Permit Review Detail
Review Status: Completed
Review Details: DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Permit Number - D10-0035
Review Name: DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Review Status: Completed
| Review Date | Reviewer's Name | Type of Review | Description | Status | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10/07/2010 | FERNE RODRIGUEZ | START | PLANS SUBMITTED | Completed | |
| 10/07/2010 | RONALD BROWN | ADA | REVIEW | Passed | Not a COT owned and/or operated project |
| 10/07/2010 | FERNE RODRIGUEZ | COT NON-DSD | REAL ESTATE | Passed | |
| 10/12/2010 | DAVID MANN | COT NON-DSD | FIRE | Approved | |
| 10/15/2010 | TOM MARTINEZ | OTHER AGENCIES | AZ DEPT TRANSPORTATION | Approved | >>> Douglas Kratina <DKratina@azdot.gov> 10/15/2010 8:25 AM >>> Regional Traffic Engineering has NO COMMENT on this submittal and recommends approval of this development. It will have no impact on any existing ADOT facilities. Thank you |
| 10/28/2010 | JENNIFER STEPHENS | PIMA COUNTY | ADDRESSING | Denied | 201 N. STONE AV., 2ND FL TUCSON, AZ 85701-1207 AUDREY FARENGA ADDRESSING REVIEW PH #: 740-6800 FAX #: 623-5411 TO: CITY PLANNING FROM: AUDREY FARENGA, ADDRESSING REVIEW SUBJECT: D10-0035 S.E.C. 1ST ST. & NORRIS AVE/DEVELOPMENT PLAN DATE: October 27, 2010 The above referenced project has been reviewed by this Division for all matters pertaining to street naming/addressing, and the following matters must be resolved prior to our approval: 1. Include the section, township and range on the Vicinity Map and all Title Blocks. 2. Change section 18 to 16 on the Vicinity Map. |
| 10/29/2010 | TIM ROWE | PIMA COUNTY | WASTEWATER | Denied | PIMA COUNTY REGIONAL WASTEWATER RECLAMATION DEPARTMENT 201 NORTH STONE AVENUE TUCSON, ARIZONA 85701-1207 MICHAEL GRITZUK, P.E. PH: (520) 740-6500 DIRECTOR FAX: (520) 620-0135 October 29, 2010 To: GENE GOLDSTEIN BRAMIC DESIGN GROUP Thru: Patricia Gehlen, CDRC Manager City of Tucson Development Services Department __________________________ Reviewed by: Chad Amateau, P.E., Civil Engineer PCRWRD Subject: S.E.C. 1ST ST. & NORRIS AVE. Dev. Plan - 1st Submittal D10-0035 The Pima County Regional Wastewater Reclamation Department (PCRWRD) has reviewed the proposed sewer collection lines for the above-referenced project. The following comments are offered for your use: 1. Obtain a letter from the PCRWRD's Development Liaison Unit, written within the past year, stating that treatment and conveyance system capacity for the project is available in the downstream public sewerage system and provide a copy of that letter to this office. The required form to request such a letter may be found at: http://www.pima.gov/wwm/developer.htm#permits The development plan for this project cannot be approved until a copy of this letter has been received by this office. 2. Sheet 2: Add a General Note that states: THIS PROJECT WILL HAVE ______ EXISTING AND______ PROPOSED WASTEWATER FIXTURE UNIT EQUIVALENTS PER TABLE 13.20.045(E)(1) IN PIMA COUNTY CODE 13.20.045(E). 3. The development plan submitted is significantly deficient. No sewer (private/public/proposed or existing) has been shown on plan. Refer to Pima County Development Services "Development Plan Review, Checklist Requirements" section J. WASTEWATER, for submittal requirements. The checklist is available at; http://www.pimaxpress.com/SubDivision/Documents/DevPlanReq.pdf This office will require a revised set of bluelines, and a response letter, addressing these comments. Additional comments may be made during the review of these documents. Pima County Code Title 13.20.030.A.2 requires that a wastewater review fee be paid for each submittal of the development plan. The fee for the first submittal is $166 plus $50 per sheet. For the second submittal, the review fee is $50 per sheet. For all subsequent submittals, the review fee is $39 per sheet. The next submittal of this project will be the second(2nd) submittal. A check for the review fee of this submittal in the amount of $50.00 (made out to PIMA COUNTY TREASURER) must accompany the revised set of bluelines and response letter. If the number of sheets changes, please adjust the review fee accordingly. If you have any questions about this review letter please call me @ the phone number below. ______________________________ Tom Porter, Sr. CEA, (520)740-6719 PCRWRD cc: Chad Amateau, PE Kristin Borer, PE, DLU Manager DLU Project folder |
