review fee accordingly.





If you have any questions regarding the above comments, please do not hesitate to contact me.
04/11/2007 GLENN HICKS COT NON-DSD PARKS & RECREATION Denied DATE: April 10, 2007

TO: Ferne Rodriguez, Development Services

FROM: Glenn Hicks
Parks and Recreation
791-4873 ext. 215
Glenn.Hicks@tucsonaz.gov

CC:


SUBJECT: S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II: Tentative Plat Review(3-5-07)


Denied. Silvercroft Wash is identified as trail #136 in the Eastern Pima County Trail System Master Plan. Please indicate a 20 ft wide, public, non-motorized trail easement is being dedicated along the west side of Silvercroft Wash.
04/12/2007 PGEHLEN1 OTHER AGENCIES PIMA ASSN OF GOVTS Passed
05/17/2007 ELIZABETH EBERBACH ENGINEERING REVIEW Denied TO: Patricia Gehlen; CDRC Coordinator
Consultant: RICK Engineering
SUBJECT: Starr Pass Vistas Village 2 Tentative Plat Engineering Review
REVIEWER: Elizabeth Eberbach
LOCATION: T14S R13E Section 16
ACTIVITY NUMBER: S07-033

SUMMARY: The Tentative Plat sheets, Drainage Report, landscape documents, and schedules of title report were received by Engineering for review. The Drainage Report was reviewed for Tentative Plat purposes only. Engineering does not recommend approval of the Tentative Plat at this time.

