Microfiche records prior to 2006 have not been completely digitized and may not be available yet on PRO. If you cannot find what you are looking for please submit a records request.

Permit Number: DP13-0194
Parcel: 12313101A

Address:
2110 N 1ST AV

Review Status: Completed

Review Details: RESUB - SITE and/or GRADING

Permit Number - DP13-0194
Review Name: RESUB - SITE and/or GRADING
Review Status: Completed
Review Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description Status Comments
01/02/2014 ROBERT SHERRY PLUMBING-COMMERCIAL REVIEW Approved
01/07/2014 ANDREW CONNOR LANDSCAPE REVIEW Reqs Change ADMINISTRATIVE MANUAL SECTION 2-10.0.0: LANDSCAPE PLAN REQUIREMENTS

Identification and Descriptive Data

All improvements and site information, such as adjacent rights-of-way and property lines, shown on the landscape plan will be identical in size and location to those shown on the base plan (site plan or tentative plat). Should amendments be required to the base plan through the review process, the same amendments will be made to the landscape plan which will then be resubmitted along with the base plan.

The landscape plan will contain the following identification in the lower right corner of each sheet:

Relevant case number for reviews DP13-0194

ARTICLE 7: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS

LANDSCAPING AND SCREENING

A 5' wall is required to screen vehicle use area from residential zoned properties per DS TABLE 7.6.4-1. Note: All walls required by this section must be of masonry material or masonry with a stucco or textured finish.

A 6' wall is required to screen refuse storage from residential zoned properties per DS TABLE 7.6.4-1.

Interior landscape border is required to screen multifamily use from residential zoned properties to the south per DS TABLE 7.6.4-1.

Ensure that all Zoning and Engineering comments and concerns are addressed.

Additional comments may apply
01/07/2014 ANDREW CONNOR NPPO REVIEW Approved
01/09/2014 RONALD BROWN HC SITE REVIEW Reqs Change ALL RESUBMITTAL COMMENTS ARE PRESENTED IN ALL CAPS

1. Change project information title description from 6 Single Family Residences (2012 IBC Classification R-3 to R-2 Apartments) to 6 Residential Rental Units.
NON-RESPONSIVE: JUST BELOW THE PROJECT DESCRIPTION "(6) 2-Story Apartment Homes, 2-Story/4 Bedroom Each" ADD THE FOLLOWING: "2012 IBC OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATION: R2 - APARTMENTS"

2. Provide 1 Van Accessible parking space including signage, access to accessible route, aisle and markings.
NON-RESPONSIVE: NOT ONLY IS THERE NO ACCESSIBLE PARKING PROVIDED, ALL VISITOR PARKING HAS BEEN DELETED. REFERENCE ZONING COMMENTS FOR NUMBER OF VISITOR PARKING REQUIRED AND MAKE ONE OF THEM AN ACCESSIBLE VAN PARKING SPACE.

3. Insure and note that all slopes of the accessible routes are to comply with 2009 Edition, ICC A117.1, Section 403.3; 5% maximum running slope and 2% maximum cross slope.
NON-RESPONSIVE: ADD THIS NOTE TO THE DRAWING

4. For all marked crossings:
a. Only 1 marked crossing is required
b. Provide a large scale detail of the different types of marked crossings showing all accessible requirements i.e.: dimensions, widths, slopes, ramps with slope direction arrows, markings, detectable warning strips, 6" curb and flush curbs.
TOO RESPONSIVE: ALL THE MARKED CROSINGS HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED. ADD ONE MARKED CROSSING NEAR THE EAST END OF THE SITE AS REQUISTED ABOVE.

ADDITIONAL COMMENT:
5. PROVIDE A WRITTEN RESPONSE.
END OF REVIEW
12/13/2013 MARTIN BROWN FIRE REVIEW Approved
12/18/2013 STEVE SHIELDS ZONING REVIEW Denied CDRC TRANSMITTAL

TO: Development Services Department
Plans Coordination Office

FROM: Steve Shields
Lead Planner

PROJECT: 2110 N. 1st Avenue - Multi-Family Development
Development Package (2nd Review)
DP13-0194

TRANSMITTAL DATE: December 18, 2013

DUE DATE: January 13, 2014

COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed.

