Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: RESUBMITTAL - CDRC - TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW
Permit Number - DP15-0114
Review Name: RESUBMITTAL - CDRC - TENTATIVE PLAT REVIEW
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08/28/2015 | KROBLES1 | START | PLANS SUBMITTED | Completed | |
| 09/03/2015 | ED ABRIGO | PIMA COUNTY | ASSESSOR | Reqs Change | Office of the Pima County Assessor 115 N. Church Ave. Tucson, Arizona 85701 BILL STAPLES ASSESSOR TO: CITY OF TUCSON PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT FROM: Suzanne Gilpin GIS Cartographer Pima County Assessor's Office (520)724-4387 DATE: September 2, 2015 RE: Assessor's Review and Comments Regarding DP15-0114 CASA SETON PLACE-Tentative Plat * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Plat meets Assessor's Office requirements. __X___ Plat does not meet Assessor's Office requirements. COMMENTS: " There must be bearings and dimensions for the perimeter and all lot lines and all common areas. NOTE: THE ASSESSOR'S CURRENT INVOLVEMENT IN PROCESSING ITS MANUAL MAPS TO DIGITAL FORMAT IS EXPEDITED GREATLY BY EXCHANGE OF DIGITAL DATA. IN THE COURSE OF RECORDING THIS SUBDIVISION YOUR ASSISTANCE IN PROVIDING THIS OFFICE WITH AN AUTOCAD COPY WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED. THANK YOU FOR ANY DIGITAL DATA PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED. |
| 09/03/2015 | JENNIFER STEPHENS | PIMA COUNTY | ADDRESSING | Reqs Change | 201 N. STONE AV, 1ST FL TUCSON, AZ 85701-1207 MICHELENE NOWAKADDRESSING REVIEW PH #: 724-9512 TO: CITY PLANNING FROM: MICHELENE NOWAK, ADDRESSING REVIEW SUBJECT: DP15-0114 CASA SETON LOTS 1-11/TENTATIVE PLAT 2nd REVIEW DATE: AUGUST 31, 2015 The above referenced project has been reviewed by this Division for all matters pertaining to street naming/addressing, and the following matters must be resolved prior to our approval: 1.Correct Tax Parcels on Sheets 6, 7, 8 for adjacent property: on the north --#123-01-017D and on the east---#123-05-160A2.On Sheets 6, 7, 8 label Detention Basin as: Common Area “B”3.Both private streets (Common Area “A”) will need to be named. The suffix will be “Place” or “Court”, since these are cul-de-sacs. Please e-mail proposed street name choices to: Addressing@pima.gov for review. Note: one street name “Leighton Place” has been reserved for this project. |
| 09/04/2015 | STEVE SHIELDS | ZONING | REVIEW | Reqs Change | CDRC TRANSMITTAL TO: Development Services Department Plans Coordination Office FROM: Steve Shields Lead Planner PROJECT: Casa Seton Development Package (2nd Review) DP15-0114 TRANSMITTAL DATE: September 8, 2015 DUE DATE: September 14, 2015 COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings and any redlined plans along with a detailed response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments were addressed. This plan has been reviewed for compliance with the Unified Development Code (UDC) Administrative Manual (AM) Section 2-06. Also compliance with applicable development criteria for the proposed use as listed in the City of Tucson Uniform Development Code (UDC) and the UDC Technical Standards Manual (TSM). The review comments include the actual standard first with the applicable Administrative Manual section number and the following paragraph is the actual comment related to the specific item that must be addressed. If you need to review the sections listed below click on the link or copy it in the address bar of your internet program. http://www.amlegal.com/nxt/gateway.dll/Arizona/tucson_az_udc/administrativemanual?f=templates$fn=default.htm$3.0$vid=amlegal:tucson_udc_az This link will take you directly to the section used for the standards review. The UDC & TSM requirements are in the Unified Development Code and can be viewed at the same web link as above Section 3.3.3.G.5.c UDC, An applicant has one year from the date of application to obtain approval of a site plan that complies with zoning and other development requirements in effect at the time of application, unless an ordinance adopted by Mayor and Council during this period states otherwise. A site plan application that has been in review for a period of one year and has not yet been approved is considered denied. To continue the review of a site plan for the property, a new site plan must be submitted that complies with regulations in effect at the time of re-submittal. The new submittal initiates a new one-year review period. One year Expiration date is , 2016. SECTION 2-06.0.0: DEVELOPMENT PACKAGE (TENTATIVE PLATS AND SITE PLANS) Section 2-06.1.0 GENERAL 2-06.2.0 APPLICATION SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS 2-06.3.0 FORMAT REQUIREMENTS 2-06.4.0 CONTENT REQUIREMENTS 2-06.5.0 FLEXIBLE LOT DEVELOPMENT (FLD) - ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS 2-06.1.0 GENERAL 2-06.1.1 PURPOSE This standard has been prepared for the purpose of informing applicants of the submittal and review requirements for development package documents to assure proper and adequate information is presented in a consistent manner, thereby providing the basis for an efficient and timely review. The development package documents are prepared in support of applications for building permits and related reviews. The information that is requested establishes the basis upon which the project will be approved and could affect what is required of the property in the future, should there be a proposal for expansion or for a different use of the property. This standard does not waive any applicable city regulations or codes. 2-06.1.2 APPICABILITY This standard shall be used for all site plans and tentative plats submitted to PDSD for review. 