DRAINAGE COMMENTS:
1) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L: Address the following drainage report comments:
a) To accommodate south portion of watershed VII, show additional drainage interceptor and crossing improvements between proposed pipes at CP 2B and 2C on drainage exhibit Figure 6 and on Tentative Plat (in vicinity of lot 34 frontage.
b) Tucson Code section 26-10(e): In balanced basins, and where development is less than 3 units to the acre, use of a fee system may be considered appropriate in lieu of a detention system in order to preserve the natural drainage patterns However, a fee may be utilized in place of a detention/retention system, when it can be clearly demonstrated that detention at the site does not provide off-site flood relief due to the parcel size, location within the drainage basin, or other factors. Also, as current policy, the City is at this time not accepting in-lieu fees for basins. Revise Basin requirement section 3.0 in report and provide detention discussion and calculations.
c) It appears the hydrology for the project has been carefully studied. However, there are missing HEC-HMS data input sheets for some of the watersheds in the appendix; for example there was no input data sheet for Q100 = 93cfs for watershed cp1, only HMS result output is provided. Also the nomenclature on Figure 5 for watersheds / concentration points need clarification for review purposes. Check circular referencing or revise labels or further clarify tables for watersheds, concentration points, and channel Q100's for review. This data / tables on Figure 5 may need to be added to the report portion of the drainage report and discussed if tables on exhibits do not provide sufficient clarification.
d) The delineation for top of bank along wash B needs to be clarified in two areas on the existing drainage map exhibit Figure 4, exhibit Figure 5, and Tentative Plat planview:
i) Expand top of bank to include contributing larger west tributary adjacent to station/section 8.
ii) Expand west top of bank to include a portion of tributary near station/section 6.
e) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L: For preformed scour calculation sheet in appendix add velocity as additional column for review purposes. Toedowns for spillways shall be called out on Tentative Plat. Downstream erosion protection and spillways may be reviewed and sized at grading plan review stage.
f) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L: Provide freeboard and erosion protection for each channel design and show as details on Tentative Plat.
g) Tucson Code Sec.26-5.2(5): Development in floodway fringe area may not increase the base flood elevation more than 1/10th of a foot for any offsite property. Provide discussion in the drainage report regarding no adverse impact to adjacent properties.
h) DS Sec.10-02.8.5.1: Culvert design minimum Manning's coefficient shall be 0.025 per Table 8.1. Update all culvert design calculations.
i) DS Sec.10-02.8.5.1: Provide street capacity analysis for street sections, using 0.020 minimum roughness coefficient per Table 8.1.
2) Land Use Code (LUC) Sec.2.8.1.5.A and Tucson Code Chapter 26 Article I Division 1 Section 26-5.2(4): There are riparian floodplain areas on the site and the east portion of project which lies along an ERZ Wash are subject to development restrictions. Per floodplain and erosion hazard area regulations, 100-year floodplain riparian areas shall not be unnecessarily altered. Clearly delineate the overlapping area of the 100-year floodplain limits and the limits of riparian area on Tentative Plat. Necessary alteration includes necessary all weather access to a site where there are no other access, or necessary utility crossing disturbance where there are no other locations for the utilities, or other necessary development where there are no other alternatives. Additional lot development is not considered a necessary alteration of the riparian floodplain. Address the following comments:
a) DS Sec.2-13.2.5.B.1.p: Show on an ERR/ERZ Exhibit and on drainage exhibits, the areas of overlapping floodplain/riparian areas as well as critical sensitive habitat areas that begin in the floodplain and extend outside of the floodplain as riparian areas. Label as Protected Riparian Area. The riparian area and any encroachment must be accepted by Landscaping as well as Engineering with the review and acceptance of the ERR/ERZ report which is required with the riparian floodplain review and ERZ Overlay Zone submittal package. The project shall reflect ERR and ERZ conformance in the Tentative Plat and drainage report.
b) DS Sec.2-13.2.5.B.1: Add documentation to drainage report that references the ERR/ERZ report. Provide an ERR/ERZ report that discusses how the project design is in conformance to the development restrictions. See DS Sections 2-13.2.5.B.1, 2, and 3 for report content.
c) LUC Sec.2.8.6.5, DS Sec.2-13: ERZ washes are reviewed under the LUC code and Development Standards for these sections and are subject to required notification procedure, Stormwater Advisory Committee, and other overlay review, scheduling, and procedural requirements. Contact Zoning Manager Patricia Gehlen 791-5608 ext. 1179 for ERZ overlay zone application and procedural questions.
d) DS Sec.2-03.2.3.I: On drainage exhibit (as well as ERR/ERZ exhibit), show limits of resource corridor as described in LUC Sec.2.8.6.4.B. This delineation shall be shown on a same exhibit that shows the 100-yr floodplain limits so that the overlapping area is clarified.
e) Development Standard (DS) Sec.2-13.2.2.C.4: Regarding the proposed disturbance of the riparian floodplain for some lots and a road improvement, address the following:
i) Since the proposed lot development is not allowed to encroach the riparian floodplain area, show that each proposed lot has a viable buildable area by indicating a potential or proposed building area that would include the area needed to accommodate appurtenances and a footprint of a house that is a reasonable product for this type of subdivision.
ii) DS Sec.2-13.2.5.B.2.d: The proposed road crossing location and alignment at concentration point 1A is acceptable to engineering for access purposes to the site. However, the location is subject to Landscaping/NPPO review. Also, consider larger pipe size for CP 1A for wildlife traversability per this section, showing sufficient cover for proposed roadway. Revise tables (section 5.2) and calculation sheets in report. Discuss proposed crossing in the ERR/ERZ Report.
3) Tucson Code Sec.26-6.2: Address the following comments for water and sewer utility crossing in the floodplain:
a) Assure alignment of sewer crossing is perpendicular to wash flowline.
b) In report provide scour calculation at sewer crossing.
c) Provide cross sections of sewer and any water line crossings.
d) Discuss in drainage report how all new water supply and sewage disposal systems shall be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of floodwaters into the system and discharge from systems into floodwaters. Waste disposal systems shall be located to avoid impairment to them or contamination from them during flooding.
e) Show all location of water line on plan view.
4) Tucson Code Sec.29-15(b)(1)f: Section 6.0 needs clarification. Address the following:
a) Revise 404 compliance statement sheet in the Drainage Report to reflect that the project does have 404 washes on site per section 6.0 of the report. Clarify in compliance statement which permit applies, or, which will be needed and if application has been submitted.
b) Revise verbiage in section 6.0 to reflect current project which has proposed development in 100-year jurisdictional floodplain and jurisdictional 404 washes.
c) Provide documentation from Army Corps of Engineers for this project.
5) DS Sec.10-01.V.2.5: Address the following items on exhibits and Tentative Plat planviews:
6) LUC 3.7.4: Surface stormwater should be directed into the landscape areas to promote water harvesting surface drainage. Clearly explain how water harvesting will be accomplished to the maximum extent possible and whether drainage from lots are to be discharged into water harvesting areas prior to discharge into wash. Show how stormwater will be directed toward the water harvesting areas. Consult the Water Harvesting Guidance Manual (Adopted October 18, 2005) for design guidelines. The manual is available online at http://dot.tucsonaz.gov/stormwater/downloads/2006WaterHarvesting.pdf
7) For drainage maintenance section, address the following:
a) Revise section to reflect "drainage facilities".
b) Provide additional column for proposed solutions for condition in table. There ar