| 11/01/2010 | STEVE SHIELDS | ZONING | REVIEW | Denied | CDRC TRANSMITTAL TO: Development Services Department Plans Coordination Office FROM: Steve Shields Lead Planner PROJECT: 1st Street and Norris Avenue Development Package (1st Review) D10-0035 TRANSMITTAL DATE: October 27 DUE DATE: November 04, 2010 DEVELOPMENT PLAN COMMENTS: Please resubmit revised drawings along a response letter, which states how all Zoning Review Section comments regarding the Land Use Code and Development Standards were addressed. 1. Section 5.3.8.2, LUC, permits a maximum of one year from the date of application to obtain approval of a development package. If, at the end of that time, the development package has not been approved, it must be revised to be in compliance with all regulations in effect at that time, and must be resubmitted for a full CDRC review. The one-year expiration date for this development plan is October 06, 2011. 2. This site plan was reviewed for compliance with the City of Tucson Development Standards (D.S.) and Land Use Code (LUC) for full code compliance for the entire site. 3. This project comprises two (2) parcels and as a structure is proposed to be built across the property boundary the parcels must be combined. Provide a copy of the approved Pima County Combination Request form with your next submittal. The Following comments are based on Development Standard 2-01.0 & LUC Section 3.6.1. 1. D.S. 2-01.2.7 The north arrow, contour interval, and scale as applicable to each sheet should be placed together in the upper right corner of each sheet. 2. D.S. 2-01.3.1 The name, mailing and email addresses, and phone number of the primary property owner of the site, the developer of the project, registrant(s), and other person(s), firm(s), or organization(s) that prepared the development package documents shall be provided on the right half of the cover sheet. 3. D.S. 2-01.3.2.D Provide the administrative street address within the title block. 4. D.S. 2-01.3.3 Provide the development package number D10-0035 near the title block on all sheets. 5. D.S. 2-01.3.4.C. Provide the Section, Township and Range, and north area for the project-location map. 6. D.S. 2-01.3.7.A.4 Identify the existing and proposed use of the property as classified per the Land Use Code. List all Land Use Code sections each proposed use is subject to. The existing use should be listed as "FAMILY DWELLING "K", SUBJECT TO: SEC. 3.5.7.1.F" and the proposed use should be listed as "FAMILY DWELLING "FLD-6", SUBJECT TO: THE DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS IN SEC. 3.6.1 AND SEC. 3.5.7.1.F" 7. D.S. 2-01.3.7.A.5 As a general note list the total number of units/lots proposed. 8. D.S. 2-01.3.7.A.5 & LUC Section 3.6.1.4.E & F The provided "Allowed units per acre:" shown under "SITE DATE" is not correct. Per LUC Section 3.2.3.1.F Flexible Lot Development (FLD) Density Matrix, FLD Designator "FLD-6, Development Alternative "B" the Allowable Density is twenty-two (22) units per acre. Based on a total site area of 15,248 sq. ft / 43560 = 0.35 acres X 22 = 7 units allowed, proposed is 6. Revised the density calculation to show the allowed and provided. 9. D.S. 2-01.3.7.A.9.b & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.E The site coverage calculation does not appear to be correct. Based on the total given under "Proposed New Structures" of 6,751 sq ft / 15,248 the site coverage would be 44.3 %. It does not appear that this calculation includes the vehicle use area, pavement, shown south of the proposed garage. For your information for calculating site coverage it is the area of a building within the outside edges of the exterior walls at ground level (design grade), not second floor, that is used, see LUC Section 3.2.9.2. 10. D.S. 2-01.3.8.B If applicable all existing easement shall be drawn on the plan. The recordation information, location, width, and purpose of all easements on site will be stated. 11. D.S. 2-01.3.8.C The following information regarding existing private or public right-of-way adjacent to or within the site shall be provided: the name, right-of-way width, recordation data, 12. type and dimensioned width of paving, curbs, curb cuts, and sidewalks. 13. D.S. 2-01.3.9.H.5.a Fully dimension the proposed parking spaces within the garage. 14. D.S. 2-01.3.9.H.5.a & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.F.2 Per LUC Section 3.6.1.5.F.2 An alley abutting an existing development shall not be used for parking access. That said a Board of Adjustment for Variance is required for the alley access to the proposed garages. 15. D.S. 2-01.3.9.H.5.a The proposed provided vehicle parking does not meet the requirement of LUC Section 3.3.4. RESIDENTIAL USE GROUP, Multifamily Dwellings 0-70 units/acre. Based on the number of bedrooms in each unit ten (10) vehicle parking spaces area required, eight (8) provided. A Board of Adjustment for Variance is required to reduce the number of vehicle parking spaces. 16. D.S. 2-01.3.9.H.5.d The proposed bicycle parking calculation is not correct. Per LUC Section 3.3.3.5 The number of required bicycle parking spaces is calculated as a percentage of the total number of motor vehicle parking spaces provided. If the calculated number of required bicycle 17. parking spaces is less than two (2), the minimum number of required spaces is two (2). That said the number of required bicycle parking spaces is two (2). 18. D.S. 2-01.3.9.H.5.d Show the location of the required bicycle parking and provide a detail that addresses all requirements of D.S. 2-09.0. 19. D.S. 2-01.3.9.L If applicable all proposed easements (utility, sewer, drainage, access, etc.) are to be dimensioned and labeled as to their purposes and whether they will be public or private. 