2-06.2.1 APPLICATION SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS Development Package applications are available from PDSD. Completed applications and accompanying materials shall be submitted to PDSD. Incomplete or inaccurate applications will not be accepted, nor will any application in which the pre-application conference or neighborhood meeting requirements have not been met. The types of documents and the specific number of copies required of each of the documents are on the PDSD website or may be obtained from PDSD. Resubmittals of development packages require a comment response letter that details how all previous comments have been addressed. Provide the same number of copies of the comment response letter as plans provided. The following documents and information shall be submitted upon application: 2-06.2.1 Application Form A completed application signed by the property owner or authorized designee; 2-06.2.2 Development Package A development package must be prepared to the format and content requirements described herein; 2-06.2.3 Related Reviews In addition to the plan process, a project may require review for other types of plans and documents. The applications for those processes are submitted to the appropriate department for review and approval. These related reviews can be applied for so that review can occur concurrently with the development package application. However, it must be understood that, should the related application be approved subject to conditions or denied, this may affect the; 2-06.2.4 Concurrent Reviews The development package is designed to allow for concurrent review of any site related reviews. Concurrent review means that all plans and documents needed for the review are submitted as one package. Examples of site related reviews include but are not limited to: site plans, landscape plans, NPPO plans, water harvesting plans, grading plans, SWPPP plans, floodplain use permits, and overlay reviews. Separate applications are often required for the different site related reviews even if the plans are submitted concurrently; and, 2-06.2.5 Fees Fees in accordance with Section 4-01.0.0, Development Review Fee Schedule. CONTENT REQUIREMENTS 2-06.4.7.A.6.a - List additional applications and overlays, by case number (if applicable), in lower right corner of each sheet. As a general note provide the type of application processed or overlays applicable, a statement that the project meets the criteria/conditions of the additional application or overlay, the case number, date of approval, what was approved, and the conditions of approval, if any. 1) The TSMR will need to be submitted and approved prior to approval of the development package. COMMENT: As a Technical Standards Modification Request (TSMR) will be required, provide the TSMR case number adjacent to the title block on each sheet. Also provide a general note stating the TSMR case number, date of approval, what was modified, and any conditions of approval. 2-06.4.7.A.7 - If the property is part of a subdivision plat that is being reviewed or has been recorded, provide the case number in the lower right corner of each sheet. As a general note, indicate whether the project is part of a Flexible Lot Development (FLD), condominium, or another similar type project. 2) COMMENT: If the final plat is submitted prior to approval of the tentative plat provide the final; plat case number adjacent to the title block on each sheet. If you have any questions about this transmittal, please Steve Shields, (520) 837-4956 or Steve.Shields@tucsonaz.gov RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised development package |
| 09/08/2015 | BVIESTE1 | ENV SVCS | REVIEW | Approved | The Tentative Plat/Development Plan has been reviewed on behalf of the Environmental Services Dept. and is approved. If there are any questions, I can be reached at kperry@perryengineering.net |
| 09/08/2015 | SSHIELD1 | ZONING HC | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 09/09/2015 | JOE LINVILLE | LANDSCAPE | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 09/10/2015 | KBROUIL1 | COT NON-DSD | FIRE | Approved | |
| 09/14/2015 | ELIZABETH LEIBOLD | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Reqs Change | DATE: September 14, 2015 TO: Bill Carroll, P.E., Engineering and Environmental Consultants, Inc. SUBJECT: Development Package Engineering 2nd Review submittal PROJECT: Casa Seton Development Package Engineering Review LOCATION: 1777 N POTTER P, 123-01-017F, T14S R14E Sec5, Ward 6 IMPACT FEE AREA: Central FEMA PANEL: 2277L, Zone X-Unshaded WATERSHED: Flowing Wells Wash Watershed (a non-designated basin management area) REVIEWER: Elizabeth Leibold P.E. ACTIVITY NUMBER: DP15-0114 SUMMARY: The resubmittal of this Development Package includes the Tentative Plat, with conceptual grading a new subdivision Casa Seton, which was received and reviewed by Planning & Development Services Department Engineering Division. Discussion of soils report with engineer from EOR's office occurred end of August. Not all comments were completely addressed. Development Services Department Engineering Division does not recommend approval of this Development Package at this time until the remaining comments are addressed. BASE PLAN / MASTER COVER SHEETS/ GENERAL NOTES: 1) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4: Assure all required general notes have been added to the cover sheet, including the remaining comments: a) Tech Man Secs.4-04.14.3.2(a)-(d), 4-04.14.3.3, 4-04.1.5.1&2: Revise note 17 to match verbiage in standard regarding maintenance for drainage and