TENTATIVE PLAT COMMENTS:
8) Revise detail A/5; provide street section per standards. Justify in drainage report any depressed curb if proposed.
9) DS Sec.2-03.2.2.B.7: Where the overlay zone requires a separate review process (HDZ and ERZ), note the file number, date of approval, and any conditions placed on that approval or, if the review has not been completed, that it is in process. An Overlay Application is required; submit separate overlay packages for the HDZ review and the ERZ review. Information regarding ERR/ERZ must be submitted in the ERR/ERX Report, and HDZ information may be submitted as one sheet of the Tentative Plat or separate document.
10) LUC Sec.2.8.1: Per Hillside Development Zone, address the following comments:
a) LUC Sec.2.8.1.6: With the HDZ Overlay package, submit an HDZ Plan including the calculations and content specified in DS Sec.2-12.2.0 and LUC table 2.8.1.I. including but not limited to the following comments for the HDZ exhibit sheet:
i) Show 15% slope areas.
ii) Label any delineated HDZ undisturbed open spaces.
iii) After providing calculation for ACS, provide applicable data per columns A, B, C, and D of table 2.8.1.I.
b) Indicate on conceptual grading planview sheet, or on a Tentative Plat planview, or by Tentative Plat general notes, that any slopes steeper than 3:1 with the exception of retaining walls, will be stabilized with properly engineered stone riprapping or sculptured rock that is hand-placed on the slope, and, that the development should utilize construction methods which ensure slope stabilization and minimize soil erosion.
11) DS Sec.11-01.4.1.C.3: Clarify access ramps with a detail or further notation to state that truncated domes are required per ADAAG. This is an update to COT standard detail 207. There is a recent directive to use the new "truncated domes" - little raised nodules in lieu of grooves. Remove lines in HC ramp area details on legend, all plan views, and details on all sheets; or, add notation to clarify that truncated domes are required on these areas.
12) DS Sec.2-03.2.3.A: For survey and boundary data, clarify the following on sheet 2:
a) DS Sec.2-03.2.1.J: Clarify locations and make legible all survey monuments to be set and found;
b) Indicate benchmark location on a plan view or provide local benchmark that can be shown on a plan view;
c) Label ties to section corner(s) on sheet index or other plan view;
d) Boundary data needs to match title report exhibit, provide exhibit of legal description;
e) Provide and show on planview local benchmark for project.
13) Address the following street comments:
a) Show sewer line in Greasewood.
b) Contact Fire Department regarding application for fire box for proposed gate, enclosed with the plan package.
c) Clarify right-of-way and dedication for MS&R along Starr Pass and Greasewood. Clarify right-of-way width for Starr Pass as the MS&R map indicates 120-feet.
d) DS Sec.3-01: Regarding curb and sidewalk requirements, address the following comments:
i) Show new curb and MS&R 6-ft sidewalk along frontage of Starr Pass Boulevard on Tentative Plat planview. Between the EHS limits at the Silvercroft Wash crossing, an 8-ft asphalt path will be acceptable at 5-ft offset from edge of pavement. Show concrete toedown along pavement edges on Tentative Plat.
ii) Label shared use path along Greasewood on Tentative Plat planview.
iii) Along Greasewood, provide connection from existing asphalt path to new sidewalk/curb access ramp at Starr Pass Boulevard.
iv) Along Greasewood, show or add note that a left turn bay will be constructed as part of PIA.
v) Along Greasewood, add note or show that a minimum 5-ft wide bike lane is to be provided along project-side of new roadway reconstruction.
vi) Along west bound Starr Pass Boulevard, add note or show that a minimum 5-ft wide bike lane is provided.
14) Address the following easement comments:
a) DS Sec.2-03.2.3.C: All existing easements, including those in Title Report Schedule B item 4, 5, and 7 will be explained in a response letter or drawn on the plat, and recordation information, location, width, and purpose shall be included.
b) If any easements are not in use and proposed for abandonment, so indicate. Blanket easements should be clearly noted with recordation data and proposed status.
c) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.J: All proposed easements (utility, sewer, drainage, access, etc.) are to be dimensioned and labeled as to their purposes and whether they will be public or private; show any private drainage maintenance easement areas.
15) Address the following drainage / floodplain related comments:
a) Tucson Code Sec.26-5.2(13): Add general note that states that no walls, any type of fences, or other permanent obstacles will be allowed within the floodplain. This note will also need to be added to Final Plat when submitted.
b) Explain road drainage and provide scupper calculations.
16) DS Sec.11-01: Address the following conceptual grading design questions:
a) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.L.2: Provide minimum PAD elevations and proposed finished floor elevations for lots adjacent to washes.
b) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.M: Provide geotechnical report that includes soils analysis for site, recommendations for maximum slope grades, minimum slope treatments / scour protection, minimum setbacks from basin, percolation testing data and results. The typical lot grading detail shall reflect recommendations from geotechnical report for minimum sideyard setbacks for positive drainage from structure.
c) Per D.S. 2-03.2.4.K: Revise typical lot grading details on sheet 5 to reflect custom lot graded lot product. Clarify "minimum" setbacks. The minimum side and rear setbacks, building setbacks to swales shall reflect recommendations per geotechnical report.
17) DS Sec.2-03.2.4.I: Identify and provide dimensions, approximate areas in square footage, and purposes of any areas proposed for dedication (such as common areas, or riparian natural open areas, etc.) clarifying and differentiating any common areas for a basin or other areas.
18) DS Sec.2-03.2.2.C.2.b: When a grading plan is submitted, a fully completed floodplain use permit application with the $50 permit processing fee will be required. Grading Plan review package will be accepted after the Tentative Plat design has been revised and is at an acceptable stage of review - at minimum, after the 2nd Tentative plat resubmittal.