This plan has been reviewed for compliance with the Unified Development Code (UDC) Administrative Manual (AM) Section 2-06. Also compliance with applicable development criteria for the proposed use as listed in the City of Tucson Uniform Development Code (UDC) and the UDC Technical Standards Manual (TSM).

The review comments include the actual standard first with the applicable Administrative Manual section number and the following paragraph is the actual comment related to the specific item that must be addressed. If you need to review the sections listed below click on the link or copy it in the address bar of your internet program. http://www.amlegal.com/nxt/gateway.dll/Arizona/tucson_az_udc/administrativemanual?f=templates$fn=default.htm$3.0$vid=amlegal:tucson_udc_az

This link will take you directly to the section used for the standards review. The UDC & TSM requirements are in the Unified Development Code and can be viewed at the same web link as above

Section 3.3.3.G.5.c UDC, An applicant has one year from the date of application to obtain approval of a site plan that complies with zoning and other development requirements in effect at the time of application, unless an ordinance adopted by Mayor and Council during this period states otherwise. A site plan application that has been in review for a period of one year and has not yet been approved is considered denied. To continue the review of a site plan for the property, a new site plan must be submitted that complies with regulations in effect at the time of re-submittal. The new submittal initiates a new one-year review period. One year Expiration date is October 11, 2014.

2-06.3.12 - An index of sheets in the development package shall be provided on the first sheet.

1. COMMENT: The sheet index does not match the sheet numbers. Sheet 3, utility plan is numbered SD3 and on the index it is U-1.

2-06.4.3 - The administrative street address and relevant case numbers (development package document, subdivision, rezoning, board of adjustment, DDO, MDR, DSMR, overlay, etc.) shall be provided adjacent to the title block on each sheet.

2. This comment was not addressed correctly. Provide the administrative street address and the development package case number, DP13-0194, adjacent to the title block on all sheets. COMMENT: Provide the administrative street address and the development package case number, DP13-0194, adjacent to the title block on all sheets.

2-06.4.4 - The project-location map to be located on the first sheet of the development package in the upper right corner, shall cover approximately one square mile, be drawn at a minimum scale of three inch equals one mile, and provide the following information.

3. This comment was not addressed correctly. The map is not drawn to scale. COMMENT: Provide a location map drawn at of three inch equals one mile.

2-06.4.9.H.5 - If utilizing parking area access lanes (PAALs), they shall be designed in accordance with Section 7.4.6, Motor Vehicle Use Area Design Criteria, of the UDC.

4. COMMENT: Provide a width dimension for the access lane located east of unit 6.

5. COMMENT: Per UDC Section 7.4.6.F.2.b Access lanes and PAALs must be setback at least two feet from a wall, screen, or other obstruction over six inches. The additional area is necessary to provide clearance for fire, sanitation, and delivery vehicles. Show the required two (2) foot setback from the access lane to the fence along the east property line.

6. COMMENT: Per UDC Section 7.4.6.H.1 Barriers, such as post barricades or wheel stop curbing, are required in a vehicular use area to prevent vehicles from extending beyond the property lines, to prevent cars from damaging adjacent landscaping, walls, or buildings, overhanging adjacent sidewalk areas, and/or driving onto unimproved portions of the site. That said some type of barrier is required along the east side of the access lane that runs along the east property line.

7. Per UDC Section 7.4.6.H.1 Barriers, such as post barricades or wheel stop curbing, are required in a vehicular use area to prevent vehicles from extending beyond the property lines, to prevent cars from damaging adjacent landscaping, walls, or buildings, overhanging adjacent sidewalk areas, and/or driving onto unimproved portions of the site. That said some type of barrier is required along the west side of the access lane that runs along the east property line from the trash enclosure to the sidewalk adjacent to unit 6.