basin facilities: Owner(s) shall be solely responsible for operation, maintenance, and liability for drainage structures and detention basin, and shall have an Arizona Registered Professional Civil Engineer prepare a certified inspection report for drainage and detention facilities at least once each year, and that these regular inspection reports will be on file with owner for review by City staff, upon written request. City staff may periodically inspect drainage and detention facilities to verify that scheduled and unscheduled maintenance activities are being performed adequately. Owner(s) agree to reimburse City for any and all costs associated with maintaining drainage and detention facilities, should City find owner(s) deficient in their obligation to adequately operate and maintain their facilities. b) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.7.A.6.a: Revise general note 19 to provide statement that project meets criteria/conditions of TSMR(s), and once approved, update note to include case number, date of approval, and include conditions of approval, if any. c) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.8.G: Verify soils are properly prepared for compaction in area of pool removal, or add general note that this will be done during improvement plan stage if soils report is not updated to address recommendations for this issue at Tentative Plat stage. SITE PLAN SHEET COMMENTS: 2) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.8.D: Identify entities along western property boundary west of basin; clarify whether these are existing or proposed sewer manholes or other objects; add sewer manhole symbol and sewer line (both private proposed sewer and existing public) to legend. DRAINAGE REPORT COMMENTS: 3) UDC Sec.7.14.1&4, Tech Man Sec.4-04.2.2, 2.3.1: Drainage comments are provided to address those features that impact feasibility of the project and should be addressed prior to grading permit review, at Tentative Plat stage. Address the remaining Drainage Report comments: a) Tech Man Sec.4-03.3.5.1.3.a: There are basin-utility and basin structure setbacks missing from Tentative Plat. See Soils comments regarding basin design with proximity to proposed sewer. (See also Utility comment below). b) In-lieu of retention, add discussion in drainage report that compares the proposed 20% runoff reduction to the in-lieu detention option of: the difference in volume between the developed and existing 2-yr runoff volumes or the difference in peak discharges with the difference in volume and/or peak discharges between the developed and existing 5-yr runoff volumes. Explain how minimum requirement is met. c) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.N, Tech Man Sec.4-04.2.3.1.6.A.4: Flows for pre- and post developed conditions in report indicate an additional flowrate quantity along northern property line; clarify on sheet C-2 all sub-watershed flowrates if the one shown is for smaller sub-watershed. d) Tech Man Sec.4-03.3.5.1.4: Regarding outlet detail or planview, as stated previously, walled basins should be avoided; earthen slopes are referred to in detention retention manual. There may be a need to show geotechnical recommendations for seepage control or side slopes grades for basin. e) Tech Man Sec.4-04.2.3.1.3.A.6: Response letter stated no perimeter walls yet planview notes and details indicate walls are proposed. If there are proposed wall or future walls, the Tentative Plat should provide some guidelines for those wall openings to match drainage design for subdivision. Provide any sizing calculations for proposed subdivision perimeter wall openings. Assuring pre- and post developed conditions are thoroughly described in report. GRADING, PAVING, DETAIL SHEET COMMENTS: 4) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.M.1, Tech Man Secs.2-01.4.1.C, 8-01.5.2.G: Address the remaining grading comments: a) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.M.1: Limits of grading shall coincide with needed fill on project site to accommodate slope or fill and construction area; clarify that perimeter elevations are maintaining existing flow patterns, necessary construction area and fill runout on grading planview. Address the following slope/cut/fill comments: i) Clarify flow arrows for proposed lot drainage scheme that has conceptual grading information. ii) Add fill to a side of the retaining wall on detail E on C-3. iii) Clarify side yard setbacks on lot details. iv) Tech Man Sec.2-01.10.5: Consider interceptor swale along south boundary to address offsite flows from sub-watershed south of parcel. Show any swale with width dimensioned within a common area as needed. b) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.M.1: Provide additional data or other cross sections for conceptual grading design; delineate, dimension width, and label existing sewer and water line easements at south and north areas of project. Show on plans using lot detail and or cross sections how Geotechnical Evaluation Report recommendations are met on plan. Assure recommendations for slopes, basin setbacks from building and private street, are reflected on plans. Provide basic details for utility trench protection from adjacent basin, based on revised soils report or addendum. (See soils & utility comments) c) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.W, Tech Man Sec.4-04.2.3.1.5.C: Clarify as to whether there are retaining walls proposed since "weep holes" are labeled on detail H on sheet C3. Otherwise, correct nomenclature for wall openings if there are only screen walls proposed. d) Tech Man Secs.2-01: The response letter stated that lots are front