20. D.S. 2-01.3.9.O & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.C.1 As this is full code compliance for the entire site provide perimeter yard setback dimension from all existing structures along the east property line. It appears that the two (2) existing structures will not meet perimeter yard setbacks and will require a Board of Adjustment for Variance. 21. D.S. 2-01.3.9.O & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.C.1 The proposed 9'-0" perimeter yard setback shown from the propose garage does not meet the requirements of LUC 3.2.6.4. The minimum perimeter yard for the proposed project is based on the development designator FLD-6, Perimeter Yard Indicator "BB" adjacent to R-2 zoned property is 10 or ¾ of the exterior building wall, which ever is greatest. A Board of Adjustment for Variance is required. 22. D.S. 2-01.3.9.O & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.C.2 There is what appears to be a street perimeter yard setback line shown along the north end of the west parcel. This line is not shown correctly. Per LUC Section 3.2.6.5.A the front street perimeter yard is twenty (20) feet or one and one-half (1 1/2) the height of the proposed wall (H), measured from the street property line, whichever is greater. Remove the street perimeter yard setback line from the plan and provide a street perimeter yard setback dimension from each structure along the north and west property line. 23. D.S. 2-01.3.9.O & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.C.2 The provided cross section does not match what is shown on the plan, please clarify. 24. D.S. 2-01.3.9.R & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.G.2 Provide width dimensions for all existing and proposed sidewalks on the plan. Per D.S. 2-08.5.1 All sidewalks will be a minimum four (4) feet wide. 25. D.S. 2-01.3.9.R & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.G.3 & D.S. 2-08.4.1 At least one (1) sidewalk will be provided to project from each street on which the project has frontage. Provide a sidewalk the connect from the proposed site to the proposed sidewalk shown in the right-of-way (ROW) along Norris Avenue. 26. D.S. 2-01.3.9.R The sidewalk area around the proposed "COOKING GRILL UNIT" does not appear to meet the minimum width requirements for a sidewalk. Provide a fully dimensioned detail for this area. 27. D.S. 2-01.3.9.T Show refuse collection areas, including locations of dumpsters, screening location and materials, and vehicle maneuverability, fully dimensioned, and access route. 28. If dumpster service is not proposed, indicate type of service. 29. D.S. 2-01.3.9.X & LUC Section 3.6.1.5.B.5 Provide a note on the plan stating "ALL MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT, UTILITY BOXES, IRRIGATION EQUIPMENT AND SIMILAR ELEMENTS SHALL BE SCREENED FROM ADJACENT STREETS EXTERIOR TO THE PROJECT AND FROM ADJACENT EXISTING RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT. SCREENING SHALL BE ARCHITECTURALLY INTEGRATED WITH THE OVERALL DESIGN OF THE FLD.". 30. LUC Section 3.6.1.5.B.6 Clearly indicate on the plan how the requires of LUC Section 3.6.1.5.B.6 are met. Depending on how the above comments are addressed addition comments may be forth coming. If you have any questions about this transmittal, please Steve Shields, (520) 837-4956 or Steve.Shields@tucsonaz.com Sshield1 on DS1/planning/New Development Package/ D10-0035 RESUBMITTAL OF THE FOLLOWING IS REQUIRED: Revised development package.. |
| 11/02/2010 | RONALD BROWN | ZONING HC | REVIEW | Denied | 1. Insure Compliance with Inclusive Home Design Ordinance 10463. Provide a new general note referencing to that effect. a. Do not add these notes to drawing THE DEVELOPER SHOULD BE AWARE OF THE FOLLOWING: b. As per Section 1003.2, Provide at least one accessible entrance on an accessible route from public areas. c. Reference Section 103.1, Wavier of Provisions in this Standard. 2. Any additional pedestrarian access ways from public right of ways as required by Zoning are to be accessible. Reference Zoning comments. END OF REVIEW |
| 11/03/2010 | BIANCA RAMIREZ | ENGINEERING | REVIEW | Denied | DATE: November 3, 2010 SUBJECT: Development Plan Review TO: Bramic Design Group LOCATION: 1st Street / Norris Ave, T14S, R14E, Section 8, Ward 6 REVIEWERS: Bianca Ramirez, CFM ACTIVITY: D10-0035 (First Review) RESUBMITTAL REQUIRED: Development Plan SUMMARY: Engineering Division of Development Services Department has received and reviewed the proposed development plan for the above referenced property. Engineering Division does not recommend approval of the development plan at this time. Please address the following review comments prior to the next submittal. Please include a response letter to the comments along with the corrected copies of the development plan. Development Plan: 1. .Per 2-05.2.1.A - Please ensure that future submittals have engineers stamp located within ½ inch margin, required for all sides of the sheet. 