2-06.4.9.H.5.a - Show all motor vehicle off-street parking spaces provided, fully dimensioned. As a note, provide calculations on the number of spaces required (include the ratio used) and the number provided, including the number of spaces required and provided for the physically disabled. The drawing should indicate parking space locations for the physically disabled. A typical parking space detail shall be provided for both standard parking spaces and those for the physically disabled. For information on parking requirements for the physically disabled, refer to adopted building and accessibility codes of the City of Tucson. Design criteria for parking spaces and access are located in Section 7.4.6, Motor Vehicle Use Area Design Criteria, of the UDC.

8. COMMENT: The vehicle parking spaces calculation shows "21 SPACES PROVIDED (18 IN PRIVATE GARAGE)". Zoning acknowledges that there are 18 in the garages but was not able to locate the three (3) additional spaces called out in the calculation.

2-06.4.9.H.5.d - Show bicycle parking facilities fully dimensioned. For specifics, refer to Section 7.4.9, Bicycle Parking Design Criteria, of the UDC. Provide, as a note, calculations for short and long term bicycle spaces required and provided.

9. This comment was not addressed provide a short and long term bicycle parking space calculation that includes the number required and provided for both short and long term bicycle parking spaces. The calculation should be as follows; SHORT TERM BICYCLE PARKING - 24 BEDROOMS x 0.10 = 2.4 OR 2 REQUIRED, 4 PROVIDED, LONG TERM BICYCLE PARKING - 24 BEDROOMS x 0.5 = 12, 12 PROVIDED 2 IN EACH UNIT. The 4 short term bicycle parking space provided is based on the detail provided, see UDC Section 7.4.9.B.d. REQUIRED COMMENT: Provide a short & long term bicycle parking space calculation on the plan, see UDC Table 7.4.8-1 for requirements.

10. COMMENT: Short term bicycle parking detail, sheet SD2, provide the 4'-0" clear dimension between racks on the detail, see UDC Figure 7.4.9-C.

2-06.4.9.O - All applicable building setback lines, such as erosion hazard, floodplain detention/retention basins, and zoning, including sight visibility triangles, will be shown.

11. This comment was not fully addressed. See high lighted. COMMENT: Along the south property line the "LOWER" and "UPPER" level setback lines are labeled backwards.

12. This comment was not addressed correctly. The required street perimeter yard would be based on the exterior wall height measured from grade to where the wall meets the eave. Base on the elevations shown on sheet SD2 17'-8" from top of bearing to finished floor plus 6" to grade the exterior wall height would be 18'-2" requiring a street perimeter yard setback of 27.26'. COMMENT: Per UDC Section 6.4.5.B.1 The width of the perimeter yard is the distance measured horizontally from a specified point to the face of each exterior building wall at the wall's highest point. That said the required street perimeter yard would be based on the exterior wall height measured from grade to where the wall meets the eave. Base on the elevations shown on sheet SD2 18'-3" from top of bearing to finished floor plus 6" to grade the exterior wall height would be 18'-9". Per UDC Section 6.4.5.C.1.a Within established areas, the minimum required front street perimeter yard is 20 feet or one and one-half the height of the proposed wall (H), measured from the street property line, whichever is greater. With an exterior wall height of 18'-9" x 1.5, the required front street perimeter yard setback is 28.125'. Based on the "27.37'" shown on the plan a Design Development Option (DDO) to reduce the required street perimeter yard will need to approved prior to approval of this development package. Contact Michael Taku, phone 837-4963 or email Michael.Taku@tucsonaz.gov for DDO process and requirements.