draining, however there are details under detail H on sheet C3 that show split draining lots. Clarify flow arrows for proposed lot drainage scheme that has conceptual grading information. SURVEY RELATED COMMENTS: 5) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.9.A, M.1: Address the remaining survey related comments: a) Label all proposed lot lines with approximate distances on planview. b) Depict a local Basis of Elevation, on a conceptual grading sheet planview. Only note was found; show location on a planview. UTILITIES / EASEMENTS COMMENTS: 6) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.8.B, 2-06.4.9.L: On conceptual grading planview sheets, all existing and proposed easements (utility, sewer, drainage, TCE, maintenance, access, etc.) are to be dimensioned and labeled as to their purposes and whether they will be public or private. The easements may have to be recorded and the recordation information added to the development package prior to approval. Provide title report with resubmittal. Specifically also address the remaining utility/easement comments: a) Admin Man Sec.2-06.4.8.B: On Tentative Plat sheet C2 and detail C on sheet C3, show the (existing?) sewer easement at northern portion of project, including easement width, recording data, and delineation of easement limits both on and off site (if straddling property line). It is unclear how the sewer line is to be protected from basin and how construction of sewerline is to be proposed without sewer easement shown on plans - either onsite or straddling property line. There may be construction constraints if easement does not allow for offsite improvements; this will need to be clarified for Tentative Plat purposes as this may impact layout. b) Tech Man Sec.4-04.2.3.1.5: The proposed flows at the inlet structure of the basin are in line with the proposed sewer trench. This could be considered a conflict with proposed sewer and the proposed basin; the City is concerned about stormwater migration into the sewer line trench near and under the proposed basin. Consider reconfiguring basin or location of proposed sewerline. (See grading also comments). Since this comment is important for feasibility of the project, the layout of the sewer with respect to the basin will need to be shown on Tentative Plat based on geotechnical recommendations. At this time the soils report only states that drainage swales should not be coincidental to utility trenches; there is no specific recommendation for the sewer line under the basin. STORMWATER POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN COMMENTS: No comments at this time. SOILS/GEOTECHNICAL REPORT COMMENTS: 7) Tech Man Secs.4-04.2.3.1.6.A.4.d, 4-03.2.2, 2-01, 4-03.III.3.5.1.3.a: Geotechnical Engineer shall address the following soils report related comments; a) Show location of Boring 6 on Location Plan exhibit in appendix. b) The soils report discusses how moisture migration should be avoided especially for utility trenches and that services should be located beyond the drainage swales. Provide revised soils report or addendum for recommendations of sewer line protection at basin. Provide revised soils report with recommendations for the design of protection of the existing and proposed sewer system, so that a general layout of the design can be reviewed for feasibility at Tentative Plat stage. At this time, there does not appear to be sufficient distances between property boundary, proposed basin wall, load from detained basin water, area subject to seepage (flow net), minimum grading setback, and the existing and proposed sewer system. c) Provide any soil recommendations for area where pool was removed / verify soil properly prepared for compaction. This may be addressed at grading improvement plan review stage. For resubmittal, provide revised development package including revised soils report, revised grading plan, revised soils report, with comprehensive response letter, revised drainage report, copy of title report, and other documents. If you have questions, call me at 837-4934. Elizabeth Leibold, P.E., CPM, CFM Civil Engineer Engineering Division Planning & Development Services Dept |
| 09/14/2015 | ROBERT SHERRY | PLUMBING-COMMERCIAL | REVIEW | Reqs Change | 1. Private sewer collection systems that are reviewed by the Pima County Department of Environmental Quality can expect to receive comments if the sewer is shown crossing either retention or detention basins. [Initial comment: A section of the new private sewer is shown crossing the retention basin CA 'B'. Clarify how this branch of the site sewer can be properly installed and backfilled without impairing the function of the retention basin. Reference: Section 306, IPC 2012.] 2. The proposed sewer will be located under a superimposed load from the foundation of the retaining wall; have you considered this issue during both dry and storm water-filled conditions? [Initial comment: Clarify how the existing private sewer located along the west side of the retention basin is to be accessed for repair within the proposed 4-foot wide space between the retaining wall for the retention basin and the existing wooden fence along the property line.] |
| 09/15/2015 | PATRICIA GEHLEN | ZONING-DECISION LETTER | REVIEW | Reqs Change | This review has been completed and resubmittal is required. Please resubmit the following items: 1) Two rolled sets of the plans 2) A disk containing all items submitted 3) All items requested by review staff 4) All items needed to approve this plat |
Final Status
| Task End Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| 09/25/2015 | AROMERO4 | OUT TO CUSTOMER | Completed |