2. The most recent aerial photo of the building does not match what is depicted on the development plan. Please provide documentation to support lot combination or modify development plan to represent actual footprint(s) of building(s) and lot(s) and/or clarify. 3. .Per 2-05.2.1.D.2 - Within location map identify within the square mile area, major streets, specifically identify 6th Street and Tucson Blvd. 4. Per 2-05.2.1.D.3 - Provide Section, Township, and Range and label section 8, within location map. In addition, add north arrow to location map. 5. Per 2-05.2.1.H - Provide contour interval to development plan (together with north arrow and scale). 6. Per 2-05.2.1.J - Please provide legend that shows and describes all symbols used in the drawing. 7. Per 2-05.2.1.K - Verify that any applicable rezoning, annexation, or subdivision case numbers are listed in the lower right hand corner, next to the title block. 8. Per 2-05.2.2.A.1 - List the names, addresses and telephone numbers of the primary property owner of the site and developer of the project. 9. Per 2-05.2.2.A.2 - Please list the name and telephone number of the person that prepared the development plan. 10. Per 2-05.2.2.B.2 - Provide the proposed use of the property. 11. Per 2-05.2.2.B.11 - List the gross area of the site by square footage and acreage 12. Per 2-05.2.2.C.1.a - Within Drainage Note 1, revise herein to "hereon" and add comma following now and in the future. 13. Per 2-05.2.2.C.1.b.- Within Drainage Note 2, revise palan to read "plan". 14. Per 2-05.2.2.D.2 - List the following note on all development plans, "No structure of vegetation shall be located or maintained so as to interfere with the sight visibility triangles in accordance with Development Standard 3-01.0. 15. Per 2-05.2.2.F.4 - Please revise not to include "except public sewers within public sewer easements or right of way,". 16. DS Sec.2-02.2.3.A:- Provide lot numbers for each property line, specifically north and south dimensions that do not appear to be labeled on plan. 17. DS Sec.2-02.2.3.B - Verify that all easements have been drawn on the plan; be sure to include recordation information, location, width, and purpose of easement. 18. DS Sec.2-02.2.3.C - Provide the existing and future right of way dimension and label appropriately. Include recordation data, street type (Local), and provide dimensions for width of paving, curbs, curb cuts and sidewalks. Along with dimension from street monument lines to existing and proposed curbs, sidewalks, driveways, and utility lines 19. DS Sec.2-02.2.3.E - Indicate the ground elevation on site based on City of Tucson Datum (indicate City of Tucson field book number and page). DS Sec.2-02.2.3.E.1 - For land less than one (1) percent, contour lines shall be drawn at intervals of not more than one (1) foot. DS Sec.2-02.2.3.E.2 - For land that slopes between approximately one (1) percent and five (5) percent, , contour lines shall be drawn at intervals of not more than two (1) feet. 20. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.D - Indicate if existing streets are public or private, provide widths, curbs, sidewalks and utility locations, all fully dimensioned. 21. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.K - Show onsite pedestrian circulation as required by the Land Use Code (LUC) utilizing location and design criteria in Development Standard 2-08.0. Ensure that sidewalks are constructed to conform to set development standards. 22. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.L - Show existing and proposed sidewalks along abutting right-of-way. Ensure that such sidewalks are in compliance with set accessibility requirements for the physically disabled. 23. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.R - Label existing and future sight visibility triangles 24. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.S.- Show fire circulation, including accessibility and vehicle maneuverability. 25. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.T Show refuse collection area, including location of dumpsters, screening locations, size, materials, and vehicle maneuverability, fully dimensioned. 26. DS Sec.2-02.2.4.W - Indicate location and types of any proposed signs. 27. Show all fences, walls, or vegetation for screening and sight visibility by type, material, height, location and spacing per D.S. 2-02.2.1.27. 28. Show Development plan number on all sheets per D.S. 2-02.2.1.29. 29. DS Sec.2-02.2.1.A.8: Provide typical parking space detail for parking areas. Provide parking dimensions, note and depict parking details for both standard and handicap parking, together with access thereto. See DS Sec. 3-05.2.0.B.1 for minimum parking standards. Including but not limited to parking spaces located within garage. 30. Any alley abutting an existing development is not to be used for access to parking. 31. Unable to interpret Cross-Section 1, please revise to reflect building being depicted within development plan. 32. Development Keynotes to be revised 3. Indicate height of curbing 4. PAAL is not to be accessed from an alley, especially not an unpaved one. 5. Revise leader to point to structure and not garage door for clarification. 