13. COMMENT: Per UDC Section 6.4.5.B.2 A vertical structural member(s) (i.e., post, column, dormer wall) supporting a roof extension from the principal structure is considered a wall for applying perimeter yard requirements. Per 6.4.5.d.1 Interior Property Lines. Along interior property lines, the roof overhang of the porch may extend two feet into the perimeter yard, provided the side or rear yard is not reduced to less than three feet. Per UDC Table 6.3-2.A: DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE R-1, R-2, R-3, MH-1, & MH-2 ZONES, Nonres Use to Res Zone, the required perimeter yard setback is based on 10 or ¾ the height of the building exterior wall measured from grade. The required perimeter yard for the "COVERED PORCH" to the north and south property lines would be 10'. Based on the allowed 2' overhang it appears that the proposed porch encroaches into the required perimeter yard. Clearly show the covered porches on the plan & delineate the allowed 2' overhang, and provide a dimension to the overhang. See redline on sheet SD1. It appears that the proposed buildings along the north property line may meet perimeter yard setbacks. It appears that a Design Development Option (DDO) to reduce the required north and south perimeter yard will need to be approved prior to approval of this development package. Contact Michael Taku, phone 837-4963 or email Michael.Taku@tucsonaz.gov for DDO process and requirements.

2-06.4.9.Q - Provide the square footage and the height of each commercial, industrial, or business structure and the specific use proposed within the footprint of the building(s).

14. COMMENT: Per AM 2-06.4.9.Q provide the square footage within the footprint of the buildings.

2-06.4.9.R - Show on-site pedestrian circulation and refuge utilizing location and the design criteria in Section 7-01.0.0, Pedestrian Access, of the Technical Standards Manual.

15. This comment was not fully addressed. Provide width dimension for all sidewalks shown on the plan. COMMENT: Per TSM 7-04.3.A All sidewalks must be a minimum of four feet wide. Provide width dimension for all sidewalks shown on the plan.

16. COMMENT: Per TSM 7-04.3.A All sidewalks must be a minimum of four feet wide. It appears that the pop outs shown at the front entry doors encroaches into the minimum four foot sidewalk on all units.

17. COMMENT: Per TSM 7-04.1.B A sidewalk is required adjacent and parallel to any access lane or PAAL on the side where buildings are located. That side a sidewalk is required on the east side of unit 6 the full distance of the access lane to the trash enclosure.

ADDITION COMMENTS:
1. Sheet SD3, utility plan, the site layout does not match the layout shown on sheet SD1

2. It does not appear that you meet building code for the distance between structures, contact COT Commercial Structural review, Eric Newcomb.

If you have any questions about this transmittal, please Steve Shields, (520) 837-4956 or Steve.Shields@tucsonaz.gov

RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised development package
12/27/2013 JASON GREEN ENGINEERING REVIEW Reqs Change DATE: January 9, 2014
SUBJECT: ZACK 2110 Development Plan Package- 2nd Engineering Review
TO: Rhonda Rawson, RA
LOCATION: 2110 N 1st Ave; T143S R14E Sec06
REVIEWERS: Jason Green, CFM
ACTIVITY: DP13-0194

SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Planning & Development Services Department has received and reviewed the proposed Development Plan Package. Engineering Division does not recommend approval of the Development Plan Package at this time. This review falls under the Unified Development Code (UDC), Administration Manual (AM) and Technical Standards Manual (TSM). Refer to the links for further clarification:
http://www.amlegal.com/nxt/gateway.dll/Arizona/tucson_az_udc/administrativemanual?f=templates$fn=default.htm$3.0$vid=amlegal:tucson_udc_az

The following items need to be addressed:


SITE PLAN:

1) Completed

2) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.3.12: Revise the development plan document and Sheet Index on Sheet 1 to correctly label the Utility Sheet, SD3 not the U-1 as labeled.

3) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.1: Revise the development plan document to also provide the phone number of the owner of the project on the first sheet and verify if this is the same information as the Owner. If the Owner is different provide that information also.

4) Completed.

5) Completed.

6) Completed.

7) Completed.

8) Completed.

9) Completed.

10) Completed.

11) Completed.

12) Completed.

13) Completed.

14) Completed.

15) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.H.1: Revise Keynote #5 to reference the correct standard driveway apron per TSM Sec.10-01.4.3. The proposed driveway must meet the minimum PC/COT Standard Detail for Public Improvement #206; plan view correctly references the detail however the Keynote references #200, revise.