LANDSCAPE PLAN COMMENTS:
19) On Landscape planview sheets address the following comments:
a) with any basin, assure that no proposed plants are blocking or placed on access ramps or inlet / outlet areas for the basin.
b) DS Sec.3-01.5.1.A.1 & DS Sec.2-03.2.4.M: Show the sight visibility triangle on Landscape planview sheets such that there is no sight visibility conflict. Other than trees as noted below, plant materials located within existing and future sight visibility triangles shall be limited to ground cover or low-growing vegetation of a species that will not grow higher than thirty inches. Trees may be located within existing and future sight visibility triangles only if clear of leaves and branches to a height of at least six feet above grade upon installation, and at all times thereafter. The trunk caliper of any species selected may not exceed twelve inches in diameter at maturity. Trees with multiple trunks are not allowed. Trees may not be planted in a line that could result in a solid wall effect as viewed from the motorist's perspective. The number and location of trees within existing and future sight visibility triangles may be restricted or modified by the City of Tucson in order to preserve visibility.

The next submittal should address all the above items. Submit revised Tentative Plat, a bound copy of the geotechnical report, revised Drainage Report, copy of revised Landscape Plan, title report, and response letter. Prior to resubmittal, you may schedule a meeting with me to go over your comments. If you have any questions, please call me at 791-5550 extension 2204.

Elizabeth Eberbach, PE
Civil Engineer
Engineering Division
Development Services
05/23/2007 PATRICIA GEHLEN ZONING-DECISION LETTER REVIEW Denied COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
DEVELOPMENT SERVICES

May 23, 2007

Mirela Hromatka
Rick Engineering Company, Inc.
1745 East River Road, Suite 101
Tucson, Arizona 85718

Subject: S07-033 Starr Pass Vistas Village II Tentative Plat

Dear Mirela:

Your submittal of March 5, 2007 for the above project has been reviewed by the Community Design Review Committee and the comments reflect the outstanding requirements which need to be addressed before approval is granted. Please review the comments carefully. Once you have addressed all of the comments, please submit the following revised documents and a DETAILED cover letter explaining how each outstanding requirement has been addressed:

ALL BLACKLINES MUST BE FOLDED

11 Copies Revised Tentative Plat (Fire, Zoning, Traffic, ESD, Addressing, Landscape, DUPD, Wastewater, Parks and Recreation, Engineering, DSD)

6 Copies Revised Landscape Plan (Zoning, Landscape, DUPD, Parks and Recreation, Engineering, DSD)

2 Copies Revised NPPO Plan (Landscape, DSD)

2 Copies Bound Geotechnical Report (Engineering, DSD)

2 Copies Traffic Impact Analysis (Traffic, DSD)

2 Copies Environmental Resource Report and Mitigation Plan (Landscape, DSD)

2 Copies Revised Drainage Report (Engineering, DSD)

2 Copies Title Report (Engineering, DSD)

Should you have any questions, please call me at 791-5608 extension 1179.

Sincerely,

Patricia Gehlen
CDRC Manager

All comments for this case are available on our website at http://www.ci.tucson.az.us/dsd/

Via fax: 322-6956