6. Provide width of garage door (single car). 7. Provide detail for concrete slab and indicate thickness of slab. 8. Provide height of existing chain link fence 9. Correct leaders - conflicting with keynote 10. 10. Correct leaders - conflicting with keynote 9. 11. Provide width of existing sidewalk. 12. Unable to locate keynote 12, please provide width and specify what's to be upgraded. 13. Provide height of curbing and specify whether to remain or be removed. 14. Provide width of sidewalk 15. Specify height of exiting fence to be removed and provide type and height of new fencing be used to replace the old fencing. 16. Provide height of existing fence. 17. Change "o" to "to" and ensure design selected allows for minimum pedestrian access. Keynote 17 appears to be incorrectly pointing to sidewalk near proposed new single family unit, please clarify. 21. Provide appropriate COT Detail number. 22. Provide appropriate detail reference numbers. 33. Additional Comments may be forthcoming. If you have any questions, I can be reached at 837-4928 or Bianca.Ramirez@tucsonaz.gov Bianca C. Ramirez, CFM Engineering Associate City of Tucson/Development Services Department 201 N. Stone Avenue P.O. Box 27210 Tucson, Arizona 85726-7210 (520) 837-4928 office (520) 879-8010 fax |
| 11/04/2010 | JOHN BEALL | COT NON-DSD | COMMUNITY PLANNING | Denied | CDRC Review Planning and Development Services Dept., Community Planning Review D10-0035, 1st Street & Norris Ave., 1st submittal Comments Due: 11/4/10 Comments Submitted: 11/4/10 Items reviewed: Development Plan, Landscape Plan Proposal and Need for Land Use Plan Compliance: This proposal is to add a new, 1600-square-foot, 3-bedroom, 2-story residential unit on the southern portion of an exiting lot that already has two residential units on it. The subject lot will be combined with the adjacent lot to the west, which has three residential units on it, to form a 0.35-acre site. Because the proposed density would be approximately 17 units per acre (6 units/0.35 acre), the applicant is proposing to use the Flexible Lot Development option (FLD-6) option in the R-2 zone. As per the Land Use Code (LUC) Section 3.6.1.4.A, FLD proposals need to conform with the General Plan and its components, or in this case is the Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan (SHNP). Land Use Plan Policy Summary: Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan Policy Summary: A goal of the Land Use Policies is to maintain the quiet, single-family residential character of the neighborhood. Land Use Policy 1.1.8 restricts access for higher-density residential development (over 6 units/acre) to major streets. Policy 1.1.9 requires that all Code-required parking be located on-site, and 1.1.10 recommends against the granting of parking variances. Policy 2 promotes preserving the unique diversity and character of the neighborhood's historic and architectural value. Policy 2.1 requires that the architectural design of new construction be compatible with, and complementary to the design of structures along the surrounding block frontage. Transportation Policy 5 promotes upgrading alleys in the neighborhood, for vehicular access and parking. General Plan Policy Summary: Element 2, Supporting Policy 2.1 encourages housing … adjacent to regional activity centers to … minimize auto use and air pollution. Land Use Policy 3 protects established residential neighborhoods by supporting compatible development. Supporting Policy 3.4 supports urban character residential development (15 or more units/acre) along arterial streets or adjacent to community and regional activity centers and major employment sites. Policy 6.13 supports incentives for development in or adjacent to regional activity centers that will encourage infilling of vacant or underutilized parcels adjacent to activity nodes. Action 6.13.A is to consider incentives, including density bonuses and parking reductions, to expedite activity center infill. Element 4, Policy 5 promotes neighborhood identity and visual character. Supporting Policy 5.3 supports infill projects that reflect sensitivity to site and neighborhood conditions and adhere to relevant site and architectural design guidelines. Supporting Policy 5.5 promotes upgrades to neighborhood infrastructure, including sidewalks, and improvements to the existing housing stock. Policy 6 promotes quality in design for all new development. Assessment: The development site is one block southeast of Speedway Boulevard and Campbell Avenue, at the southeast corner of 1st Street and Norris Avenue. It's one block east of the University of Arizona (UA), which is a regional activity center; and it's on the edge of the Sam Hughes residential neighborhood. Surrounding residential uses include a mix of single-family residences and interspersed, multi-family units. Several lots in the vicinity are developed with more