16) Completed.

17) Completed.

18) Completed.

19) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.H.5.a: Revise the development plan document to clearly label in plan view and with Keynote all proposed 6-inch curbing within the vehicle use area, specifically the driveway location areas from wedge to vertical.

20) Completed.

21) Completed.

22) NEW: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.H.5.a: Due to the redesign of the site the following comments are new:

a) Revise the development plan document to label and dimension all areas of the vehicular use area. It is acknowledged that the applicant is redesigning the site due to the relocation of the refuse containers. Verify that the design meets the minimum requirements of UDC 7.4.

b) Label and dimension the required 2-foot setback from the access lane to the fence along the east property line. Per UDC Section 7.4.6.F.2.b Access lanes and PAALs must be setback at least two feet from a wall, screen, or other obstruction over six inches. The additional area is necessary to provide clearance for fire, sanitation, and delivery vehicles.

c) Provide a vehicular separation from the vehicular use area and the existing alley along the east side to prevent cars from access the parking lot. Per UDC Section 7.4.6.H.1 Barriers, such as post barricades or wheel stop curbing, are required in a vehicular use area to prevent vehicles from extending beyond the property lines, to prevent cars from damaging adjacent landscaping, walls, or buildings, overhanging adjacent sidewalk areas, and/or driving onto unimproved portions of the site.

23) Completed.

24) Completed.

25) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.R: Revise the development plan document to label and dimension all onsite pedestrian access lanes. Per TSM Sec.7-01.4.3 the minimum width for a sidewalk is 4-feet, revise. Provide a dimension for all onsite sidewalks at all areas in plan view.

26) Completed.

27) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.R: Clarify on the development plan document the pedestrian circulation path along the north side of Units 4, 5 and 6. Verify if the sidewalk has a 6-inch revel or if it is flush. If the sidewalk is not constructed per PC/COT SD #200 as stated and is modified then a separate detail is required to show how it has been modified.

28) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.R: It is acknowledged that the plan has been revised to provide for pedestrian access to the current refuse location however per the applicant the refuse containers are going to be relocated and will require a redesign of the pedestrian area. Verify conformance with access.

29) Acknowledged.

30) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.S: Revise the development plan document to label and dimension the required pedestrian circulation along the abutting right-of-way. Such sidewalks must comply with accessibility requirements for the physically disabled and the design criteria in TSM Sec.10-01.4.0. The sidewalk is not clearly shown on plan view, revise.

31) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.S: Revise the development plan document to label the PC/COT Standard Detail for Public Improvement #203 for the connection of the new to existing sidewalk located at the north portion of the site in the right-of-way. A new sidewalk will be required along the abutting right-of-way and must be connected to the existing sidewalk to the north.

32) Restated: AM Sec.2-06.4.9.T: It is acknowledged that the plan shows a new refuse location, however per the applicant the refuse location is being revised with ES approval and must be clearly delineated and dimensioned for the new location. Revise the development plan document to provide for centralized onsite solid waste and recycle collection service pick up per TSM Sec.8-01.5.1.A. Provide a construction detail for the refuse enclosures. The detail must match TSM Sec.8-01 and Figure 1 for the required enclosure walls, gates, concrete thickness and compressive strength, concrete approach apron dimensions, 14'x40' clear approach for each container, etc. Provide written approval from ES for the new design and location.


GENERAL COMMENTS:

Please provide a revised Development Plan Package that addresses the comments provided above. Include a comprehensive response letter addressing in detail responses to all of the above comments.

For any questions or to schedule meetings call me at 837-4929.



Jason Green, CFM
Senior Engineer Associate
Engineering Division
Planning & Development Services Department

Final Status

Task End Date Reviewer's Name Type of Review Description
01/16/2014 FERNE RODRIGUEZ OUT TO CUSTOMER Completed
01/16/2014 CPIERCE1 REJECT SHELF Completed