than one residential unit. For example, there may be a main house and a guest house on a lot, or two or more residential units, which can be either free-standing or attached. The site itself is developed with five single-story, casita-style units, including three on the western parcel and two on the eastern parcel. The southern-most portion of the eastern parcel is vacant, and that's where the applicant wants to construct a sixth unit, which would be two-story. South of the residential units is a dirt parking area that's accessed from an east-west alley that runs between Norris Avenue to the west and Olsen Avenue to the east. Parking is also available on First Street and Norris Avenue, adjacent to the site. Surrounding Uses: The surrounding properties are all zoned R-2. To the east is a single-story, single-family home. To the south, across the alley, is a single-story fourplex on two adjoining parcels. To the west, across Norris Avenue, and to the north, across First Street, are single-story, single-family homes. Consistency with Land Use Plan Policies: The Sam Hughes Neighborhood Plan was adopted in September 1985, while the General Plan became effective in November 2001. When there's conflicting policy direction, staff typically looks to the most specific plan for the area, which would be the neighborhood plan. However, in this case, we consider the policy direction from both plans, because the General Plan policy direction regarding activity centers is more current. If new development can be implemented compatibly with the surrounding land uses, the General Plan policies support urban character residential development (15 or more units per acre) adjacent to regional activity centers and major employment sites, to promote opportunities for people to live near where they work or go to school, i.e., the UA. Compatibility - Although the surrounding residences are single-story, staff believes the proposed two-story unit can be designed to be compatible with the surrounding residences. The plans indicate that there will be no balconies or windows on the second story, on the east-and north-facing sides. Clerestory windows on the second floor would preserve neighbors' privacy, yet also allow natural light into the rooms. Staff defers to the Design Examiner's review regarding privacy issues. While most of the neighborhood is single-story, there are scattered two-story residential units throughout, so another two-story unit would add visual variety but not be considered unusual. Parking - SHNP policies require that all Code-required parking be provided onsite, and recommend against the granting of parking variances. The plans indicate eight parking spaces inside a new garage, to be constructed on the south edge of the site, north of the alley; and use of on-street parking, for which a variance will be needed. Over the past couple of years, the Mayor and Council have directed staff to provide some relief for parking requirements, and there have been Land Use Code amendments to that effect. Also, it is being increasingly recognized that public streets are an under-utilized resource for parking. Current planning trends call for being more flexible and creative with respect to satisfying parking requirements, especially near activity centers. The addition of a new 3-bedroom unit could generate an additional three cars, and possibly a visitor or two. Parking should be easily accommodated on the street, adjacent to the site, and should not create any adverse effects for neighbors. General Plan policies support considering incentives, including parking reductions, to expedite infill near activity centers, and this proposal is consistent with that policy direction. SHNP policies also support upgrading alleys for vehicular and parking use, and this proposal is also consistent with that policy direction. Neighborhood Character/Architectural Design - SHNP policies promote new development that is architecturally compatible with or complementary to the design of structures on the surrounding block frontage. Dimensioned elevations should be provided with the next submittal to demonstrate compliance with this policy, as well as photos of the existing development on the site and in the surrounding neighborhood. Summary/Comments: This proposal is to add a new two-story residential unit to an existing, 5-unit casita-style development, one block east of the UA. Because the General Plan (2001) policy direction for activity centers is more current than that in the SHNP (1985), staff considered the policy direction in both, and this proposal is consistent with the General Plan policy direction. Also, direction from the Mayor and Council over the past two years to relax parking requirements where reasonable was considered, as it's more current than the policy direction in the SHNP, which recommends against the granting of parking variances, and it's consistent with General Plan policy direction adjacent to activity centers. The following comments are offered: 1) Dimensioned elevations of the proposed residential unit, and photographs of the existing development on the site and surrounding areas, must be provided with the next submittal, to demonstrate architectural consistency with existing development in the area. 2) Staff defers to the Design Examiner's review regarding privacy issues. 3) A resubmittal is required. Reviewed by: J. Hershenhorn, 11/4/10 F:\Shardir\UPDfiles\Development Review\CASE_REVIEW\CDRC\2010 Cases\D10-0035.doc |
| 11/04/2010 | ADAM SMITH | DESIGN EXAMINER | REVIEW | Denied | D10-0035 1st Street & Norris Avenue: Development Plan Adam Smith’s Comments Functional Open Space Provide a note on the plan consistent with Sec. 3.6.1.7 (Management of Common Properties). Reconcile the functional open space calculations. The Development Plan Keynotes section states 1,400 sf of functional open space is provided. The FLD Alternative B 20% additional open space calc section states 1,159 sf. Provide a note stating that barrier free access will be provided to the functional open space amenities consistent with Sec. 3.6.1.5.G.5. There are several misspellings in the Development Plan Keynotes section. Please revise as follows: 17. New patio area with ramada as style to be determined 18. New bench seating area (2) 19. New cooking grill unit 23. 1,400 s.f. functional open space Privacy Mitigation (Sec. 3.6.1.5.A.2) 1. The privacy mitigation note for the proposed new 2-story unit is overly restrictive. Consider amending to read: “On the east facing elevation of the proposed two-story unit, balconies are prohibited and the upper floor windows shall be either clerestory or translucent.” 2. Provided a dimensioned elevation drawing. |
| 11/04/2010 | ADAM SMITH | DESIGN EXAMINER | REVIEW | Denied | James A. Gresham, FAIA 3654 North Cactus Boulevard Tucson, AZ 85716 520.795.0871(h) 520.975.0202(c) jagresham@gmail.com November 4, 2010 D10-0035FIrst Street and Norris Development Plan Attn: COT Planning and Development Services Department Patricia Gehlen Adam Smith John Beal Following are comments from the City of Tucson Design Professional Re: D10-0035 Sec. 3.6.1.5.A.2 Privacy Mitigation The privacy mitigation measures for the new 2-story unit should be documented with either a drawing, description or both. Respectfully submitted, James A. Gresham, FAIA COT Design Professional ÿ |
| 11/05/2010 | ROBERT YOUNG | PIMA COUNTY | PIMA CTY - DEV REVIEW | Passed | |
| 11/05/2010 | JOE LINVILLE | LANDSCAPE | REVIEW | Denied | 1) Add the CDRC case number and any related case numbers to the landscape plans. DS 2-07.2.1.B 2) Fences or walls constructed in a single continuous line shall extend into a street landscape border no more than the actual width of the fence or wall. Where a fence or wall incorporates offsets or similar design features, a screen may extend a maximum of three (3) feet into the street landscape border. Revise the plans address the screen wall location reuquirements along Norris Ave. 3) Trees are required every forty feet along pedestrian pathways. Revise the plans to show trees along the internal circulations system. LUC 3.6.1.5.B 4) Grading, hydrology, and landscape structural plans are to be integrated to make maximum use of site storm water runoff for supplemental on-site irrigation purposes. The landscape plan shall indicate use of all runoff, from individual catch basins around single trees to basins accepting flow from an entire vehicular use area or roof area. Revise the plans to define water harvesting areas and areas of the site that contribute runoff.. Include drainage arrows and show curb or wall openings. LUC 3.7.4.3.B 5) Provide details on proposed walls. If a perimeter wall is proposed along a public right-of-way, it shall be constructed of, or painted with, graffiti-resistant materials. The wall shall incorporate one or more of the following decorative materials: a. tile; b. stone; c. brick; d. adobe; e. a textured material such as stucco or plaster; or f. metal. LUC 3.6.1.5.B.6 6) Plant Cover/Dust Control. All disturbed, grubbed, graded, or bladed areas not otherwise improved shall be landscaped, reseeded, or treated with an inorganic or organic ground cover to help reduce dust pollution. Revise the plans to call out ground plane dust control treatments for the site and adjacent right of way areas. LUC 3.7.2.7, LUC 3.7.2.4.A.4 7) Revise the required number of trees in the landscape calculation for Norris Blvd. 1 tree is required for every 33 feet. LUC 3.7.2.4 8) Revise the plans to meet the vegetative coverage requirements for Norris Ave. LUC 3.7.2.4.A.5 |
| 11/05/2010 | PGEHLEN1 | OTHER AGENCIES | PIMA ASSN OF GOVTS | Passed | |
| 11/05/2010 | PGEHLEN1 | TUCSON WATER NEW AREA DEVELOPMENT | REVIEW | Approved | |
| 11/05/2010 | JANE DUARTE | COT NON-DSD | PARKS & RECREATION | Approved | |
| 11/05/2010 | PGEHLEN1 | OTHER AGENCIES | TUCSON AIRPORT AUTHORITY | Passed | |
| 11/08/2010 | FRODRIG2 | ENV SVCS | REVIEW | Denied | Date: November 4, 2010 Due Date Case Number Project Address November 4, 2010 D10-0035 1st Street & Norris Avenue DEVELOPMENT PLAN Comments: Denied, The proposed Development Plan for the 1st Street and Norris Avenue, Case No.D10-0035. Dose not meets the minimum requirements for the Environmental Services, Solid Waste Disposal Standard 6-01.The Plan must show that enclosures for both Solid Waste and Recycle collection. 1. All containers shown on the Development Plan must be labeled for the intended us being Solid Waste or Recycle materials 2. A Detail of the container enclosures must be shown on the plans clearly showing that the minimum inside dimension between the bollards shall be less than 10'- 0". As shown on the Solid Waste Standards. 3. All enclosures must show the gates installed and mounted to the end on the CMU screen wall as show on Solid Waste Standards. Also the size of containers proposed to be use must be noted on the plans. 4. The proposed development plan to be location at 1st Street and Norris Avenue, must state the development physical address on title block of each sheet of the proposed plans Environmental Services Department Development Plan Review Reviewer: Tony Teran Office Phone (520) 837-3706 E-mail: Tony.Teran @tucsonaz.gov |
| 11/09/2010 | JOSE ORTIZ | COT NON-DSD | TRAFFIC | Denied | November 9, 2010 ACTIVITY NUMBER: D10-0035 PROJECT NAME: 1st-Norris Ave PROJECT ADDRESS: 2000 E 1ST ST PROJECT REVIEWER: Jose E. Ortiz PE, Traffic Engineer Resubmittal Required: Traffic Engineering does not recommend approval of the Development Plan; therefore a revised Development Plan is required for re-submittal. The following items must be revised or added to the development plan. Include a response letter with the next submittal that states how all comments have been addressed. 1. Provide asphalt pavement improvements to the alley along the entire frontage of the proposed site. 2. A permit or a private improvement agreement will be necessary for any work performed within the Right-of-way. Contact Permits and Codes at (520) 791-5100 for permit information. If you have any questions, I can be reached at 837-6730 or Jose.Ortiz@tucsonaz.gov |
| 11/10/2010 | JOHN WILLIAMS | ZONING-DECISION LETTER | REVIEW | Denied | COMMUNITY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES November 10, 2010 Gene Goldstein Bramic Design Group 6255 N. Camino Pimeria Alta # 136 Tucson, Arizona 85718 Subject: D10-0035 1st STREET & NORRIS AVENUE Development Plan Dear Gene: Your submittal of October 7, 2010 for the above project has been reviewed by the Community Design Review Committee and the comments reflect the outstanding requirements which need to be addressed before approval is granted. Please review the comments carefully. Once you have addressed all of the comments, please submit the following revised documents and a set of 12 DETAILED cover letters explaining how each outstanding requirement has been addressed: ALL BLACKLINES MUST BE FOLDED 12 Copies Revised Development Plan (Addressing, Wastewater, Zoning, HC Site, Engineering, Planning, Design Examiner (2), Landscape, Env Svcs, Traffic, PDSD) 7 Copies Revised Landscape Plan (Zoning, Engineering, Planning, Design Examiner (2), Landscape, PDSD) 4 Copies Dimensioned Elevations (Planning, Design Examiner (2), PDSD) 2 Copies Photographs of Development/Surroundings (Planning, PDSD) 2 Copies Pima County Combo Request Documentation (Zoning, PDSD) 1 Copy Full Digital set of plans & elevations on 300dpi Tiff CD (PDSD) Should you have any questions, please call me at 837-4893. Sincerely, John Williams Planning Technician All comments for this case are available on our website at http://www.ci.tucson.az.us/dsd/ Via fax: N/A |
| 11/10/2010 | LIZA CASTILLO | UTILITIES | TUCSON ELECTRIC POWER | Approv-Cond | 4350 E. Irvington Road, Tucson, AZ 85714 Post Office Box 711, Tucson, AZ 85702 WR#230832 November 10, 2010 Bramic Design Group Attn: Gene Goldstein 6255 N Cam. Pimeria Alta #136 Tucson, Arizona 85718 Dear Gene Goldstein : SUBJECT: 1st and Norris D10-0035 Tucson Electric Power Company has reviewed and approved the development plan submitted November 2, 2010. It appears that service drop to 2006 & 2008 will be in conflict with the new building. Enclosed is a copy of a TEP facilities map showing the approximate location of the existing facilities. Any relocation costs will be billable to the customer. In order to apply for electric service, call the New Construction Department at (520) 918-8300. Submit a final set of plans including approved site, electrical load, paving off-site improvements and irrigation plans, if available include a CD with the AutoCAD version of the plans. If easements are required, they will be secured by separate instrument. Your final plans should be sent to: Tucson Electric Power Company Attn: Mr. Ricahrd Harrington New Business Project Manager P. O. Box 711 (DB-101) Tucson, AZ 85702 520-917-8726 Should you have any technical questions, please call the area Designer Mike Kaiser at (520) 918-8244. Sincerely, Elizabeth Miranda Office Support Specialist Design/Build lm Enclosures cc: DSD_CDRC@tucsonaz.gov, City of Tucson (email) M. Kaiser, Tucson Electric Power |